"I have found this a most useful book for undergraduate teaching purposes. It tackles a period and an area unfamiliar to most students in a way that makes its subject both comprehensible and interesting. "--Journal of Islamic Studies
| |||||||||||||||
"I have found this a most useful book for undergraduate teaching purposes. It tackles a period and an area unfamiliar to most students in a way that makes its subject both comprehensible and interesting. "--Journal of Islamic Studies
"Knowledge of the early history of Central Asia is limited. Written texts for significant events or trends are either nonexistent or contradictory. Evidence from art history, archaeology, linguistics, and folklore is often controversial, resulting in scholarly disputes and sometimes unwarranted speculation. Vital gaps in information about the area persists, and decades may elapse before an equivalent of Edwin Reischauer's and John Fairbank's important text East Asia: The Great Tradition is available for Central Asian history. When historians attempt to produce such a work, Rich¬ard Frye's 'The Heritage of Central Asia' will be a useful guide and perhaps even a model. Frye has provided a valuable chronological scheme for the pre-Islamic history of the region, indicating both scholarly consensuses and disagreements. In sixteen compact chapters, he outlines, in readable prose, the major political trends, religious beliefs, economic developments, and military campaigns in Central Asia, one of the principal crossroads linking East Asia with "Central and West Asia and Europe. Its vitality throughout the ages and its significance in the transmission of religions, technological discoveries, and artistic motifs emerge clearly from Frye's narrative. The various peoples of Central Asia have served as cultural and political intermediaries between the civilizations of East Asia and those of Central and Western Asia. The sym¬bolic representation of their role is the Silk Road, which had vastly greater significance than the shipping of Chinese silk westward. Merchants, missionaries, and envoys traveling along (he Silk Road facilitated the diffusion of Zoroastrianism. Buddhism, and later Islam through much of Asia, an invaluable contribution to numerous cultures. As befits a distinguished specialist in Iranian studies, Frye focuses on the Persian element in Central Asia, though he does not ignore other groups. He describes the important role of the Persians in the pre-Turkish domination of Central Asia and despite Turkish rule, he notes that the "Turks were the principal agents for spreading what we have called the Iranian version of Islamic culture" (p. 231). Even later, during the Mongol era, Persian was the lingua franca of much of Asia. Frye devotes less attention to the territories now incorporated into the "Autonomous Region" of Xinjiang in China, but, as he rightly points out, his "book is a concise history" and will, of necessity, omit 'many interesting details in the ancient history of Central Asia" (p. 9).'--Journal of Near Eastern Studies --Journal of Near Eastern Studies
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
58 of 62 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great Overview of History of Central Asia,
By P. Cornelius "pcornelius" (Mountain View, CA United States) - See all my reviews
This review is from: The Heritage of Central Asia: From Antiquity to the Turkish Expansion (Princeton Series on the Middle East) (Paperback)
With the publication of Dr. Richard Frye's The Heritage of Central Asia from Antiquity to the Turkish Expansion (Princeton: Markus Wiener Publishers, 1996, hardcover (ISBN 1558761101 ) and softcover (ISBN 155876111X), 264 pages) at last we have for Central Asia an overview book worth reading by novice and veteran alike. As the title implies, topics in the book include geography, pre-history, Zoroastrianism and Achaemenid Persians, Alexander the Great and the Greeks, the Parthians, nomads, Kushans, Silk Road trade, Buddhism, Sogdians, Muslims, Turks and much more. There are several (somewhat small) maps and a fair number of illustrations and photographs. Appendix topics include sources, geographical names (always a challenge in Central Asia), rulers in Bukhara and Samarkand, Sogdian deities, languages and coinage. The book is fully-indexed. Professor Frye of Harvard University is one of the deans of the field, especially in the area of Persia and author of numerous books including the recently re-published Bukhara. The very real accomplishment of this book is its comprehensive form which for once does not concentrate solely on a single time or place, but instead successfully communicates a feel for what was happening in all the regions throughout these historical periods. Much is to be learned and many questions will be answered. In some areas of research, of course, due to insufficient sources, the jury is still out and Frye does what one wants him to: he sets up the parameters of the question and the possibilities such that when someday new finds are made, the reader can judge them in the proper context. When he speculates, he informs the reader that that is what he is doing and refrains from offering theories without evidence as if they were fact. The conjectures too, as well as the facts, are always interesting coming as they do from a researcher of this stature and experience. Dr. Frye, who met the famous Sir Aurel Stein, first of the Foreign Devils of the Silk Road, and by extension his work, is a link back to the earliest Silk Road research and forward to what may be revealed by future excavations of mummies in Xinjiang and in the newly-independent republics of Central Asia. This book will be a valuable and often-consulted volume in the library of anyone with a passion for the Silk Road.
21 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A much needed book--but not for everyone,
By
This review is from: The Heritage of Central Asia: From Antiquity to the Turkish Expansion (Princeton Series on the Middle East) (Paperback)
My review of this book follows five others, which divide between praising or severely criticizing it. Such a dramatic split of opinion is a bit unusual on Amazon.com, but having read--and then re-read--the book, I understand it. And I take a middle (three-star rating) position: the book is best for a beginning student of in-depth academic study of the region, or for the general reader (most likely an upcoming tourist traveller to Central Asia, as I am) who is highly motivated to do background reading and get below the surface. But if you do not fall into either of those categories, i.e. are not considerably motivated, then this book is not for you.
Its strengths: -- There are very few general surveys--as vs. narrow academic monographs---written about Central Asia prior to the Islamic conquest. So this book doesn't have much competition in its category. -- We should be grateful that such a survey has been written by a leading scholar in the field, which requires knowledge of various modern and ancient languages as well as diverse functional areas (numismatics, art, etc.) which few individuals combine. Dr. Frye is a rare treasure in this area and was generous in taking time out of his scholarly work to produce a book oriented (sort of) to the layman. -- Dr. Frye is rigorously honest in indicating what we do or do not know, and it turns out that we know very little of this region prior to the era of the Persian Empire, and our knowledge afterwards continues to be thin until the Islamic conquest...which concludes his book. So, if nothing else, his book acts as a useful "truth meter" against which to measure other authors, perhaps less rigorous (honest) than he, tempted to declare as settled truths what is actually shaky on the evidence. If this book says anything, it is that there are few settled truths about the region during the pre-Islamic period. -- The book summarizes what little we DO know of that earlier period. The weaknesses of the book: -- Dr. Frye may be a great scholar, but he is a poor writer when it comes to the general public. The book is written in academically tedious style. -- The worst problem: Dr. Frye's rigorous honesty in telling what we do know and what we don't or just guess backfires. Nearly half the book is spent weighing the evidence for various assertions and concluding that, in the end, we don't know this, that, or the other thing. These excursions--essentially academic--could provide a new and devoted student of the subject with a good general guidemap to future specialization and research to resolve the uncertainties. But to the lay reader they are irrelevant detours. The book--already modest at about 240 pages--could have been cut to half that size without loss for the general reader. It would have been sufficient for the author to note at the outset that many facts remain uncertain, to skip telling us what we don't know or the arguments he thinks incorrect leading to certain conclusions, and to simply give a narrative of the current accepted consensus of historians of what DID happen in the area. Such a clean and thus abbreviated narrative would have been especially useful given the numerous waves of nomads and resulting kingdoms which have swept over the area, because for a non-specialist, keeping them all straight on one reading requires a fast-paced, economical narrative without excursions into scholarly byways of the sort in which this book often engages. A last complaint. The book, like most other general surveys of Central Asia I have read, engages in detailed written geographic descriptions of Central Asia and its ancient kingdoms while providing only 20th or 21st century reprint maps which do not begin to correspond to the text. It's no doubt a matter of money: hiring a cartographer to produce maps specific to a book of ancient history is likely expensive. But the lack of adequate maps in the book, while not crippling, is inconvenient and annoying. If reading it, keep close at hand a good National Geographic Atlas or something comparable. So I am glad for this book, because we have few others like it, but it is dry and for the general reader it is frankly a "slog" requiring considerable motivation. If travelling to the region, I suggest the following: read it once, highlight the useful passages (about half the book), then read those passages again. Then you will get out of it what you need--a good and coherent narrative of what little we know, without a lot of academic detours regarding what we don't know.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
needs better maps,
By DaLaoHu (Portland, OR) - See all my reviews
This review is from: The Heritage of Central Asia: From Antiquity to the Turkish Expansion (Princeton Series on the Middle East) (Hardcover)
I give this book a four because, although it is awkwardly written, it did provide me with a well-ordered summary of the early history of central Asia. Some reviewers complained about its lack of detail, but I think this is more due to the lack of written historical sources than to the author's failure to grasp the subject. He does a good job with what he has, (or so I must assume because I myself am not a specialist in the field). It was interesting to learn about the Sakas and the Kushans, groups I had never heard of before. But please, I have read several books now on central Asia and I have yet to find one with decent maps. The maps in this book are atrocious. For a university professor not to be able to provide maps is simply not being aware of the resources he has right at hand. Just go to the geography department and ask any graduate student, where you will probably get a quality product and cheap as well. I gather that Bactria was roughly present Afghanistan, that Sogdiana was roughly north and east of that, that the Scythians were roughly north and west of that, and that the Sakas were somewhere in the area of eastern Iran, but I am still only guessing because the maps in this book were no help at all.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|