Most Helpful Customer Reviews
4 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
This book is a TRAVESTY., May 20, 2004
By A Customer
This review is from: Her Dream of Dreams: The Rise and Triumph of Madam C. J. Walker (Hardcover)
I am not surprised at all by the patronizing tone used by such reviewers as the person from "Houston, Texas USA" (probably a relative of Beverly Lowry) who complains that "It is a little bizarre to read reviews complaining that a second book about Madame C. J. Walker has been published. One of the measures of an individual's importance is the number of books they inspire..." The Houston reviewer continues in the same condescending tone about Alelia Bundles "whining" and asks, "Is there a rule that white guys can have a hundred books about them but Black women only get one each?" No, but thanks for your concern about black women and our history. The goal for any writer or scholar is to write a book when you have something to add to the information that is already available. It doesn't mean that you pretend that Madam Walker's biographer, her journalist great-great granddaughter Alelia Bundles, doesn't exist. The bottom line is that the definitive book on Madam C.J. Walker (On Her Own Ground: The Life and Times of Madam C.J. Walker) has already been written and Lowry has not contributed to our understanding of this pioneer. Also, to add insult to injury, she manages to cast two other black women pioneers, Ida B. Wells and Mary McLeod Bethune, as women with "skin color like milk with a little tea in it. Their noses are aquiline, and some have soft hair." Mary McLeod Bethune had light skin and soft hair? Oh, okay! Lowry finally had to admit that her description of Bethune was "exaggerated", but still insisted that brown-skinned Ida B. Wells was "lightskinned" in the the Sept-Oct 2003 issue of Black Issues Book Reviews where she admitted to other mistakes in her book. Bundles book was a bestseller and she has no reason to be "jealous" of Lowry's sloppy scholarship, which is surprising considering her other work. Even though a reviewer in the Wall Street Journal thanked Lowry for "bringing Madam Walker back to us" and marveled that it was "astonishing that her name is all but forgotten today", Madam Walker has NEVER been "forgotten" by African-Americans. The only thing that should be forgotten is this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
An Incredible Woman, May 20, 2010
I rarely give a book 5 stars, but this one deserves it. I have read a ton of biographies, auto biographies and this is one of the best I have ever read in terms of detail. Any author that will track down the census records of the subject has my admiration.
In addition, I can also recommend "The Black Rose". Having also read "On her own Ground" which is also good, "Her Dream of Dreams" is my particular preference.
I approached this book in terms of Madam's standing as a cosmetic legend, like Helena Rubenstein or Mary Kay Ash, to learn about how she went from a washer woman to owning a fablous mansion. No ordinary thing for a black woman in the early 1900's!
What sets this book apart from the others is the information about the company. As a former beauty consultant, I was fascinated by the letter that was sent out to new prospective agents, on page 349 hardback. This gives you an idea into Madam's thinking.
Quite a few biographies seem to speculate about the subject's life, especially where there's no clear information, so I found this one no different. In addition, I felt like I was going with her as she went from town to town selling her products and building her business. Her stamina was amazing.
As you can tell, this review is as much about Madam as the book.
As the other reviewer, I say read this book and make up your own mind.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
ain't no contest, May 29, 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: Her Dream of Dreams: The Rise and Triumph of Madam C. J. Walker (Hardcover)
Shouldn't the point be more along the lines of gratitude for another book on Madame that we have for history? I'm more inclined to agree with what the Kirkus Reviews articulated about Lowry's book: "impeccable research informs a prose that sings, whirls, and delights." I speak as both an educator and a person of color: I would never neglect reading this book in favor of Bundles' book; read both, decide for yourself. Maybe you'll be inspired to write the third, who knows? (As for holding Lowry's account as inaccurate because she isn't African American herself--I don't think that kind of ideology is really going to get us anywhere. Honestly, do you?) Peace!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|