This book is culled from a series of Guardian newspaper columns, and represent one newspaper hack's attempts to use self-help materials to better his life. As such, it could easily have been an excuse for a truly British middle-class whinge, based on one of those mish-mash columns of semi-coherent ramblings that really tells us nothing at all, and that seems to exist between the gardening section and Sudoku in the pages of UK newspapers' weekend sections with the sole purpose of making the reader feeling slightly soiled and withered.
Thankfully, Oliver Burkeman keeps the cheap-shots largely in check, and it soon becomes very clear that the author is genuinely interested in scrutinising this material and sifting for insights. His prose is quite informal and breezy, but he does a fine job of praising the authors that he feels are not snake-oil salesman (and so
Cal Newport and
David Allen emerge relatively unscathed), whereas others who seem to promise the earth, or require massive change in the service of nebulous goals, receive something of a dressing down (
Stephen Covey and
Anthony Robbins both come in for some criticism). I think this brings up an important point- if, like me, you have been influenced by various self-help gurus over the years it might be easy to get defensive if your particular favorite life-coach or guru comes in for some flak from Burkeman, but I think it is possible to disagree with his assessment on various thinkers, and still derive some worth from this book. You should note though that author never managed to change his life substantially after all his research: one way to view this is to admire his honesty (which I do); another is to be more skeptical and ask yourself if you would trust someone to speak authoritatively about a subject that they have had no real success in.
It is important to realize that he is not the 'Richard Dawkins' of self-help skepticism and he isn't trying to debunk the whole field, although he does appeal substantially to contemporary sociological/psychological research (in this, he often parallels the equally interesting
59 Seconds and
Brain Rules). Consequently, this is a useful book for for the self-help aficionado looking to contextualise their own thinking, and also for the individual new to a field that even the most diehard self-help consumer must admit has its share of charlatans. It never takes itself too seriously, and ultimately is quite a fun read.