Amazon.com Review
Willie Steinberg, the protagonist of
Heart and Soul, a book for ages 12 and older, is a promising 17-year-old cellist and composer who's left her arty school in Philadelphia for a long, lousy summer in Virginia with her hapless mother. Her father is home most of the time and Willie hangs around a lot; the stifling heat of Richmond often doesn't allow for more. But she also involves herself with friends confronting their entry into adulthood. As Willie looks for the inspiration to write a symphony, she sinks lower into what could be called depression. Yet nothing is so clear in
Heart and Soul as a clinical description; there's just the unsightly gray of teenage lament.
Gr. 8^-12. The consummate self-conscious outsider, Willie is having an identity crisis that has plummeted her into depression. Neither parent is much help: her dad is never home, and her mother seems barely able to take care of herself. It is only when Willie reluctantly becomes involved in helping prickly, troubled Malachi, a Jewish schoolmate with a chip on his shoulder, that she is able to see a clear path for herself. The first-person narrative, by turns vague and inspired, plunges readers into Willie's melancholy and confusion, but it's really Malachi who is the novel's strongest character. He is as much (perhaps even more) an outsider as Willie, and his prickly personality makes for some explosive scenes. This is an ambitious book, with many themes vying for attention--parent-child relationships, divorce, religious and class prejudice, self-esteem. But because most of them remain only partly developed, it will be patient readers who will be this novel's best audience.
Stephanie Zvirin
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.