16 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An excellent work., April 29, 2006
The book is up to Ms Hughes usual high standard. It discusses Helen in the context of the Bronze Age (including Homer) and how she has been regarded throughout history. The discussion about the Bronze Age and the Trojan War era is particularly thorough and reveals a great deal of knowledge about this little known time. For example when discussing (some) women's high status in the bronze age she points out that the Lion Gate Lions at Mycenae are in fact lionesses. The book is also interesting and entertaining and does not necessarily require some knowledge of the subject.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
30 of 34 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A FUN, INFORMATIVE READ, April 14, 2006
This is popular history. This work is not a history text. The reader needs to keep this in mind when starting this work. The author, in my opinion has done more than an excellent job. Her prose alone make the book worth the read. Granted, there is much speculation in this work, but if you read the author's comments, she is the first to point this fact out. That being said, with what we know today, and the author has done an amazing job of gathering her facts, then much of the life of Helen must be speculation. The author has given us this although I would choose the words "educated speculation" in the case of this work. I enjoyed ever word of it, learned a lot and was stimulated to read other works. What more could I ask for? Not only do we get a speculative look at a shadowy figure, but we get an excellent look at bronze age history. The author's discription of present day sights is absolutely wonderful and makes one want to travel.
As a side note, after years and years of reading and the study of history, I have found that an expert in the field of history does not absolutely have to have a worn tweed jacket,gray beard and monotone speech to know his or her subject.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
25 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Good Attempt to Reconstruct the Bronze Age, February 19, 2006
Troy has always fascinated people and the "cause" of the Trojan war, the Spartan princess Helen, is now perhaps only second to Cleopatra in the modern iconography of ancient women. Indeed, while we are not even sure that a real Helen existed, there certainly was a Troy and a Sparta, and their histories, although now obscured by the mists of time and lack of contemporary written record, had to have been quite turbulent. Through the writings of Homer and others, Helen has come down to us as intelligent, obviously beautiful, and as either victim or schemer, goddess or mortal, violated virgin or whore. In any case something very bad happened to Troy around the projected time of Helen's life, even if she really did not exist.
Bettany Hughes in her lengthy (458 pp)"Helen of Troy: Goddess, Princess, Whore" has covered the background of this period. Helen is part of a complex Greek mythology based on the early history of ancient Greece (including Magna Grecia - Modern Turkey, Crete, Cyprus etc.) The house of Atreus and the Tyndareids make modern dysfunctional families look tame, with cannibalism, incest, murder, torture, congress with gods, etc. commonplace. While Hughes concentrates on the story of Helen, these various behaviors occasionally come through, especially in regard to the murder of Agamaemnon by Clytemnestra, Helen's half sister, and Orestes subsequent murder of his mother and her lover, and later of Helen herself (if the later was not wafted up to Olympus as Apollo is said to have done.)
While Hughes certainly jazzes up the story a bit here and there(not exactly necessary as the story is pretty juicy from the word go) she presents a lot of very interesting material on the Trojan War (the later unfortunately made into a recent movie that somehow took a really fascinating story and made it boring!) and of Helen as an icon of that war.
I recommend this book as a solid, if sometimes speculative, summary of the life and times of Helen of Troy and the effect that her legend has had on the world's collective imagination.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No