Customer Reviews

Hero, Come Back

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

Dodd's story made Hero Come Back worth the read, though the other two selections fell a little flat. As eager as I usually am to read anything by Laurens or Dodd, I might have just waited for this one to appear at my local library.

Laurens' Lost and Found, at well under a hundred pages, could not seem to fit in any conflict at all between the two main characters. Reggie's occasional exasperation at Anne's persistent attempts to harass the family of an abandoned child provide little more than momentary flares (that naturally fuel sexual tension), but the two are almost immediately united in the goal of restoring the child to his birth family. Their romance is also too smooth to hold any suspense or drama. I enjoyed the story for what it was-a very light read, but do not expect more.

In contrast, Boyle's Matchmaker's Bargain was full of conflict, and much more inventive; but the conflict was so contrived it was difficult to get into the story. Amanda unknowingly stumbles onto a matchmaker while in flight from her family, accidentally bargains for a match with her heart's desire, who shows up in the form of war-battered James. From there on it gets sillier-Amanda cannot leave the little village without marrying or being arrested, a ball to attract what must have been every eligible man in England is planned, Amanda's "secret" is rather ridiculous, and I have doubts that even jail cells in tiny hamlets feature removable bars. However, the hi-jinks the two stumble into on the way to the conclusion are entertaining enough to keep your attention, even if the absurdity of the plot's premise is distracting.

Dodd's Third Suitor is the most satisfying of the three stories. Jessie is saddled by her greedy father with a deliberately inattentive duena, and forced to withstand the attentions of two obnoxious suitors until Harry, embittered former spy, steps in to help dodge them. Unbeknownst to Jessie, Harry is candidate number three, and a former girlhood crush. Harry does not remember Jesse as the pest of a girl who broke his nose and ruined at least one good time, but is falling for her anyway. On the cusp of revealing his true name and third suitor status, the romance is interrupted when an old enemy appears. The story was necessarily short, but well developed for its length, the characters were fairly well defined and the twists in the plot kept you guessing enough to keep the pages turning.

You know, when I buy an anthology I just never know what I will come up with. It's like going to the county fair. You pays your money and you takes your chance. Luckily for me, two out of three was not bad except that the "bad" one was officially called a novella and took up most of the book.

---4.5 stars, Stephanie Laurens, "Lost and Found"
At less than 80 pages this was a very good story. Why this was so short I don't know but it would have done well as a longer offering. Anne Ashford and Reggie Carmarthen were very good lead characters and complimented each other admirably. He seemed to instantly realize how serious she was about finding a solution to Benjamin's parental (or lack of) situation and I liked seeing them work together. A feel good ending all around.

---2 stars, Elizabeth Boyle, "The Matchmaker's Bargain"
This was the novella of the trio and I just can't make out why. Why was this author chosen to write the longest portion of this anthology? Is it mandatory that they be over 370 pages long? Do readers demand quantity instead of quality? For me, it was trite, contrived, unweildy and had very poor dialogue. Try an experiment some time when you are reading. Say the dialogue out loud. This was riddled with lines spoken by our heroine, Amanda Farleigh (masquerading as Miss Smythe to protect her identity) such as, "Sir, I must away", and "Sir, I beseech you to leave" and "Please, sir, unhand me". And our hero. Oh, yes, our hero! Mr James Reyburn (Jemmy to his friends and family) must have said "demmit" either aloud or to himself once on each page (somethimes more than once per page). Gosh how I grew to hate that word! I think the whole thing was drawn out just to make for more pages in the book. I felt that nothing was added to the story by having it that long..over 155 pages.

---4.5 stars, Christina Dodd, "The Third Suitor"
A very good story. Needed to be longer. (Say, what if we take away about half from EB?) It was well thought out, it had wonderful characters who were likeable and realistic and the plot was interesting, tight, and workable. Lady Jessica Macmillian and Edmund Kennard Henry Chamberlain, Earl of Granville (posing as just regular Mr Harry Windberry) have not come to this out-of-the-way place by accident and therein lies this delightful tale. He doesn't remember her, she doesn't recognize him, but they have met before and she is actually the reason his nose was broken all those years ago. A true delight to watch them rediscover each other and fall in love in the process. This one was 112 pages but seemed much shorter because I was so interested in it.

This book also contained 18 pages at the end selling stories available from this publisher which (stupid piled on top of stupid) actually included the three stories included in this very book! (Please, people, is there really not an editor in the house any more????)

I had never read the three books which contained these three heros so they didn't actually "come back" for me but I really enjoyed getting to know two of them. I will probably search out the originals to read just so I can get to know these guys a little better.

"Lost and Found" by Stephanie Laurens. In 1834 London Reggie Carmarthen (see ONE WILD NIGHT) needs a wife and heir. He hopes to be as happy as his friends the Cynster twins are in their recent marriages, but has no one in mind until he assists Anne Ashford as she yells at Lord Elderby that young Benjy is his offspring. Reggie wonders if this passionate woman that he has known for years could become his ardent bride.

"The Third Suitor" by Christina Dodd. In 1847 Dorset, Harry Chamberlain (see IN YOUR ARMS) looks down from his balcony to see a woman hiding in the bushes below. She introduces herself as Lady Jessie McMillan explaining that she is an heiress hiding from a suitor, Marques Jenour-Redmond. Harry agrees to help Jessie avoid her suitors but soon wants to court her too.

"The Matchmaker's Bargain" by Elizabeth Boyle. In 1818 England Amanda Preston visits Esme Maguire hoping she can fix her broken heart. The matchmaker and her cat Lord Nelson are stunned when they realize who the intended is although that is not quite what Amanda has in mind. At Esme's home, once wounded veteran James Reyburn (see ONCE TEMPTED) and Amanda meet, love blossoms, but she has a secret that keeps her from telling her beloved how much she loves him.

These three nineteenth century English romances demonstrate that a hero can come back at least in a well written novella. The male protagonists were secondary characters in previous stories, but show the respective author's skills as each successfully move to top billing. HERO COME BACK is a delightful historical collection

I liked everything about this anthology. . . the stories themselves, the characters and the way they were written and worded. What a great way to find new writers in your favorite genre. All three short stories were very good. It was well worth the read and I will be checking out other books and novellas by each author.

A friend highly recommended this book to me, however, I could not get into it at all and wound up not finishing it.

Just the type of book to stick in your purse for those wait times in the MD's, Dentist, or other offices. The authors are great and the stories are intriguing!

Usually there's one author I have to have in these compilations and the other stories are boring or just awful, but all of these stories were fun.

Stephanie Laurens story was good, not as wonderful as her usual books but the format is short and she writes very long books. I haven't read Elizabeth Boyle before. It wass humorous and entertaining, although not up to the caliper of the other two. Christina Dodd's is the best with a real plot. It's packed with action and Jessie, the heroine, is funny and smart. She's a good match for Harry, and there's some steamy scenes.

I only bought the book for the Stephanie Laurens story, and I was not disappointed. A sweet little story and very much in character with what we already know about them from the previous Cynster stories. I felt that that the other two authors were not writing at all in the Regency genre - they should have stuck the characters in a modern novel. Although they were quite well written, I would never buy them on their own.