Customer Reviews

Hearts and Minds (The Criterion Collection)

5 star:		(35)
4 star:		(8)
3 star:		(6)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(3)

 

 

The images from Hearts and Minds are disturbingly heartbreaking and grotesque. For example, a naked little girl is shown running down a road with skin pealing off her body as napalm continues to eat into her flesh. American soldiers watch the girl running by them, until it seems as if the camera that is capturing the moment urges the soldiers to help the girl. A Viet Cong suspect is shot point blank in the head on the street and his body falls to the ground with blood pulsating out of his temple. A child cries in agony by the grave of someone close to him while the grave diggers take a break with a cool Coca Cola. These unsettling scenes slowly descend into some unused space of the brain as they will return to consciousness in order to haunt the viewer of the horrors of the Vietnam War at a later time.

Peter Davis had accumulated over 200 hours of footage before beginning the long process of editing down the film into a feasible 112 minutes. During these 112 minutes the audience gets to follow how the American mindset which is created from young age, and how it influenced the decisions of the war. Davis brings the audience to a high school football game where young minds are formed into believing that what they do is right and that they have to win at all costs. Similar mentality saturates the thinking behind the American decision makers as President Lyndon B. Johnson increased the American participation in the war, to which he stated, "The ultimate victory will depend on the hearts and minds of the people who actually live out there." The President's statement also became the title for the film.

The Vietnamese people, whose living standards were and are much different from the typical American lifestyle, fought for independence and freedom while the United States fought against the fear of Communism. This political and fundamental difference in perceiving the war was monumental as Communism, in essence, become the liberator for the Vietnamese people, and the Americans were perceived as the evil invaders. Most Vietnamese were opposed to the American's, as most people in Vietnam are poor, and those who promoted the so-called Americanism of Vietnam were war profiteers and people in high positions. The war continued into a dirty slaughter of civilians and children through dropping millions of bombs, spraying the herbicide Agent Orange, burning villages to the ground, and killing suspect Viet Cong as the American soldiers were in constant fear of being shot in the back.

Interesting comments were made by several characters such as General Westmoreland who said that "the Oriental doesn't put the same high price on life as does the Westerner." This followed by a shot of a child weeping in misery by a grave, which brings across the message of the ignorance that some of the leading military staff possessed. However, General Westmoreland continued to make derogatory comments about the Vietnamese people and continued to come across as a bigot and a racist.

Hearts and Minds was initially delayed in the United States for a year as a result of the distributors, Columbia, being afraid of legal repercussions. However, the film went on to win the Oscar for Best Documentary Feature in 1975, and the Oscar's positive appraisal of Hearts and Minds led to a massive controversy. Nonetheless, Hearts and Minds message was out as it was the biggest documentary of the time with a million dollar budget.

Ultimately, the audience will have traveled a rough cinematic journey, which could be summed up by Daniel Ellsworth's quote "We weren't on the wrong side -- we were the wrong side." This notion is offered through several perspectives while viewing the horrors of war, as families were destroyed, children burnt to unidentifiable lumps of meat, and men wished they were home with their loved ones. Hearts and Minds provides the audience several interesting notions to ponder, but the most vivid idea would be that war should be avoided at all costs as people are mutilated and die on all sides.

It's interesting that so many of those who have reviewed this film have included information about when and where they first saw it. But I understand. In 1974 we had cowardly withdrawn our promised assistance to our Vietnamese "friends." The riots had stopped. We stopped caring about a war that continued unabated; the evening news no longer led with stories of American vs. "bad guy" bodycounts. I saw the film in a theater located on one of the very streets where the most bottles had been thrown by students and other youth, and where the most heads had been bashed by Seattle's finest (gee, some things never change!) When the film ended there was absolute silence: no one spoke; no one moved from their seat; it seemed no one even breathed. After almost a minute you could finally hear some muffled sobs only. There were, and are, no words to express the darkness of men's souls; there is only art. And, besides being a good documentary on the Vietnam war,
(by "good" I mean it will anger both sides, and provoke much conversation and debate,) this film is art, of the most important kind.
A late-blooming "child of the 60's" I am oft-dismayed that more recent generations neither know nor value the cultural icons of our youth, many of which I still hold dear. But the single most true thing about our generation was growing up in the shadow of a news machine that fed us war and hate on a daily basis. A shadow that was sometimes our own hatred, and sometimes our fear of oncoming nuclear missles (which fortunately never came,) or the fear of a loved one in a body bag.

Please watch this film. You'll gain a better understanding, not just of part of the war, but of a part of the soul of America . . .my part.

This is, without doubt, one of the best, most memorable movies I have ever seen. It has stuck with me since I first saw it as part of a high school film-making course in in Ottawa, Canada in 1975. It was the first, last and only time I ever saw it and I remember it all vividly 25 years later. At the time it exposed me to the absolute evils and sickening realities of a modern war for really the first time. It's lack of narrative adds a peculiar realism that I have never seen repeated in a documentary or fiction work. So controversial was the picture that at the 1974 Oscars, the Academy of Motion Picture Sciences convinced the late Frank Sinatra to go on stage after it won best documentary to tell the audience the movie's award victory did not mean the Academy supported the movie's avowed anti-Vietnam War tone and tenor. The move by the Academy was unprecedented -- and has never been repeated. This movie must be re-issued. It is an outstanding testiment to the power of film.

To start off, the "criticism" that this film is "too one-sided" or has "an agenda", demonstrates a lack of understanding of what a documentary is and does. Documentary filmmakers ALL have agendas; they have a point-of-view and must engage viewers emotionally or they fail in their task.

I saw "Hearts and Minds" in college in about 1977. The campus auditorium was packed with mostly sympathetic "liberal" college students, with the exception of about half a dozen uniformed military clearly present to ridicule the film and voice their opposition. As has been mentioned in other reviews, a stunned silence gripped the room at the end of the film, as the parade clown shouting "Come on! Smile! Get happy!" pranced into the fade-out at the end of the credits. The only sound was the audible sobbing coming from the military protesters. We as an audience stayed to talk to them and to help them deal with the emotions they were experiencing. It was one of the most amazing experiences I've ever had at a movie. It forever burned the power of film into my mind.

Of course, the filmmakers have an anti-war agenda. Of course, the film is harshly critical of a government that, in its view, sent a generation off to an un-winnable war and basically forgot about them and the horrific experience they endured. The film is compassionate and caring about the soldiers in the Vietnam war while being unmerciful in its presentation of the politicians and upper-echelon bureaucrats who perpetuated the war. ("Are you really asking me this goddamn silly question, Mr. Davis?" asks presidential advisor Walt Rostow, almost rolling his eyes, when asked to explain the origins of the Vietnam conflict. This embarrassing, pompous moment might have been edited out of a less courageous film, but director Peter Davis is taking no prisoners.)

The portraits here of heroes, victims, villains and cads, are incisive and powerful. An earlier reviewer criticized the film for using the interviews with the parents of a deceased soldier. The parents are proud of their son, proud of President Nixon (even though an on-screen disclaimer notes that these comments were made pre-Watergate) and seemingly proud of the way he died. They have clearly chosen to be a part of the film voluntarily, so when the mother breaks down at a fond memory of her son, the audience does not feel pity, but rather great compassion for these good people who have been lied to, and whose son died for the lie.

Of course, a film could be made to show the noble intentions of our involvement in the war (or you could just rent the John Wayne movie "The Green Berets"), but it is fairly universally granted that the Vietnam War was a tragic, shameful episode in American history. This film, made and released at the moment of America's withdrawal from Vietnam at a time when support for the war was at its lowest, captures that feeling of depression and anger. It is a film of its time and should not be criticized for that.

Neither should it be missed.

As a Vietnam Veteran undergraduate in Illinois our Vets Club rented this movie for a Vietnam Symposiom in April of 1975. Both Francis Fitzgerald and Walt Rostow were speakers and we showed "Hearts & Minds" as an introduction to this two day event. The great ironry is that it was the same week that Siagon fell which brought an ironic closer to this event that we had spent six months planning.

This academy award winning film still weighs heavy in my mind both for its content and the events under which we viewed it. It is essential that any person attempting to bring sense to the War in Vietnam view this film. The owner of its video rights have a moral obligation to let American citizens watch this film.

This is by far the most affecting film about war I have ever seen. I have read extensively about Vietnam, and although I am too young to remember the state of the country while it was immersed in the conflict, I have always been drawn to its stories and lessons. The narrative voice of this documentary is absorbing, yet not dogmatic. I don't want to over-intellectualize this film and run the risk of taking away any of its power to affect me. Simply put, I feel every American should view it. The lessons it exposes are completely relevant to what this country is supposed to be about, and what it actually is. I'm a ninth-grade American History teacher, and I lament the fact that I would be risking my job by showing this- especially given the events of 9-11-01 (and since) which have unfortunately had the effect of disenfranchising honest inquiry into the methods and motivations of our political leaders. Please do whatever you can to get your hands on it and your mind around it.

Basically a documentary of the Vietnam War's impact on humanity. Interviews with senior officials and servicemen, as well as political goons of the era. This is one of the most interesting, disturbing and powerful views of the war. The interviews with pilots who saw themselves as "technicians" doing their job and marines who only wanted to "kill gooks" but then realized that they were in fact killing human beings, Heart's and Minds is as intense as it is historically important. If you want to understand humanity and war better, don't miss. ...

I had the opportunity to be with one of the angry young warriors featured in this documentary when he was hurt on June 29, 1966. It is amazing to watch him as this documentary played out, and to then realize that after that difficult period, this angry young African American amputee became a parent of five, and a counselor for a generation of youth from the inner city of Detroit. The experience of all who made the walk in Vietnam was life-changing and often truly traumatic. However, one should pause and reflect - where did they all go afterwards? In the case of William Marshall, he overcame his anger (or at least recognized his anger and put it to constructive work) and became a great asset to the city of Detroit. As you watch this great film, I would challenge you to realize that some are able to use these tragedies to recover, rebuild and pass on personal character, and obviously, some are not. It has been 31-plus years since Charlie Morris (deceased Medal of Honor winner from that same day) along with 41 other young men including myself, walked and fought with William; but it is people like him who make America an interesting mix of people and greatness. I wonder where all the other hurt and angry young warriors from this doumentary went in their own journies after Vietnam. And I also wonder where the children in Vietnam went in their journey through life - such as the very young boy saying goodbye to his father. Truly a thought-provoking walk down a memory lane.

An anonymous warrior from A Company, 2nd Battalion, 173d Airborne Brigade - 1966

I don't know what the viewer from Tallahassees' problem is. Somehow they think that seeing people murdered in Vietnam is OK but, a couple of GI's in a Saigon whore house is the obscene part that nobody should watch. Obviously, this person spent no time in the 'nam. Enough said about that. This is a great documentary about the American involvement in Vietnam as whole. It does have that dovish anti-war feeling to it. But, let's face it, the place was simply murder on an industrial scale. The only way our leaders thought we could win the war was to kill almost everybody. This film shows that in graphic detail. This film is not for the faint of heart. But, I highly recommend it to those that want a slight glimpse of reality.

Peter Davis's 1974 documentary about the causes and effects of America's Vietnam War has been digitized and reissued after 25 years, and it is an invaluable touchstone for each of us.

Using war footage, newsreels, clips from Hollywood films, and interviews with officials, soldiers and Vietnamese, ex-CBS journalist Peter Davis and his team present a sobering view of American arrogance, misguided policy and dishonest government. (Sound like anything you've heard lately?)

Some of the most memorable scenes for me are: General Westmoreland's comment that the "Orientals" don't value life the same way we do, right after we see a Vietnamese boy mourning at his father's funeral; a Vietnamese coffin maker hammering nails into a child's coffin; Daniel Ellsberg, on trial at the time for releasing the Pentagon Papers, listing the lies told to the American people by five presidents -- Truman, Eisenhower, Kennedy, Johnson and Nixon; Charlie and Jerry, bored Air Force men cruising Saigon for entertainment; fitting prosthetic limbs onto veterans; Clark Clifford, Secretary of Defense from 1968-69, discussing the interviews that suddenly made him realize that the war could not be won; a father talking about how his son died for a worthwhile cause as his wife looks on. Shocking, also, is the revelation that the US offered France TWO ATOMIC BOMBS to use in their war with Indochina (later Vietnam)!! This film is heartbreaking and poignant, capturing the tragedy of lives caught up in madness.

Davis used interviews from people who supported or fought in the war; some later came to oppose the action while others continued to support it. A wonderful extra feature would have been to talk to those same interviewees today; instead, the only dvd extra is the director's commentary, but it is terrific. You hear what Davis's thoughts were in making the documentary and how his own perceptions changed over the years, the material he did get and the material he wasn't allowed to use, experiences he had during filming and the problems he had getting it released.

If you have this film on vhs or remember seeing it, you will love this crisp new print and enjoy Davis's insightful comments. If you have never seen it, you simply must. While this documentary doesn't have the benefit of hindsight, it does have the advantage of immediacy, being shot and released while the war was still being fought. The message: no one wins a war.