Customer Reviews

From Hell to Victory

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(5)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

For those who haven't yet seen this forgotten Italian-made war film (aka Contro 4 bandiere), this movie has the lovely actress Capucine in it. That alone earns the movie at least three stars! Despite the great cast and the abundant action, this movie has so many cliches and corny dialogue that you'll need a dose of Aleve just to finish it. Don't get me wrong, I've enjoyed watching this war movie ever since I was a kid, only now I see all the plot holes and flaws. I mean come on, the "German" fighter planes are nothing but British spitfires with German insignia painted on them!

The movie begins on August 24, 1939, in a Paris cafe, where six friends (George Peppard, George Hamilton, Horst Bucholz, Anny Duperey, Sam Wanamaker, and Jean Pierre Cassel) from different countries (of course) are about to be torn apart by World War Two. They vow to meet again on the next August 24, not realizing that the war would still be raging then. All six join the Allies, except the lone German in the group, Horst Bucholz. Bucholz becomes a Panzer commander and eventually fights against his former friends in the battle of Normandy in June 1944. Each of the six friends takes an active role in the war, and from the British evacuation from Dunkirk to the liberation of Paris, they stuggle to survive and keep in contact with one another. Along the way, Capucine enters the picture as a heroine who will risks everything to save Allied pilots from being captured by the cruel Gestapo.

By the liberation of Paris, however, only three of the six (I won't say which) have survived, and they share a tearful reunion in the same Paris cafe where they had vowed to return. The battles scenes have plenty of explosions, but they are extremely unrealistic. With a cast like this, though, I absolutely recommend this guilty pleasure to fans of war movies. Just don't set your standards too high! By the way, a lot of the battle scenes in this are the same scenes featured in another European war movie (Partizanska eskadrila (1979), aka "Battle of the Eagles"). Unfortunately, since both movies were released in 1979 I have no idea which movie copied from the other.

The other reviews for this film have listed most of it's major flaws. It is indeed improbable that this group of people would become such close friends, and George Hamilton as a Frenchman strains credibility as much because of his public image as for any other reason. The thing that sets this movie apart for me is that it features a really good perfomance from Sam Wanamaker and the last good role (that I am aware of) for Capucine. I realize she is an actress of limited range, but I was always fond of her and enjoyed many of her movies. Most of her later career work amounts to cameo roles in productions not worthy of any name actress let alone one with her style and class. Her character has style, grace, compassion and courage, as I would like to believe the lady did herself. If you are a Capucine fan, I recommend this movie highly.

This Italian made WWII movie is average at best. The major cast members are luminaries from the United States, France and England. The battle scenes are well-done with plenty of tanks and extras, but there is not much of a plot. The story, focusing on a group of friends from different nations who go separate ways during the war, is improbable and only dwelt one sporadically. Recommended only for WWII movie fans. The VHS from Media is of good quality.

I've Been Happy with Every Product I Received from Amazon and Their 3rd Party Vendors, Until Now!!!! Looks Like It Was Copied Off A TV Screen with an Old Camcorder! Night Scenes Were Too Dark to See at All! Cover Looks Like It Was Printed off a REALLY BAD Home Color Printer. Back Says Digitally Mastered - Widescreen Presentation - English 2.0 - Interactive Menus NONE of this was true!! Didn't fit on my screen properly had to undersize (1st time hundreds of movies on this TV, I ever had to do that) Sound was awful. Menu says play and scene selection that's it with a single picture background. Name of the company says "Trinity Home Entertainment". I think Amazon got taken by their vendor and ultimately I was the one that got screwed!!! Very disappointed!!!!! I Saw this movie when I was a kid and enjoyed it! I know it wasn't the greatest movie! This terrible copy ruined the Nostalgia for me! I won't forget that AMAZON!

esta es una gran pelicula, lastima que la copia que se nos envia este un poco borrosa, algo mal grabada...es una de las mejores peliculas que he visto con tan buenos actores, todos y cada uno de ellos ademas de muy bien hecha y un tema fabuloso, el hecho de que le de 5 estrellas a pesar de la mala gravacion....es porque es en verdad una pelicula para tenerla y poder verla repetidas veces....marta

The Script is not the best and the plot is highly improbable but the on going musical theme sort of sticks in your head. I watch the movie to listen to the theme.

I checked this out because I really like Umberto Lenzi and George Peppard. I was not disappointed, this is easily my favorite of Lenzi's WWII films. The film is about the effects of WWII on a group of friends, basically. Plenty of action and drama to keep you entertained. And George Hamilton is actually really kick ass in this, I was surprised!

The dvd ain't so hot, though. Its vhs quality but it is watchable and the sound quality is okay. Its worth picking up if you want to see a different side of Lenzi, are interested in Italian WWII films, or if you like George Peppard.

good action. good story of friends during that time period when wars did breakup friendships

The taste of vistory is so fleeting that before you get to gloat. it is in
the past tense. Relive someone's else victory and you see it for what it really is. Sure, you can celebrate your D-days and your Iwo-Jimas and your
triumph over very ill and dying soldiers at Waterloo but it is only retained subjectively in your flawed memory machine.
Speaking of flawed memory machine, hey, isn't this like the 2nd war movie
and the third Drama George Hamilton & George Peppard were in?