Customer Reviews

Hidalgo [VHS]

5 star:		(139)
4 star:		(84)
3 star:		(40)
2 star:		(11)
1 star:		(10)

 

 

Based on the life story of Frank T. Hopkins and his horse Hidalgo, "Hidalgo", from director Joe Johnston, is a compelling, beautiful, and exciting film (even though it stretches its running time to 130 minutes) that interests every moviegoer with suspense, romance, and tales of comraderie.

The year is 1890, and half-American, half-Souix Indian Frank T. Hopkins (Viggo Mortensen), is invited by an Arabic sheik to compete in "The Ocean of Fire", the most prestigious and dangerous long-distance race ever known to man. Usually reserved for the purest bred stallions and the wealthiest and best riders in the world, the 3,000 mile race across the Arabian Desert leaves half of its competetors dead from natural disaster, insanity, or the treachery of fellow riders. After witnessing a tragedy at Wounded Knee Creek, and falling out of his once-claimed title of the best rider in the West, Frank and Hidalgo jump at the opportunity, where they encounter danger in all forms, and must rely on their friendship and strength to pull off the impossible.

Seeing as "Hidalgo" is Viggo Mortensen's first film in which he has been the only-billed star, he handles the pressure well as the quiet and conflicted Frank T. Hopkins. He plays the character with a brilliant subtlely, and gives him an air of understated intelligence and courage. With the right amount of emotion, Mortensen is the modern day Indiana Jones-like action hero; with sex appeal and gripping stunts. Although he lacks charisma in some instances, he is overall perfect and enjoyable in his role. The supporting cast is strong, with the highlights being Louise Lombard as Lady Anne Davenport and a small but memorable performance by Victor Talmadge as Rau Rasmussen. However strange this may sound, the horse Hidalgo gave one of, if not the best, performance in the movie. He made the relationship between himself and Frank heartbreaking and fufilling, and expressed emotions and conveyed certain thoughts across to the audience in simply a look. If there was ever an award for the best animal actor, I would personally award it to Hidalgo.

One of the main highlights of Hidalgo is the beautiful sets and surrounding scenery. Rich in color, there are stunning shots of the Arabian desert, the plains of old America, and snowy forests and rivers, and just the people of each new environment, which make the story overall more enjoyable. The cinematography is jaw-dropping, as the perspectives, running shots of the races, and choice in angles and film speeds are spot on in nearly every scene. The music is also incorporated well, jerking emotions and suspense from the audience.

Although I have heard the contrary, I was thoroughly satisfied with "Hidalgo" as a whole. I loved the way the relationship between Frank and Hidalgo was portrayed, the story was new and exciting, and I was moved, gripped by the suspense, and engrossed in the film from start to finish. Although it runs a little long, ends one too many times, and has some bad dialogue, it will ultimately satisfy moviegoers of most ages due to the content, draw, and overall look of the film.

Unless the Academy opens a new category for "best performance by an animal actor", you won't be hearing of this movie next Oscar season, but that's no reason to miss this movie now. Hidalgo, the horse, and Viggo Mortensen, as Frank T. Hopkins, completely won my heart as well as a place in "Great Couples of the Silver Screen", or at least as great partners in a buddy movie. This wonderful painted mustang plays the serious buddy, making his human tend to business in spite of other inclinations. It is a charming footnote to the movie that Mortensen was so taken with the horse that he bought it after the movie was completed.

Frank T. Hopkins may or may not have lived all the adventures he was famous for recounting, but it is verifiably true that he was instrumental in saving the wild mustang from extermination in North America. For that he is a hero.

This movie version of the 3000 mile race Hidalgo and Hopkins were said to have run across the Arabian desert to keep their title as "greatest long distance race runner" is an old-fashioned popcorn-movie-as-entertainment movie. It should also help the theaters sell quite a bit of bottled water and soda. The film's weaknesses are mostly attributable to the script. The writing (credit is to John Fusco, not-quite-known for writing the screenplay for SPIRIT: STALLION OF THE CIMARRON--- an AHA!! moment here) could have been tighter, and left needless plot holes. Also annoying is a slight laxity in editing. However, the story itself is a dramatic one, and the movie is fun to watch. The cinematography does well by the story and the locale.

Omar Sharif, once again as a sheik, comfortable to the core in his role, is a delight. Viggo Mortensen is good to look at, obviously, but made me realize how difficult "laconic" is to play. He manages. Just. Louise Lombard, playing the English seductress Lady Anne, who continually raises her stakes in the race, has the most compelling eyes of any actress I can recall. The original music by James Newton Howard is also well done.

"The Last Samurai" opened on a similar note: Army orders cause a murderous slaughter of Native Americans for which the protagonist feels responsible, explaining his taking refuge in alcohol. Both protagonists have cynical reasons for leaving America, but some prospect of finding their souls again in a very foreign land, a completely unfamiliar culture. "The Last Samurai" has what this film lacks: a psychological examination of the hero's journey. Both films' protagonists and heroines form a prohibited bond, Samurai's developing naturally, this one seemingly more contrived and less deep. But whereas "The Last Samurai" is a war movie, this film ends as "Seabiscuit": a very exciting horse race.

Our audience was completely involved, groaning, cheering, sweating it out for the heroes, the heroine, and even, occasionally, for the also-rans. It is a satisfying ride. B-

Hidalgo is based upon a true story, so it's no wonder it's thrilling, truth being stranger than fiction and all. Although it's highly doubtful that everything in the movie actually happened, Frank Hopkins was indeed a real life cowboy, master horseman and rider and he did participate in the great Bedouin horse race of the Middle East known as the "Ocean of Fire" in the 1890's.

This wonderfully stylized and lovingly crafted film clocks in at over two hours, yet never bores and your interest should never waver. The international cast is terrific, led by Viggo Mortensen in a low-key, subtle performance which brings depth and a real sense of nobility to the notion of a "cowboy'. We've seen loads of silver screen gun slingers, bandits and marshals from icons like the swaggering John Wayne to the laconic Clint Eastwood, but with Viggo's Frank Hopkins, we may now be witness to one of the most balanced and interesting portrayals of an authentic cowpoke. And it's all the more interesting because Frank Hopkins isn't all cowboy - half of him is Native American. This internal duality and cultural division brings character shadings and a unique sense of perspective to Hopkins.

Balancing the tensions of Native Americans with the US Government of the time, the film explores Frank Hopkin's journey between two worlds - that of a half Native American with loyal ties to his tribe and his jobs as a pony express rider and performer in Wild Bill Hickcock's show, all while having to live in the White Man's world. When he's invited to participate in the Bedouin Race, Frank soon discovers there's a whole other world out there bound by similar dogmatic traditions, where women must hide their faces behind veils, much like he's chosen to hide his native ancestry to enable him to live an easier life.

Sweeping cinematography beautifully composes authentic locations and the stunt choreography infuses the race and the action set-ups with fun and authenticity. Viggo must have definitely "lived" horses for the film, irregardless of his prior expertise with them. He clearly is at the reigns of the horse most of the time and he's totally capable and always convincing. Hidalgo the horse may qualify for his own sequel or a TV series. This beautiful animal is more expressive than many human actors and it's just one of the many joys and reasons to give this film a chance. Apparently lost by audiences in it's initial theatrical release, Hidalgo should be discovered by every movie lover.

I say Viggo has down it again, after the LOTR Trilogy he is starring in this true story about Frank T. Hopkins and his horse Hidalgo in the race across the Aribian desert of the Ocean of Fire. It might be a suprise for some people since that he is known as Aragorn, who hardly gets a swollen eye. In Hidalgo, he gets injured or beaten up in the race. Viggo brings the determined character to life. The movie gives you a feeling of romance and bravery. To me, the movie's captured my heart. I think Viggo makes a great horse rider, and the director probaly caught that from the LOTR Trilogy. They made a great choice to choose Viggo for this role, he can make you feel that the character is real alive just as he did with Aragorn.

It is a shame that many people have not read or heard what a terrific big screen adventure film "Hidalgo" is. Hopefully, now that it is out in DVD it will gain a wider audience. Anyway, a friend told me not to miss this flick, directed by Joe Johnston and starring Viggo Mortensen, and I am glad I followed his advice. Yes, the movie is flawed, but overall, if you like horses and cowboys, "Hidalgo" has a certain grace to it that makes it a treat to watch.

"Hidalgo" is the name of a legendary racehorse - not a purebred Arabian, Thoroughbred, or Andalusian, but a mixed breed of Arabian, Barb and Andalusian horses called Mustang. The Mustangs, or Paints, ran wild across the North American deserts and plains. Native Americans caught and tamed many of them and they proved to be much better, stronger and faster, than Calvary horses. "Hidalgo," a beautiful paint stallion, was owned by real life long-distance horse racer, and Pony Express courier, Frank T. Hopkins. Half Plains Indian and half Caucasian, Hopkins was a breed like his horse, and they had run and won many races together. He was a noble man, just and kind, who lived during a sad period - he witnessed the slaughter of his mother's people at Wounded Knee in 1890. Filled with grief and bitterness at the brutal murder of his family, Hopkins became a drunken drifter, hooking up with Buffalo Bill Cody's Wild West Show. Also featured in the traveling show was Hidalgo, who Hopkins claimed was the "world's greatest/fastest endurance race horse." One evening, after a performance, he was approached by the representative of very wealthy Saudi Sheikh Riyadh (Omar Sharif). Hopkins and Hidalgo were challenged to compete in the world's most grueling long distance horse race, against the Sheikh's prize Arabian stallion and many other superb animals and experienced riders. "The Ocean of Fire" was a 3,000 mile long endurance race under the burning desert sun, across the brutal Arabian sands.

Hopkins accepted the challenge and took Hidalgo to the Middle East. He was the first infidel to be invited to participate in this race. The Arabs thought the presumption was ridiculous that a small, hybrid mustang could compete against their pure animals, with long and famous bloodlines. They wager that Hopkins and Hidalgo won't last 24 hours. The movie is about this race. And the rest is history.

There are some interesting minor characters like Sharif, the desert prince, his beautiful daughter, Zuleikha Robinson, (there's gotta be a girl, even in a horse film, right?), the competitors with their rivalries and friendships. But the real star is Hidalgo, (a gorgeous animal), with a good performance by Mortensen. And the desert scenery is beautifully filmed. Certainly worth the rental price.
JANA

I have read peoples reviews about this movie. Fair enough everyone has their own opinion. One person said "Knowing horses as they do it was cruel and impossible". I agree with my limited knowledge no horse could have managed such a task. Another said the movie was to long. It was so full of high adventure and excitment for me the time passed quickly.
Look at it like this. We all know Hopkins was a tall tale teller and there never was or has been such a race. Pay no attention to the reviews or what you have heard...ITS A DAMN GOOD MOVIE.
Pure old fashioned Hollywood escapism. Apart from some of the special effects it could have been made in the golden age with someone like Alan Ladd or Tony Curtis. No bad language, no sex and no exceptional violence. And good to see Omar back in the desert once more. It did`nt entirely flop here in the U.K. but it did have a limited run which is very sad.
Good family fun which is what we need more of.

So, let's get down to it. The movie was hokey. The special effects were most definitely not top of the line. The plot was lacking dimension. And most of the characters were stolen directly from Disney movies.

However, Hidalgo was generally a good film. If not for the fact that Viggo Mortensen was PERFECT for his role, or that the story had some inspirational value, the movie itself served as an extremely refreshing breath of fresh air. Compared to the hustle and bustle of the movies that have been released in the past few months (many of them released in late december as heavy hitter oscar contenders), Hidalgo is just plain fun. You will revel in the fact that you aren't being asked to think too much or analyze each scene for its contribution to the whole. Instead, you are asked to just sit back and enjoy the show.

Having seen the movie before previews starting appearing on television, I can honestly say that I didn't know what to expect. Being totally blind to previous conceptions, I almost immediately got the impression that this was a Disney movie. It's actually a Touchstone picture, but the quality of film, the simple cinematography, the general brightness of the scenes, and the general feel-goodness of the plot was inescapably "family film." Highly recommended for all ages.

As a film addict, I find it hard to give this film 4 stars. It just seems empty to me. The direction was mediocre, but the seemingly talented multi-lingual cast headed by Mortensen of LOTR fame saves the film for the viewer. At least though, with all that is possibly wrong with this "Western" about a man and his horse Hidalgo, one is able to enjoy every minute. This movie fulfills its purpose. And for that, I am willing to give it the compliments it deserves.

What ever happened to just going to the movie TO WATCH THE MOVIE? Not sit there and pick apart everything thats wrong with it. Just watch it and enjoy it make it worth your money and not so that you regret ever going to see it because it was too "fake", it's supposed to be, its hollywood. And yes this movie i thought was a great movie and i'm buying the DVD.

What can I say? I was so pleasantly surprised by Joe Johnston's "Hidalgo" that this review is likely to seem more than a bit overdone. But "Hidalgo" is one of those movies that reminds you that movies can be just more darn fun than pretty much any other form of entertainment.

Is 5 stars too high a rating for a highly fictionalized account of Frank Hopkins' life as played by Viggo Mortensen? If you judge "Hidalgo" against Great Films like "Citizen Kane" and "The Godfather," sure. But "Hidalgo" doesn't try to be a Great Movie, it tries to be a wing-dinger of an adventure, and on that score "Hidalgo" triumphs where so many other big-budget efforts have failed miserably.

Set in the final years of the 19th century, the movie depicts an America in ugly transition. The Plains Indians are being rounded up to go onto reservations, and in an attempt to cripple the "horse culture" of these Indians the U.S. government has said that all wild mustangs will be killed unless a ridiculously high bounty is paid per horse. Hopkins works as a courier for the Army when he's not off winning long-distance horse races on his trusty painted mustang Hidalgo (T.J. is the horse's real name, and he gives a good performance). Half Lakota, half white, Hopkins is a man who may not have completely decided on his true heritage, but he's leaning toward the white man's ways.

That comes to a screeching halt as Hopkins plays a minor, unwitting role in the infamous massacre at Wounded Knee. Scarred, Hopkins crawls inside a bottle and takes a job with Wild Bill's Wild West show.

Thanks to Wild Bill's boasting, Hopkins finds himself entered as a contestant in the Ocean of Fire, the longest endurance race on the planet -- over 3,000 miles across Arabia. Hopkins is the first non-Arab to run the race, and that gives rise to a lot of ethnic slurs. Hidalgo is also the first horse to run in the race without the benefit of the sanctioned bloodline, which leads to even more racial slurs.

The majority of the movie centers around the race and Hopkins' adventures in it. Suffice it to say that while there must have been several long, boring stretches during the race across 3,000 miles of desert, but "Hidalgo" only goes for the juiciest moments, and there are several. From kidnappings to assassination attempts to rescues to locusts to sandstorms to cheetahs to boiling quicksand, this is a race for only the bravest, or the dumbest. Johnston keeps the pace up, and the 2 1/4 hour movie flies by.

The movie touches lightly on the cliches of Western-versus-Arabian culture clashes, but fortunately stays just this side of stereotyping on both sides. Sure, Omar Sharif plays a more-or-less stereotypical sheikh, but Viggo's Hopkins more than fits the bill as a stereotypical cowboy pretty much to a T, as well. If you find "Hidalgo" offensive on racial lines, you're probably looking a little to hard for things to be offended about.

In general, the acting in "Hidalgo" is broad, with the notable exception of Mortensen, who is about as reserved and stoic as one can imagine. He's on screen in virtually every sceen, but I think he said more words in "Young Guns II" (Yes, he was in that - you can look it up). But silence only gives Mortensen more chances to convey his thoughts and emotions with that leading man mug of his, and many women will undoubtedly be thrilled at watching this tall drink of water just stand and stare.

All in all, "Hidalgo" is a great example of what Hollywood can do when it focuses on the basics. An adventure only has to be an adventure - it doesn't also have to be overtly political, or too heavy on the romance, or too slapstick. Put "Hidalgo" in the pantheon of great adventure movies, from "Gunga Din" to "King Kong" to the Brendan Fraser version of "The Mummy" to even the sainted "Raiders of the Lost Ark." And that's high praise indeed. Worthy of five stars.

I happened to see this movie by chance and have taken a great liking to it. Viggo Mortensen plays Frank T. Hopkins a half breed Native American in search of himself. He gets lost even more when he witnesses the massacre at Wounded Knee in 1890. It affects him so much that he becomes a drunkard and drifts into Buffalo Bill's Wild West Show.

A chance at redemption comes from a challenge by the Sheik of Sheiks played greatly by Omar Sharief to prove his title as the greatest long distance rider in the 3000 mile Bedouin Race.

The main horse(there were 5 used), whom Mortensen purchased after the film, has a great face. Just beams with personality and draws affection from viewers.

The secondary characters are great. I have to mention Floyd Red Crow Westerman who plays old Chief Eagle Horn. As always he does a great job as the old wise friend.

There is hidden humor in the film which many people miss (ie: wrestling with annie oakly over his weapon "Annie get your own damn gun".

One thing I look for in actors is not being able to see previous performances. I watched Viggo's performance and did not think of Aragorn; a mark of good acting.

The extras on the DVD are interesting and gives you a little history of long-distance racing(San and Cellulod).

You will not be disappointed.