19 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
I wanted to like this book . . . Really!, December 17, 2010
This review is from: Heartless (Tales of Goldstone Wood) (Paperback)
I was completely turned off by Una, the princess and main character. She was whiny, temperamental, cowardly, not very intelligent (as she makes one bad choice after another), and was just generally very difficult to like. I couldn't find many reasons why the brave, virtuous Prince would pursue her to the ends of the earth. Also, new characters were introduced at various points when they didn't seem essential to the story; sometimes it just muddled the story and made it more confusing. I also agree with a couple of other reviewers about the constantly changing dialogue (old English at one point, and modern slang the next). Overall it was an interesting premise, but didn't have enough substance to hold it all together cohesively.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A New Fairytale, Worthy of the Classics, June 24, 2011
Original review on Book Whispers.
Genre: YA Fantasy (Classic Fairy Tale)
Fairytales are the timeless joy of the fantasy genre. Readers thrive off of them, whether it's retellings or variations of our favorite stories. What gets readers into more of a frenzy then the classic Fairytale? Why, an original tale that is clearly worthy of the classics. That is exactly what Heartless is.
The beauty of Stengl's writing style will please fantasy fans who hunger for the kind of quality found in Robin McKinley's books. For those who find McKinley's style too harsh and a bit hard to sink into, Stengl's softer style will be a relief. The landscapes just flow up majestically and the emotions that consume the reader make the characters feel real. The story and plot sweeps across the page with a timeless grace.
Una is definitely a classic fairytale Princess. She needs to be rescued, and there are enough warnings given to her before hand that she shouldn't have fallen victim. Then again--that's life--everyone has bitten and choked on the apple at some point. Una's downfall is of the heart, a modern and historic story of how someone can give their heart to the wrong person. In Una's case it's a terrible price she pays for the nativity of her emotions. Unlike the classic princess, Una is strong and willful. She has enough spirit to make up her own mind, and in the end find redemption--even learning from her mistakes. (Of course Prince Charming still get to ride in and save the day.)
Dragons never quite get the attention they deserve in most fairytales. In Heartless the Dragon(s) finally get that time to shine--even if they are quite the villains. Anne has created a dragon mythology that sent my head spinning into giddiness. They're like vampires in the aspect that they must be invited into a dwelling, and that they can turn other humans into dragons. It's breath taking, and terrifying, all at the same time. Heartless is such a tease as it reveals enough to get you there, but enough is left out to keep you crawling after the next book!
This is a win-win for Fairytale lovers! Dragon lovers will be smitten by the new mythology of the dragon. Princess Una will frustrate readers with the paroles of love, and have readers rooting for her (or wanting to smack her upside the head). This book deals with the modern day heartbreak on a grander scale only a Fairytale can exploit. The ending is just as practical and sweet as a Happily Ever After should be, so HEA readers should feel content. Keep an eye out for more by this author as there's more world--and dragons--to enchant readers.
Sexual Content: Really clean. A few kissing scenes, some blushing, and some very vague sexual humor. Definitely good for the kiddies.
Rating: 4/5- Great! Really enjoyed it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
My favorite read for 2010!, June 19, 2010
This review is from: Heartless (Tales of Goldstone Wood) (Paperback)
Congratulations to Ms. Stengl on a very promising debut! As a huge fan of Shanon Hale and Megan Whalen Turner's style of fiction, I was so impressed with the craftsmanship of this new fantasy! I am usually a critic of both style and content, but this young adult fiction will top my list of recommendations this year. In a market too often glutted with pulp fiction of mediocre writing (are you reading this Ms. Meyer?), this is a breath of fresh air! I can't wait for the next one!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No