Most Helpful Customer Reviews
52 of 53 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Completely absurd but also (therefore?) damn good!!!, May 25, 2008
PLOT: 4 teams of different special forces units are sent on a secretive island in the middle of the pacific ocean. Their mission is to find out why all contact to soldiers and scientist on the island is lost. And they do find out the hard way. Hell Island lives up to its name and the soldiers plunge into a nightmare they could never dreamed of...
The book is indeed a quick read. Its 115 pages are printed with large letters that would enable you to read it from almost 2 meters away. Therefore the story is really narrowed down to a showdown only. As a result it is Reilly's simplest work so far and cannot be as good as e. g. "Ice Station". But it features Captain Shane M. Schofield, nicknamed "Scarecrow", again.
In general when you read a book by Reilly you cannot expect any kind of in-depth character study. And you should also be prepared for lack of logic and completely ridiculous ideas / twists / events that would turn characters like James Bond, Rambo and Triple X into poor bystanders.
Reilly's stories are like a two hour movie where you missed everything except the last action packed ten minute showdown. You will get a few lines of introduction and then all hell will break lose. A non stop roller coaster action ride till the very end.
Of course everything is exaggerated big time in his books and especially in this short story! But, hey, which of today's action movies, mafia films, sports movies, Sci Fi films, horror movies or even love stories are not ridiculous or embarrassing in parts?
Matthew Reilly was born in 1974 - young enough to be grown up with video games and action movies. I assume he still spends a lot of time with it today. At least it would explain his writing style quite well.
Most readers would probably despise Reilly for this simple, comic book writing style. But if you are out for entertainment you will always get it in his books big time!
So lean back, stop thinking about it and simply enjoy the show!!!
PS
If you are not into these kind of books then please simply walk away and don't read them instead of complaining loudly afterwards!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Reilly WOW's me yet again with a brisk--all-too-short--read, August 19, 2008
The origin of 'Hell Island' is interesting...Reilly was asked to pen a short-story/novella that would be distributed absolutely free in Australia only. He COULD have gone the route of many authors put in this situation and saved the GOOD stuff for a differnt book, but he chose the story of 'Hell Island' hoping that if he produced something really fun to read, it might spark interest in his other books. The end result is a story that--up 'til recently, was available to about only three groups of people...those who live IN Australia...those who travel TO Australia...or those who could afford to buy a copy off ebay FROM Australia.
I had the opportunity to interview Mr. Reilly not long ago, and he mentioned that he would send me a copy...I got tired of waiting, and went ahead and grabbed a copy off ebay and wouldn't you know it, RIGHT after that I discovered they had copies to buy stateside. Oh well.
The story--what can I say? If you have never read Reilly before, quite literally, you haven't got a clue just how intense his novels really are. Seriously. Nobody writes with adrenaline to the degree that the average Reilly story comes stock with. NOBODY. Before you begin reading you simply MUST prepare yourself for an over-the-top, barely believable story that moves faster than a Tomahawk attached to the Space Shuttle. However...with that said, very few authors throw as much sheer FUN into their stories as you can find in ANY of Matthew Reilly's novels, either. Sure the stories may be flat-out unbelievable, but Reilly is well aware that his stories aren't in the realm of reality...he IS fully aware that his job as a writer is to entertain his readers, and THAT is what he does and might I say he does VERY well.
'Hell Island' is another Shane 'Scarecrow' Schofield adventure, and part of me was a bit disappointed that the storyline wasn't expanded into a full-blown novel, but that's mostly due to the fact that the time in between new Reilly Books seems to be longer and longer...and, well, I was just feeling a bit selfish I suppose.
Let me wrap this up by saying this: Matthew Reilly is easily one of my top 5 favorite MUST READ authors now--and that is no small feat considering how much I read. I don't buy his books to immerse myself into events that MAY happen, I read Reilly to escape and have a great time on the edge of my seat--something he does better than every thriller author in print today--hands down. The momentum of his books is on a level literally head and shoulders above ALL authors I have ever read. Don't get me wrong, nobody's gonna award Reilly with a classical character development award for literature anytime soon...B-u-u-t, if you want a story that moves at nearly the speed of light, there isn't a writer alive who can match Reilly. And that's the truth.
PS Matthew, if you read this, I still haven't received that copy you promised me. Hint, hint.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fun, quick, but not for the younger crowd, March 27, 2010
This review is from: Hell Island (Paperback)
This is vintage Matthew Reilly - insane action, tremendous loss of life, blood, bullets, explosions, mayhem - you get the picture. The product descriptions says something about this being for all ages, but if you don't want your kids to read bad words and get all sorts of violent images into their impressionable minds, I'd say that this isn't good for pre-teens.
As always, Reilly writes like a Bruckheimer film on steroids. You have to take a deep breath after putting this down. This is kind of like a "rated M for Mature" video game without taking time for cut scenes.
I read this book in less than an hour, so it's a very quick read. It looks like a chapter book for a 10-year-old, but don't be fooled - this is not for kids. It was a lot of fun, though. Highly recommended for the "likes their action too big to be believed" crowd.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|