2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Gospels in a mirror, February 4, 2011
This review is from: The Heliand: The Saxon Gospel (Paperback)
My husband is an artist and to check his painting, he looks at it in a mirror because he can see problems that are invisible when you look at it the regular way. I found the Heliand to be like that.
My original aim was to see how distorted the message was to the Saxons. It is distorted, but I found it to be extremely powerful for that very reason. It makes you think. When Mary wraps the infant in clothes and precious jewels, it makes you stop short. It couldn't have been like that. But it should have been; Jesus was that precious. I loved the poetic images like the meadows of heaven. And there is great joy and feeling in the telling that are pretty well missing from the traditional gospels. This is a story told by a master storyteller.
We are almost as far removed from the warrior society of the Saxons as we are from the even more distant world of Jesus. Reading the story transposed from one culture to another makes you look at the changes and think about what is important and what is just details. Like looking at your painting through a mirror.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Outstanding glimpse of religion in a specific culture, January 11, 2011
This review is from: The Heliand: The Saxon Gospel (Paperback)
I loved this book. As an Saxon history buff, this book opened a wonderful new portal into their lives and cultures. The author's notes are not intrusive, in the way that some academic footnotes can be. They enlighten and enliven the text. The translation is clean, clear, whimsical and readable.
Highly recommended for historical reference, as well as for church groups or bible study. I plan to use it with my high school classes.
Well done, Father Murphy!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An Important Fossil in the Evolution of Christianity, February 8, 2008
This review is from: The Heliand: The Saxon Gospel (Paperback)
Christianity has not been as uniform and unchanging as many American evangelicals want to believe. People have notions of "primitive" Christianity before the transformation of the Church under the Roman Emperor Constantine, and protestants of all demoninations are well aware that their religion underwent drastic changes in the era of the so-called Reformation. These days, many are also aware of the Gnostic alternative that competed with orthodox Christianity for centuries. Likewise, most American Christians have a vague awareness that Coptic, Armenian, Greek, and Russian Orthodoxy all maintain uncomfortably different doctrines. But, unless I'm terribly mistaken, rather few devout fundamentalists are aware of the scope of alternatives in the history of Christianity, of the widespread and long-lasting "heresies" like Arianism, Donatism, the Albigensians, or the Bogomils. Then there are more recent alternatives, some of them quite drastic in their difference: Shakers, Quakers, the Kingdom of Matthias, the Latter Day Saints, the followers of Hauge in Scandinavia, the Swedenborgians, not to mention syncretic variants combining Judeo-Christian material with indigenous religious ideas in almost every country where missionaries have be active. Christianity is not a constant.
The earliest translation of the Gospel stories into a northern European language was made by a Goth named Ulfilas; the Goths were strenuous adherents to the Arian heresy. Then, in approximately 835, an anonymous East Saxon "scop", or bard, synthesized the four Gospel narratives into a single text, large portions of which have survived. Given the name "Heliand" (Savior) by later scholars, this gospel narrates the life of Jesus in the alliterative epic style familiar from Beowolf, written at least 100 years later. In the Heliand, Jesus is portrayed as a warrior chieftain, and his disciples as warrior thanes. Much of the imagery used to depict Jesus comes directly from the images of Odin, who also sacrificed himself to himself to achieve "wisdom", or magical power. But Jesus is more powerful than Odin, as portrayed by the anonymous Saxon, because while Odin will perish in Ragnarok (the End of Time), Jesus will survive. Throughout the Heliand, not only the scenery and social structure of the New Testament but also the moral standards and expectations of Christianity are carefully modified to appeal to the Germanic tribesmen. Such accomodations were ultimately effective in conversion, particularly when backed up by the logistically superior military of Charlemagne.
So what, you ask! It seems to me that a recognition of the diversity of "spiritual truths" in the history of Christianity should give the intolerant politicized fundamentalists of the USA today something to think about.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No