Most Helpful Customer Reviews
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The last part is the best part-- a real jewel, November 23, 2008
Sarah Hoyt's trilogy about an alternate reality world, in which Charlemagne had a flunky steal two magic jewels from an idol in Darkest Africa and gave himself and his descendants magical powers comes to a smashing conclusion in Heart and Soul.
Having retrieved the Heart of Fire and the Soul of Fire, the principals must now return them to the African idol from which they came, and set the world right again.
We meet an unknowing earl, who threw away his priviledged life for love, an evil dragon, an evil tiger, some loyal foxes and a wild trip through the Chinese underworld where justice and mercy are tempered with fine good humor.
And in the end...well, you're just going to have to read the book for the ending.
Sarah Hoyt's writing just gets better with every book.
Walt Boyes
Associate Editor
Jim Baen's Universe
www.baens-universe.com
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
All too short a resolution, May 25, 2009
Heart and Soul is a romance set, as described by others, in an alternate history. It is the third in a series, resolving a quest to return two gems of magical power to their home in Africa.
The story alternates between various viewpoint characters, skipping from China to Cape Town to Hong Kong, then into various points within China, as well as into the Chinese afterlife. It may, in fact, move far too quickly and easily between various points -- making trips that would be long and difficult on modern jetliners into quick and relatively effortless flights for the major characters, diminishing a sense of scale for the world.
The resolution of the story comes far too quickly. It seems to be building to an epic confrontation between Oldhall, Red Jade, Jade's brother Wen, and Wen's Third Wife, vs. Zhang and his British allies, but the confrontation fizzles anticlimatically and is followed by a series of seemingly pro-forma short chapters resolving the various romantic plots and the fate of the gems. Those who have followed the series for the past two books may be disappointed with how quickly and easily everything seems to neatly wrap up.
For a romance, the relationships between Wen and Third Wife, and between Oldhall and Jade seem surprisingly uncomplicated and lack much tension. It seems clear where things will end up, and it is just a matter of getting past the obstacles thrown up by the plot.
In short, read it for an interesting setting and the journey into the Chinese afterlife, but not as much for the plot or any depth of character.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
superb urban historical fantasy, November 1, 2008
Charlemagne stole the ruby the Soul of Fire from its avatar shrine in the heart of Africa; he used it to bind the world's magic to him and his descendents. Nigel Oldhall was to obtain the rubies and turn them over to his boss, but learns instead the worlds are splitting out from this earth until eventually the realms implode. Nigel changes his mission to return the rubies to their rightful original locations in order to save the world he knows.
Before he can complete his quest, Zhang, the second in command to the True Emperor of All Under Heaven, steals one of the precious gems because he wants to be the new ruler instead of Wen, an opium addict. Wen depends on his sister Red Jade to rule behind the scenes. Jade and Wen's third wife known as the Third Lady go on separate missions to save the Chinese throne from the usurpers. Whereas Third Lady escorts Wen to the underworld to fight to regain his power stolen by Zhang, Jade goes after the rubies disguised as a dragon. When she and Nigel encounter one another, they each realize the mission has morphed out of control as has their hearts.
In the Hoyt vision of the Victorian Age, magic is controlled by the nobles of Europe; aging Queen Victoria wants to use the rubies to regain her youth and to bind the world's magic to her and her legitimate offspring. Originally Nigel was doing her bidding, but he concludes the rubies need to return to their proper place even if magic trickles down to the commoners; to do otherwise could destroy the earth. Nigel has grown since he started his quest) see SOUL OF FIRE and HEART OF LIGHT), but like Jade is unable to reveal his deepest regard for her (or him in her case). Sarah A. Hoyt delivers a first class urban historical fantasy filled with HEART AND SOUL.
Harriet Klausner
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|