Most Helpful Customer Reviews
27 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An interesting read, December 7, 1999
I've long been a reader of books on Helen Keller. As a deaf person and an educator who uses her words in my own life and teachings, I feel it is important to know the person I am talking about. I often use Helen Keller as an example to others with disabilities whom I teach, and this book is a useful addition to my library. My only reason for giving it a four and not a five star rating is Dorothy Herrmann speculates quite a bit about the thoughts and feeling of two women who lived over 75 years ago. Much of their private lives has been speculated about, but we cannot know the truth about these matters when they are no longer here to tell us. I also get the feeling the author is a bit of a Freudian psychologist, and allows this to influence her writings of the people surrounding Helen and Annie. Sometimes, innocence is just innocence and there is no need to make it salacious for the public. Is it so hard to believe that some people are just innately good? Many of the things that happened to Helen Keller were typical of the lives of women at that point. I see it in the geneaological work in my own family. Women didn't have a lot of choices, and women with disabilities had absolutely none. However, Helen was one of those people who brought out the best in others, and the protective qualities in men. As a deaf person who has both men and women for friends who are protective of me, I can understand teasing in letters which have no negative connotation of any kind. I am married, but these friends still look out for me. Both my husband and me understand why they do this and feel this way, and it is sweet, with nothing in it that has an underlying meaning. I think we can look at the relationships of Helen with most men that way, rather than assuming the worst on either side. Otherwise, the book is very well written, and certainly extremely readable in comparison to other biographies about Helen Keller.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
21 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
BEYOND THE WATER PUMP, November 12, 2000
Helen Keller calls the day she understood the basic concept of language was that all things have names "her soul's birthday." Helen herself says that "Teacher," the name Annie Sullivan insisted Helen use for her literally led her out of a dark silent world and into one where communication was possible. Many works on Ms. Keller seem to get stuck on the now famous scene at the water pump when Annie spells "water" into Helen's outstretched hand. This author, to her credit, provides a rich source of information and introduces the readers at large to Helen the student, Helen the writer, Helen the adult and Helen as one third of a strange triadic relationship when her beloved "Teacher" marries a gifted editor named John Macy. Helen and Annie had a rather symbiotic relationship and this was never made more apparent than when other educators as well as Helen's mother tried to prize them apart. John Macy, Annie's long suffering husband tired of having to include Helen in every aspect of his married life and felt that Annie was making Helen "more of an institution than a woman." He further charged Annie with being a self serving promotor and felt that Helen was being exploited. This work does indeed raise some very interesting ideas. Annie does indeed have a punitive streak, no doubt influenced by her abusive, alcoholic father and the lost years she spent in the alms-house. The alms-house was, by all accounts a genuine Chamber of Horrors and no provisions were made for children. Annie survived the gritty horrors, including the death of her beloved baby brother, Jimmie. Hardened and determined after years of battling poor vision due to trachoma, she makes a fine academic showing at the Perkins School for the Blind prior to her assignment with Helen. During the early part of their symbiotic relationship, Annie would slap Helen into submission. The now infamous Battle Over Breakfast was a case in point. Annie slapped Helen each time the child tried to take food off Annie's plate. She also slapped Helen each time she pinched her in rage. Annie would use similar exacting methods on Helen in later years. When Helen learned to type, Annie would have her redo a page many times until it was picture perfect. Indeed, this too, presented problems in Annie's marriage. When she and John Macy split, the letters he received from "Helen" had hand written corrections and were rife with expressions that were plainly Annie's. One can only speculate that John was correct in his assessment of Helen being exploited to a certain extent. This book takes into account Helen's concept of spirituality and her fascination with Swedenborgianism, a faith rooted in "a perfect afterlife where nobody is handicapped." Helen clings to this faith and later to an especially inflammatory branch of Socialism. She becomes quite political and writes numerous articles expressing her beliefs. In so doing, Helen remains fixed in the public eye as the Crusader for persons both deaf and blind. This is truly an excellent biography that explores the sensual side of Helen, the spiritual, the political and the personal make up of this quite extraordinary woman. It is a refreshing trip far down the road that leads the readers way beyond the water pump.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Very insightful...with a couple of minor caveats or nitpicks, June 30, 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: Helen Keller: A Life (Hardcover)
Briefly, I give the book a fairly high rating, because it offered much more detailed and new information than ever provided before in anything else I had read about Helen Keller. It is very well-researched and almost uniformly highly readable (very little dry stuff). It gives a harrowing account of Annie Sullivan's nightmarish childhood (and difficult and demanding personality throughout her adulthood) than was every really hinted at in other works, or in "The Miracle Worker"). That gives even more insight on how these two people interacted for so many years together. It also gives much information on Helen's sometimes naive and leftist/pacifist/near anarchist political philsophies (strongly developed by conversion to Swedenborgian). It also gives an insightful analysis of what Helen's family relationship was really like. If you've ever been on the house tour in Tuscumbia, AL, this stuff is sugar-coated and glossed over. While on some levels one can understand why, one is really mislead about what her life there was really like. Not to mention the true nature of her family. Captain Keller is just not the Civil War hero he had been made out to be, and her mother was very difficult throughout her life. And had she not suffered from scarlet fever and its aftermath, Helen would have been a Southern Belle through and through. She was very beautiful (despite the eye deformities), and her life would have been such that she would have been expected to marry well and live as much of a life of leisure as possible. I had no idea that Ms. Keller was essentially an invalid (and virtually suffered from dementia) for at least the last 6 years of her life. Not much information is provided about the end of her life. Not to be morbid or focus on the potentially lurid, I was left wondering what her caretakers had to do and what their experiences were, as well as Miss Keller's. All things said, this is a really essential book if you are interested in a fascinating life of an extraordinary woman. I look forward to the new Laura Bridgman book that just came out (6/01). She figures in the book fairly prominently. Annie Sullivan had a reasonably close relationship with her (although Miss Bridgman was much older--born in 1829--and died at the age of 59).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|