5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
History or Mythology??, January 22, 2010
This review is from: Hidden History of Greenville County (SC) (American Chronicles (History Press)) (Paperback)
I was intrigued by the title "Hidden History of Greenville County" and purchased this short 128 page volume anticipating that I would find some interesting new factoids about Greenville history. Instead I found repetition of information readily available in a number of other Greenville histories as well as the disturbing continued overabundant proliferation of Upcountry South Carolina mythology written in a manner that the casual reader would assume were factual.
A number of poorly researched/poorly documented small volumes on Upcountry South Carolina history have been published in the last ten or so years and "Hidden History" is yet another.
What is most surprising is that Mrs. Helsley, a professional archivist and professor, includes no bibliography, no citing of primary sources, nary a footnote in this supposed history, and herein lies a tremendous problem with this volume being catalogued as a history and most definitely indicates a "purchaser/reader beware".
And indeed, a "Notice" (disclaimer) appears on the copyright page which would protect both the author and the publisher from claims on the accuracy of information contained in this non-annotated volume.
It would take a large number of pages to itemize the unproven information stated as fact in this short volume and about which local researchers have spent years trying to prove through primary sources without success. I would say that if Mrs. Helsley had located primary sources to prove the myths contained in this volume she would have included them.
Mrs. Helsley is a fluent good writer and if the potential reader is interested only in a handful of "a good stories" rather than proven historical facts about the Upcountry and Greenville County, "Hidden History" is a good read but too much content in this volume must be taken "with a grain of salt". If the potential reader is interested in factual history, look for one of the handful of volumes which cites primary source material and omits the mythology - or at least in which the author states that the information is unproven.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great short read about Greenville and the surrounding areas..., August 26, 2010
This review is from: Hidden History of Greenville County (SC) (American Chronicles (History Press)) (Paperback)
This book was an interesting, quick read and I truly enjoyed learning more about Greenville (my new, adopted home city). I do wish it was longer!
Admittedly, the layout seemed a bit random. There were little bios of local characters throughout the book but at times they seemed randomly placed (the author would mention a person a few times, and then throw in the "bio" for that person far later, for example). And I do feel as if the author could have written quite a bit more about famous or semi-famous people from Greenville, for example Mayor Max Heller.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No