Most Helpful Customer Reviews
27 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Darkly challenging, June 12, 2005
Nevada Barr is at her best in Western settings, where her characters have room to roam. In this book, she returns to the west, but sets her story in a Novemberish Yosemite, hemmed in by clouds, trapped fog-like, barely above the treetops. A lot of reviewers of the hardback complained about that, but they've obviously never lived in a climate that can produce this kind of weather for two weeks at a crack. I do. It can chill you, right to the soul.
Which is what this book is all about. The set-up is simple enough: Anna Pigeon, upwardly mobile park ranger, is working undercover in a swank hotel as a waitress, hoping to suss out the fate of four hikers who went missing and are presumably dead. But what this book is really about is evil: the human evil that, like endless November fog, can invade even sacred places like Yosemite; and the spiritual evil to which some people have surrendered more than others, but which is beneath the skin of us all. Opposing this, Barr sets a collection of women of varying degrees of spiritual and emotional innocence (and in some cases, intellectual innocence) and throughout, she uses undercover detective work as a metaphor for the loss and retaining of one's identity in the face of pressures that would make you someone you don't want to be.
Basically, this is Barr's most ambitious work, and for about 350 pages it works stunningly. In the final 50 pages it comes partially unglued-one of the critical innocence-related plot threads gets dropped, and the behavior of some of the villains seems to have been altogether too convoluted, given their motives. For those reasons, I can't give the book a perfect score.
Bottom line: This is a very good book. But beware, it's darker than the normal Anna Pigeon fare, and the normally sunny landscapes of Barr's natural world share in the darkness.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
19 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
"Its a Bird, It's a plane....It's Super Anna!", July 17, 2005
I am an avid Nevada Barr reader, and can't wait for every new book she brings me with Anna Pigeon's next adventure. This one, however, dealt less with the wonderful, descriptive visual images of the National Park,in this case,Yosemite,and more with Anna having to do chase scenes of superhuman acts under more and more physical duress than any "normal", or even, "super middle-aged Anna" could be expected to realistically do!
Barr does not even begin to pull off the reality of Anna's waitress character's relationships to young people, as anyone who works with such an age group can see right through. The one, really believable character, Lorraine Knight, is MIA at times that prove unrealistic. Is anyone really surprised by the "ringleader" of the drug gang? Any mystery reader can figure that out pretty early on. Add to this ad naseum chase scenes, and this definitely is one of Anna's most forgetable adventures in one of America's most unforgetable parks!
Even with that, I wouldn't miss reading any of Barr's Pigeon books. We all have our 'bad days', and, regardless of how outrageous the plot can be, Barr always shows us the wonderful, human and evolutionary side of Anna Pigeon!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Anna Pigeon goes undercover in Yosemite, February 5, 2004
Our favorite NPS ranger Anna Pigeon has been called to California in order to quietly investigate the disappearance of four young people. While she "works" as a waitress in the Ahwahnne Hotel restaurant, she keeps her eyes open, asks questions, and noses around a bit. After she takes a long hike and finds a secret lurking in a remote area of the park, the action takes off and this book is difficult to put down. (Turns out the elevation isn't the only thing in the park that's "high.") Anna ends up finding some rather nasty folks in the midst of the spectacular glacial scenery. Thank goodness she's a trained and capable law enforcement officer and outdoors-person. A lesser woman wouldn't make it past page 155! Following the style of Nevada Barr's earlier titles, this engaging story ends with the best moral of all: There's no place like home.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|