22 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fresh Insights into Conducting and the Nazi Era, December 10, 2000
This review is from: Herbert Von Karajan: A Life in Music (Hardcover)
Classical music lovers and those who are interested in understanding more about the Nazi era in Germany and Austria will find this book to be a very rewarding experience.
HERBERT VON KARAJAN -- A Life in Music provides an unusually multidimensional biography of the conductor. Author Richard Osborne takes us through the famous and not-so-famous concert halls in the world, visiting the natural intrigues that exist in the musical world, examining the role of the Nazi Party in Germany within the musical establishment, detailing the life of a civilian in Germany during the Nazi years, and developing an evolving story of creativity from the podium and from the musical director's perspective. The sweep and detail of his portrayal of von Karajan are imposing and fascinatng, as the man himself was.
....
.... The story of the music and the man are both much more unusual and important than I had reason to hope for. Mr. Osborne's biography was very rewarding in both areas, and also took me to places where I did not expect to go.
For I had not known that von Karajan had been a member of the Nazi party from 1935 until his resignation during the war after marrying his second wife, Anita, whose ancestors included Jews. Apparently, his career was significantly affected by this alliance with the party. First, it helped him to get musical jobs in Germany until the above-mentioned marriage. Second, it made it hard for him to get certain musical jobs after World War II, even though he was cleared by the American and Austrian authorities of criminal activities. Apparently, his motives were career-oriented, rather than overtly political . . . despite many press stories to the contrary. The book contains much detail on this involvement, including documentation of the occurrences. I was impressed that nothing seemed to be glossed over. You also get comparisons to the degree of collaboration with and avoidance of the Nazis that other conductors and musicians took during the same time. I learned a lot as a result.
On the musical side, I was impressed by the hundreds of descriptions of how von Karajan created the musical results. The man was willing to put intense efforts into preparation, and then would rehearse and perform wihout a score. He was very aggressive in getting control over personnel in the orchestras he was involved with, obtaining lots of rehearsal time, and teaching the players to listen to one another to bring out the texture in the score. ....
Von Karajan usually conducted symphonic works with his eyes closed, making few gestures . . . often not openly marking the tempo. This could unnerve soloists until they began to realize that this conveyed more freedom to them, and that the orchestra would support them.
Due to the strange way his career evolved, von Karajan learned to master opera first. His casting decisions were often challenged by others because he was as interested in the acting as he was the singing. Great actors are rarely great singers and vice versa. Appearance was important to him also, so the compromises could become even stranger. Traditionally, casts were chosen for the singing alone. Not so with von Karajan.
I love detailed program notes. Much of the book is written like a series of them, built around important performances and recordings. You get a sense of how his performances differed from those that he and others had performed previously, the composer's intentions, and what the musicians and singers thought the interpretations should be. ....
Finally, I learned about what Mr. Osborne and others consider to be the great recordings of much of the world's best classical music. It will keep me busy for years seeking out these recordings, and enjoying them. ....
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
19 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A treat, from cover to cover, December 27, 2001
This review is from: Herbert Von Karajan: A Life in Music (Hardcover)
This is probably the ultimate biography of a complex and controversial personality in recent musical history. The book is conventionally structured: it is based on a detailed chronology supported by a rich factual database on Karajan's accomplishments as an orchestra builder and manager, recording artist and film maker. Stretching to more than 700 pages, the rich detail of Osborne's account certainly is one of the main attractions of this book. We learn a tremendous amount about Karajan's working methods, contract negotiations, concert tours, recording schedules, casting policy, press reviews, etc. As the story progresses Osborne branches out in all kinds of directions, gradually weaving more and more threads into the basic narrative. Given the quality of Osborne's prose this never becomes tedious. And it really does learn us something substantial about the breathtaking speed, economy, tenacity and versatility of the Karajanesque genius. There is no doubt that the book as a whole transcends the merely anecdotal. What emerges is a rich, multifaceted, holographic image of a great artist. What is even more impressive about Osborne's book is that it gives us an idea of what constitutes the essence of great conductorship. Instead of being confronted with woolly and simplistic generalizations about a certain 'Factor X' that allows an individual to coax exactly the right sound from a full symphony orchestra, we see the conceptual foundations of this most elusive of disciplines emerge in all its technical, psychological and somatic richness. Therefore, this book is definitely a must-read for any classical music lover, irrespective of personal predilections with respect to the man himself.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
a musical leader of extraordinary power, August 18, 2000
This review is from: Herbert Von Karajan: A Life in Music (Hardcover)
Richard Osborne's carefully documented portrayal of Karajan presents the picture of a complex perfectionist, sometimes gregarious and sometimes reclusive. For those readers who are collectors of Karajan's recordings, Osborne's narrative details the long association of the conductor with the Philharmonia, Vienna Philharmonic, and Berlin Philharmonic, as well as, the conductor's numerous opera recordings, the author includes information about production, technical, and musical matters that illustrate how substantial Karajan's commitment to recording was throughout his career. Osborne includes an appendix to the book about Karajan's membership in the Nazi party. A Chapter with transcipts from the denazification tribunal will be of interest to readers clarifying this stage of the conductor's complex life. The book provides fascinating background to the pre- and post-war musical lives of Vienna, Salzburg, and Berlin and enables the reader to view Karajan as a musical leader of extraordinary power and influence in an era of profound political and cultural upheaval in Europe and the world.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No