From School Library Journal
PreSchool-Grade 2-What might have been an engaging pourquoi story is instead tedious and anticlimactic. When the barnyard animals get invited to a party, they dress in their Sunday best and proceed to the neighboring farm. Rooster led the way, strutting and crowing. Duck waddled behind. Cow moseyed along in her own sweet time. Pig strolled under his umbrella to keep from getting a sunburn. Goat pranced about, thinking of the feast they were going to eat. Horse trotted along-¦ and on, and on, with everyone painstakingly accounted for. When they finally get to the party, it's more of the same, with half a dozen unremarkable party games exhaustively remarked upon. Eventually everyone sits down to eat, and most of the guests politely disguise their dismay at being presented with plain cornbread. But Rooster stalks off in a huff-and later learns that each loaf of bread was baked around a succulent meal. Since then Rooster can always be found scratching at the ground, hoping never to miss out again. The story does not have an arc so much as a slow, steep climb followed by a precipitous drop. Tate's beautifully laid-out illustrations are a delight; it is unfortunate that they did not have a better narrative.
-Catherine Threadgill, Charleston County Public Library, SC Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
PreS-Gr. 2. Barnyard animals learn a lesson about manners and passing judgments in this moral tale drawn from Joel Chandler Harris' Uncle Remus
stories. A cow, a chicken, and their friends are thrilled to attend a party at the neighboring farm. The event begins well, with games and entertainment. Then dinner is served, and the animals are disappointed by what appears to be a meal of cornbread. "I eat cornbread every day," scoffs Rooster before stalking off. The remaining animals, though, find a delicious meal beneath the cornbread crust, and Rooster learns to be more thoughtful. Children may have questions about the southern idioms and references, such as
hambone (musical percussion played on the body), but the publisher's Web site offers cultural context (along with lesson plans), and the smooth text is well shaped for read-alouds, as are the bright, clearly arranged paintings of the expressive, whimsically outfitted animals. One quibble: the text focuses on vegetables, but one picture shows a pig tucking into what looks like a piece of bacon. Suggest this for teachers seeking lighthearted material for character education units.
Gillian EngbergCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved