From School Library Journal
Grade 3-6-This biography tells Keller's story in a readable, sometimes fictionalized narrative and busy, colorful page layouts. On each spread, the main text appears on the left, while the opposite page consists of a visually appealing collage of black-and-white, full-color, and tinted photos and interesting tidbits set against a pastel background. MacLeod includes many well-known facts about Keller's life as well as a few less-familiar details. The controversy over her story, "The Frost King," which she wrote at age 11 and was accused of plagiarizing, is mentioned but not dwelled upon. Overall, the portrayal of Keller and her teacher, Annie Sullivan, is very complimentary. The illustrations include a sample of Keller's handwriting and charts that demonstrate sign language and Braille. The book ends with a detailed time line, a useful index, and a list of places to visit. This offering is livelier than Deborah Kent's Helen Keller: Author and Advocate for the Disabled (The Child's World, 2003) and better suited to reluctant readers.
Donna Cardon, Provo City Library, UTCopyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
Gr. 3-5. As with other books in the Snapshots: Images of People and Places in History series, the scrapbooklike design invites kids right into the life of a famous person. Here, in carefully captioned, black-and-white images, attractively cropped and organized on the page, children receive a glimpse of "America's First Lady of Courage" and the people and places that figured prominently in her life. Each double-page spread comprises one page of text and a multiphoto collage. Like the illustrations, MacLeod's commentary is a collection of bits and pieces about Keller, smoothly integrated to reveal the struggle, the sadness, and the success Keller experienced over the years. This seems tailor-made for browsing; kids will definitely come away wanting to know more. Steer them to Keller's own writings or to in-depth biographies such as Laurie Lawlor's
Helen Keller: Rebellious Spirit (2001) or Joan Dash's
The World at Her Fingertips (2002). Unfortunately, there are no sources here, although an extensive time line gives kids a good overview.
Stephanie ZvirinCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.