Hegel: Three Studies (Studies in Contemporary German Social Thought) [Paperback]

Theodor W. Adorno (Author), Shierry Weber Nicholsen (Translator)

Book Description

Series: Studies in Contemporary German Social Thought | Publication Date: September 29, 1994

This short masterwork in twentieth-century philosophy provides both a major reinterpretation of Hegel and insight into the evolution of Adorno's critical theory. The first study focuses on the relationship of reason, the individual, and society in Hegel, defending him against the criticism that he was merely an apologist for bourgeois society. The second study examines the experiential content of Hegel's idealism, considering the notion of experience in relation to immediacy, empirical reality, science, and society. The third study, "Skoteinos," is an unusual and fascinating essay in which Adorno lays out his thoughts on understanding Hegel. In his reflections, which spring from his experience teaching at the Goethe University in Frankfurt, questions of textual and philosophical interpretation are intertwined.Rescuing the truth value of Hegel's work is a recurring theme of the critical theory of the Frankfurt School, and nowhere is this goal pursued with more insight than in these three studies. The core problem Adorno sets for himself is how to read Hegel in a way that comprehends both the work and its historical context, thereby allowing conclusions to be drawn that may seem on the surface to be exactly opposed to what Hegel wrote but that are, nevertheless, valid as the present truth of the work. It is the elaboration of this method of interpretation, a negative dialectic, that was Adorno's underlying goal.Adorno's efforts to salvage the contemporaneity of Hegel's thought form part of his response to the increasingly tight net of social control in the aftermath of World War II. In this, his work is related to the very different attempts to undermine reified thinking undertaken by the various French theorists. The continued development of what Adorno called "the administered world" has only increased the relevance of his efforts.

Editorial Reviews

Language Notes

Text: English (translation)
Original Language: German --This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.

Product Details

• Paperback: 204 pages
• Publisher: The MIT Press (September 29, 1994)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 0262510804
• ISBN-13: 978-0262510806
• Product Dimensions: 8 x 5.3 x 0.5 inches
• Shipping Weight: 9.6 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
• Average Customer Review: 5.0 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (1 customer review)
• Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #623,622 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)

More About the Author

Discover books, learn about writers, read author blogs, and more.

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars Consciousness and experience, January 15, 2009

By 

Justin Evans (Chicago, USA) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   

This review is from: Hegel: Three Studies (Studies in Contemporary German Social Thought) (Paperback)

A book by one of the more difficult to understand thinkers of the 20th century about by far the most difficult to understand philosopher of the 19th century is obviously not a browse over breakfast affair. The good news is that for readers of either man, this is actually quite engaging. But really, it's only for those already acquainted with the whole range of jargon they use. If you don't have the time or inclination to absorb it, your time would be better spent with Marcuse or McDowell. No shame in that.

Because of all this, I suspect that the readership of Hegel: Three Studies is quite small, which is a shame. Any reader will come away disabused of two common beliefs: first, that Hegel is merely a reactionary totalitarian stooge; second, that Adorno is a fierce critic of German Idealism. The former has been put paid to by recent Hegel scholarship, but often at the price of re-enforcing the latter. So, despite the efforts of Brandom, McDowell, Pippin etc... to salvage Hegel's reputation, I can still heartily recommend this book, both as a corrective to bad readings of Hegel, and, still more, as a corrective to bad readings of Adorno.

The book itself comprises three essays. The first is by far the best. 'Aspects of Hegel's Philosophy' lays out the key element of Hegel's thought: the complete mediation of objectivity by the subject, which leads not to relativism, but to a more robust theory of truth than correspondence theories can provide. This is because only complete mediation can make the object normative for the subject; that is, only by mediating it fully can the subject cease to be alienated from the object. This would seem to give rise to the Subject as All Devouring Maw. But Adorno argues that Hegel's own theory makes it impossible to reduce the object to the subject, despite what he may have wished: an absolute subject would deny the very possibility of objective normativity. This contradiction within Hegel's philosophy points us toward the context for the thinking, and this will be perhaps the most difficult part of the book for pure philosophers. Adorno's quasi-Marxism is very difficult to get a handle on (I recommend Lukacs' "History and Class Consciousness" essay as a companion piece here, although it is substantially less sympathetic towards Hegel), but is essential for understanding his reading of Hegel. In short, modern capitalism makes possible freedom from nature's domination, but in turns 'naturalizes' what was previously cultural: that is, we come to see our social institutions as natural and unalterable. In this situation, 'facts' which could be overcome (e.g., world hunger) are taken as logically necessary, as given. Hegel is correct to see the existence of a subjective absolute, but wrong to argue that it is *our* subjective absolute. Rather, it is a 'second nature' which must itself be overcome. Adorno argues that the truth of Hegel's system is that it is inconsistent - the State becomes the ultimate guarantor of the absolute, but the State is treated as a given, as alienated from us. Hegel's discomfort with this position points us out of the system as he has described it.
All this yields the conclusion that for Hegel, truth is not ontological, but it is objective; that truth is historical, but not relativist; that the concept is mimetic, but also more than mimetic; and that Hegel is a kind of rationalist utopian who criticizes the Subject on the basis of what it could be: the condition for the freedom of subjects.

The second essay, 'The Experiential Content of Hegel's Philosophy,' is more uneven. It repeats many of the themes from 'Aspects,' while giving a more robust account of Hegel's critique of positivism, and the problems of this critique. The concept of 'totality' gets a pretty bad press these days, but Adorno makes a convincing case that we can't do without it: no meaningful critique of our world can proceed without acknowledging that our world just is a totality. At the same time, to merely affirm the totality is insufficient, as our experience of the world tells us. We experience contradiction when we sense that the whole is systematic but irrational.

The final essay, 'Skoteinos,' is a guide to reading Hegel, which isn't particularly helpful on that score. It does, however, provide some insight into Adorno's conception of philosophy itself, and argues against the prevalent practices that go under that name (positivist neuro-philosophy; Wittgensteinians etc...). Adorno's final position on reading Hegel is that a true reading will remain dialectical - insist on a tension between concept and object - whereas Hegel understood himself as abandoning the dialectic by identifying concept and object.

In short, if you're among the many people who have rejected the Hegelian tradition in favor of some version of post-structuralism, you might like to check this out. I'd like to think it's enough to change your mind.