Most Helpful Customer Reviews
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Gift for Melody, April 18, 2002
This is an excellent debut. Most first offerings are mired in a cloud of one melody or rhythm spread over ten to twelve tracks. Harcourt succeeds in making every song sound different than the one that preceded it, and in doing this he shows his gift. As a songwriter, Harcourt has a lot to say. These are not your standard songs of teenage angst. He actually seems to poke fun at this trend in "Hanging With the Wrong Crowd," a superb track. Of course, the fans that critics like to lump together as liking Radiohead, Buckley, fill in a contemporary British band, etc. will probably like this album a lot. The opening track is clearly influenced by 'No Surprises." But what intelligent band or artist isn't conscious of what Radiohead are up to? The bottom line is that the music is great, the instrumentation is varied, the lyrics are clever, and in Harcourt the States have received another great British artist a year late.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Ed Harcourt's Monsters...Here at last, March 26, 2002
A friend of mine in England was raving about this guy so much last year I bought everything that he has produced thus far. Before reviewing this album I want to rant a little about the delays in getting good stuff over here in the US when it is available in Europe and elsewhere long before it reaches these shores. With internet radio and good market research it must be within the bounds of the imagination to be able to move artists and material over here a lot sooner. It seems to me that there is more concern about shipping millions of units of J-Lo ( sounds like a Chinese dish doesn't it?) without trying to build up emerging foreign artists. This album grows on you after several plays. Ed Harcourt uses a wide variety of voice, musical styles and instruments and has a strong lyrical content to his songs. Powerful imagery is evoked and emotions stirred by the songs. I have had this in my car an awful lot since I bought it last year and never tire of it. Trying to provide a reference point for Harcourt is difficult - I find myself thinking of Martin Stephenson at times, at others, Jackson Browne, often Kevin Coyne although none of them are similar. I think too, of Nick Drake, of Michael Chapman and even Roy Harper. Ed Harcourt is Ed Harcourt. This is a splendid album and deserves to be in everyone's library. Thank you Mike Kirby for introducing me to this artist. You always did have excellent taste.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
If Here Be Monsters, I Love Monsters!, April 4, 2002
This has to be one of the most engaging LP's I've listened to this year. I heard it playing at a small record store in Madison, WI, and had to have it immediately. From the first notes, these mouth-watering slabs of pure indie-pop reach out and weave their way into your soul. I'm not sure where Ed has been all these years, but he was worth the wait. And I thought nothing could hold a candle to Pete Yorn! "She Fell Into My Arms" ranks right up there with anything in recent memory, and immediately following is "Those Crimson Tears," a song that makes you want to cry a few of your own. This album is going into my top 10 for 2002!!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|