Customer Reviews

A Highland Duchess

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(4)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

I started reading this book after having finished two historical romances by other authors with spunky, adventurous, relatively free-spirited heroines. So as I'm reading the first 15 or so pages of this, I'm thinking jeeze this heroine is just a passive doormat of a woman. Given away in marriage by her father to a debauched, hedonistic, orgy-loving duke who forces her to do unspeakable things, then widowed and in the control of her evil uncle who abuses her physically if she opposes him, she just seems to accept all of this passively. And I wonder, "How can she be this way? Why doesn't she do something?" Then I realized it's a 'historical' romance. Those spunky heroines of the other novels weren't the norm. Women of the 1800s were dominated and controlled by men. Only a very few were able to be in control of their own destiny. This book is really more accurate historically, so I need to settle in and see what happens to the heroine. And since I've long been a fan of Karen Ranney's writing skills, it wasn't that much of a sacrifice.

So about 20 pages in our heroine Emma, the widowed Duchess of Herridge, finds Ian McNair, Earl of Buchane, in her bedchamber, demanding she hand over the Tulloch mirror, which apparently rightfully belongs to the Tullochs in Scotland but was given to Emma by the late duke on their wedding day. She does not have it in her possession so she's abducted by Ian, taken to his London home, and held for ransom as he demands that Emma's uncle find and return the mirror to him.

Ian does not reveal his identity to Emma. However, he treats her kindly and with respect, perhaps the first man ever in her life to do so. They manage to fall in love in the 3 days she stays at his home and the funny thing is it's believable. You really feel that they have fallen in love, not just in lust. The process is so skillfully drawn by Ranney and is very romantic. So now you'd think we have our HEA, right? Emma finally finds happiness? Nope. Not yet. Still to come we have star-crossed lovers, marriage and/or engagement to the wrong people, murder, attempted murder, a trip to Scotland, interesting historical tidbits about science and medicine in the 1860s (Ian is a scientist), and finally, finally comes the resolution and HEA. And a great ending where we see that Emma finally finds her backbone.

I started out thinking I would not like this book and found myself drawn into sad, oppressed and repressed Emma's life. Ranney is pretty much a specialist in this kind of heroine full of pain, sadness and longing and she does it well. She knows how to get across to the reader the gamut of emotions her characters feel. We're able to see the slow evolution of Emma from sad and passive to a more proactive person. It certainly helped to have a wonderful hero in Ian. And we have a goodly amount of intrigue and mystery here also to keep up the interest. It's a good book. Maybe not great, but quite good.

This book is a little bleak, and at times it left me hunting for my happy pills. To the modern reader it is hard to see how any woman could accept what Emma accepted. But when you see things in the context of her historical era and through the eyes of an abused woman, you realise that the story is not so far-fetched as it initially appears. I enjoyed the book and loved Ian as a hero. But the main problem for me was that Ian and Emma came together far too quickly. Yes, the story had criminal suspense, but it lacked romantic suspense. I would have liked to have seen Ian do more work to win Emma over...to help her work through the issues her awful husband must have left her. I really want to give the book 3.5 stars but have dropped back to 3 stars - it is a good book, but not that good. My favourite of Ranney's latest offerings is "A Scotsman in Love"

A DESPERATE WOMAN...

The Duke of Herridge was dead. Eighteen months had passed since her husband's sudden, mysterious death, and Emma had kept the knowledge of exactly how he'd died a secret, along with other events she dared not reveal.

At least with Anthony's death she would finally be free. Now all Emma wanted to do was forget the past and adopt a quiet, decorous mode of living that would hopefully allow all the harsh rumors surrounding her to just fade away.

But then her uncle comes to her and declares he has found her another husband, and she will shortly be a married woman again. His pronouncement leaves Emma trembling with dread as she has no desire to be a bride again; marriage had been a hideous experience for her and she didn't ever want to repeat it.
As she sits contemplating what to do about her uncle's decree, lightening flashes in darkness outside the sitting room window; the stormy weather a grim parallel to Emma's turbulent emotions...

She just can't do it, she could not marry again.

She goes to the window and stares into the rainy night; and leaning her head against the glass in despair and desperation she utters a prayer into the darkness beyond, as she had done many times while married to Anthony... Please, God, save me...

When an unfamiliar voice unexpectedly calls out her name, she turns to find a strange man standing in front of an open window across the room. The man was tall, dressed all in black, with striking features and an attractive face one would not easily forget. Her intruder cheekily smiles at her; and then has the audacity to demand the duchess give him the Tulloch Sgàthán so he could return the valuable mirror to its rightful owners.


Emma knew she very much needed a miracle. But God must truly work in mysterious ways, or have a unique sense of humor, if he had sent this handsome, arrogant rogue--the-most-unlikely-knight-in-shining-armor-ever--to come to her rescue.


But luckily for Emma, Ian Hamilton McNair, Scottish Earl of Buchane, and Laird of Trelawny, is no ordinary brigand!

*****

Along with her customary dramatic flair and the smooth, sophisticated writing her readers have come to expect, in her newest historical romance, A HIGHLAND DUCHESS, New York Times and USA Today bestselling author, Karen Ranney delivers an intricately complex and powerfully stirring emotional tale of the beautiful young Duchess of Herridge... A woman who'd been traumatized during her marriage by the perverted desires of a husband who had forced her to endure acts of depravity guaranteed to crush the spirit, and defeat even the sturdiest of souls.

And it's also the story of Lord Ian McNair, an intelligent and well regarded man of science. A man who upon meeting the Duchess is mesmerized by Emma's beauty--by expressive eyes that fascinated him, and spoke of untold secrets hidden in their blue depths. They revealed a strong woman of intelligence and wry humor, along with glimpses of darker, more painful emotions she struggled to hide. Ian doesn't care about the rumors surrounding the woman they call the Ice Queen. But can he convince Emma that he'll never hurt her? That he only wants to be the man that melts the ice around her heart, eases her pain, and helps her to heal. Beyond that, he's determined to be the only man she turns to for comfort, for the safety and sanctuary found in his strong, protective arms... and for the fiery passion in his tender, loving touch.

I loved Ian and felt he was a deliciously charismatic hero. He's a man great of intelligence, and a dependable, responsible, and undeniably honorable man. I liked that he was inquisitive by nature and eager to gain knowledge about the workings of the world around him and studied the biological sciences to help people. That he was smart and playfully roguish, added to his appeal, and fortunately, he was a much better scientist than a thief. He penetrated the barriers Emma had erected around her heart and mind with his offer of friendship, with a willingness to listen, to understand, and not to judge her, for the actions of her husband. And from Ian's personal dilemma, we also learn that when you don't love someone ... sometimes the greatest kindness you can do for them, is not doing what some people consider the honorable thing. Especially if by doing it you open that person up to a lifetime of emotional heartache, knowing their love isn't returned.

And I loved how the author gradually built up the sexual tension between Ian and Emma as their attraction and desire for each other grew. It felt extremely honest and believable, and the love scenes were both thrilling and intensely sensual.


Karen Ranney is a supremely accomplished writer and consummate storyteller. She crafts deeply emotional stories that are always engaging, passionate, and utterly romantic, and her poignant, inspiring and ever hopeful themes are guaranteed to tug at your heartstrings. She also has a remarkable ability to seamlessly weave relevant historical data into a thoroughly compelling and eloquent told narrative. In A Highland Duchess, the author delves into the darker underside of Victorian life and morals in a way that is insightful, penetrating and fascinating; by subtly revealing that society's secrets, rumors and innuendo for the unpleasant and disgraceful truths they sometimes were. It essentially challenges the widely popular view that Victorian culture was exclusively characterized by strong moral principles, propriety, personal restraint, family values and excessive formality. A closer look at history tells us that wasn't always the case.

I thought Emma was a superbly drawn character. She was tired of being the Duchess of Herridge, of being the cold dispassionate Ice Queen, though that was what had helped her survive, but she wanted to wipe the memories of it all from her mind... and be simply Emma the woman. And she wanted to feel healthy, honest desire and fiery passion for a man, for Ian, and to be a willing participant in their love making without any regrets, or the terrible shame and humiliation she suffered through with Anthony's lewd debaucheries.

I felt so much compassion for her, I wanted to cry for the heartache and misery she'd suffered. Her story gives you a hint of what life may truly have been like in the 1860's for woman, and how they were at the complete mercy of their fathers or husbands or uncles or brothers. Life was not always all pleasantries and tea parties for women, even the wealthy ones.


This is a story of two good, decent and honorable people, who were brought together by an extraordinary twist of fate. In the beginning they were two wholly different people... Emma was a wounded Duchess hiding from life, and Ian, a scientist who embraced life in all its wonder and glory. But together they'll learn that love truly can mend a broken heart... and... "WHEN THE HEART WAS OPENED TO LOVE, LIFE CHANGED."

This is a richly detailed, wonderful story... Highly Recommended!


Some other recommended books by Karen Ranney: Sold to a Laird,A Scotsman in Love, Scottish Brides, Tapestry Till Next We Meet, Unlikely Governess, An (Avon Romantic Treasure) ... and anything else by this author is a good read.

This is the second Karen Ranney book I've read, and based on those two novels I'm convinced the author has some major psychological issues. Her books have these brow-beaten women who are tortured by their circumstances and somehow come out the other side stoic yet with a happily ever after in the arms of a handsom man?? It's just too unrealistic based on the horrible things she writes -- it is much more likely that the women would either run away or kill themselves, but instead they just sit there and allow themselves to be tortured and then LAMENT about it for pages and pages. Ummm...no. These aren't romances. If anything, it is the anti-Austen novel, where life sucks and you don't even get to die. Oh, but don't worry ladies, some guy will sleep with you and make it all better. Sorry, but that's just not the way it works, especially when you've been sexually abused.

Don't get me wrong. I love a romance where the hero swoops in and saves the heroine too, but if that is what she is going for, she should tone down the atrocities that happen to the heroine. Sexual assault or physical or psychological torture aren't going to be fixed by a good shag and it isn't romantic to think so. Instead, it's unrealistic and sad. I hope Ms Ranney takes the money she makes writing these depressing novels and gets herself some therapy.

I really enjoyed this book to the point of not being able to put it down.I seldom give reviews but will this time as the story was well developed and everytime I thought I knew what would happen next I was so wrong . I will miss the characters and can't wait for the next book.

I wanted to like this book, I really did, but it just wasn't a good read for me. I won't rehash the plot of the book, as others have already done that. The thing about this book is that it is very slow paced, and it took too long for the conflict to get resolved, some parts were just really drawn out. I mean how long did we have to wait until Ian's cousin either died, or regained his consciousness and gave Emma an annulment? All the second part of the book dealt with Ian's cousin being sick and Emma taking care of him, and Ian and Emma suffering silently because he is engaged, and she's married to Ian's cousin who is a jerk, while they're both living under the same roof. I found myself skimming sometimes just waiting for something to happen. And while the lead characters were not unlikable, I didn't find myself caring for their story.

In the end, this was just an okay read that could have been better.

In 1864, a nervous Lady Emma arrives at Chavensworth to meet with her husband Anthony, the Duke of Herridge. She loathes and fears her cruel spouse and wishes him in hell like he has done to her. However, she is taken aback to learn her husband is dead. Known as the Ice Queen amongst the Ton, Emma wants to be a free widow, but her Uncle Peter Harding demand she marry again even before the acceptable mourning periods ends as he covets the money she would bring to him.

Laird Ian McNair breaks into Emma's boudoir demanding she return the Tulloch Sgathan that he insists belongs to the Scots, but she has no idea what the thief alludes to with this alleged mirror. When her uncle comes to lecture her, Ian knocks him out and abducts Emma. Ian is stunned by the passion he sees hidden beneath the veneer of the Widower. However though he wants to make her ignite, he knows she is betrothed to his cousin, Bryce. When Bryce suddenly dies, the Ton believed the cold haughty Emma is a black widow spider as many believe she poisoned him. Ian vows to prove her the victim of ruthless males including the real killer of his cousin.

A Highland Duchess is a superb Victorian romantic suspense starring a strong hero and a beleaguered woman. The amateur sleuth whodunit enhances an exciting romance as Ian begins melting the ice protecting his beloved's heart; but she trusts no man as all males, who should have protected her, since her dad died have been demandingly ruthless.

Harriet Klausner

I thoroughly enjoyed this novel because of the believable characters and suspenseful plot. It has a tragic Victorian heroine, a sexy, interesting love interest, repulsive villains, and a plot that involves a murder "who done it." It's pulp fiction, not literature that addresses the human condition, for heavens sake!
The sensual scenes are just that, sensual. They are not boringly descriptive as some novels are.
I have no idea why some readers gave this novel such poor reviews. I liked it very much.

I want to apologize right up front here about this negative review! I've read a few duds, as we all do, but honestly! I've NEVER read a book that was this demoralizing. It had not one single redeeming quality!

Karen Ranney has always been one of my favorite authors! And I've even enjoyed some of her scarred characters in the past. But this has to be THE MOST DEPRESSING BOOK I HAVE EVER READ!!! Not one single enjoyable moment, character, or storyline! (At least for me.)

SPOILERS

- Emma who is horribly abused and destroyed basically by her husband, Anthony the Duke of Herridge before he dies, NEVER gets even a moment to shine or become something different from the downtrodden victim she has become...so what does Emma's uncle do? Why find her another scumbag husband who can abuse her. Just so he can control Emma's fortune.

- Byrce, Emma's new 2nd husband arranged again by her uncle is almost as bad as Anthony was for crying out loud! Emma says she will give her uncle her fortune if he will let her go to the country to live alone but nope, he has to exact his pound of flesh from Emma too, so she is forced into marriage a 2nd time to Bryce who is - ready? Ian's brother.

- Bryce is ill and almost dies en-route to Scotland with Emma and we learn he has been poisoned with arsenic. Emma cares for him and they have not had their wedding night as yet. So you'd hope or think that when Bryce wakes up from his near death experience that he would feel at least if not magnanimous towards Emma at the very least thankful. Or at the very least offer her a house in the country she wants in order to live alone. Nope didn't happen.

- Ian's explanation, at the end, to his lifetime best friend Albert, as to why he's breaking his engagement with Albert's only child, Rebecca is TOTALLY lame! As it is to Rebecca...

- Rebecca takes over what little there is to be said when Ian ends their engagement and has NO reaction what-so-ever...again life long friends here, she was to be a countess, her parents only child.

- And Albert, Rebecca's father, a Dr. and scientist basically puts Bryce out of his misery at the end. So Ian wants Albert to turn himself in to the police because Albert smothers Bryce with a pillow claiming Bryce was dying anyway and not very comfortably at all.

- The mirror, the one thing that was somewhat intriguing is just totally dropped out of the story; lost apparently.

- Julianne, Emma's maid, the housekeeper Mrs. Turner, Williams, none of the staff who supposedly show looks of sympathy - never have a single moment of caring or voicing anything positive for Emma. Julianne is never brought to justice, and disappears into the sunset...

- From page 1 to the very end, it's totally depressing! I struggled to finish it and I don't know how many times and kept telling myself "Karen's going to turn this around here somewhere. She has to!" Nope! Didn't happen. And trust me. There's plenty more I could list. But why bother? I've already wasted my $ and time and I am so disgusted with this book!

I actually think I will stick a note of warning on it when I throw it into Goodwill! =( I'm Very disappointed in Ms.Ranney! I just hope this isn't a sign of books to come.

I love Karen Ranney, but some of her books are just too depressing! There was absolutely no humor anywhere, and it makes her characters boring and unrealistic in my opinion. We all smile sometimes, even at funerals.