3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
African Christianity viewed from an African perspective, April 11, 2010
Elizabeth Isichei's book is centered,appropriately, on Africa. Rather than describing the founding of the missionary societies in the West, and their expansion to Africa, she begins with a description of various African polities before the coming of Christianity, and then the encounter of the people in those societies with the harbingers of the Christian message, and the consequences of that encounter.
The author has a sensitive, objective, and balanced perspective, avoiding both the old-style hagiographies and the bitter new critiques that saw only cultural destruction in African Christianity. The book begins with a chapter each on Antiquity and the "Middle Years" (c. l500 to c. l800). The nine central chapters are distributed among five regions and, roughly, two periods, nineteenth and twentieth centuries. A final chapter covers events since l960.
Each chapter is constructed around well-chosen issues, such as conflict between Church and State, Christians and Muslims, and Christians and traditional political leaders; the relationship between the modern missionary movement and imperialism; missionary racism; the importance of education to Christianity in Africa; the causes of the acceptance of Christianity; Liberation Theology; attitudes toward polygamy and the celibacy of the priesthood,etc. Inculturation is one of the major recurring themes, as Isichei explores the dialectic between Christianity and Culture.
Coverage is balanced among Protestants, Catholics, and Independent African churches, both "Ethiopian" and "Zionist" types. While presenting the various factors in the rise of these Independent churches, she includes the aspect which some other analysts have ironically neglected, the religious one. She also points out correctly that far more African Christians stayed with the mission-related churches than went into the Independent ones.
In style, this book is like an African truck, filled to overflowing with startling facts and new interpretations, with some dangling inconclusively over the tailgate. If it loses the smoothness of a more integrated analysis, it gains in color and pungency.
Isichei shows a firm grasp of the vast literature not only of Christianity, but of African history in general. The current debates are understood, and contrasting interpretations presented. For a book of 420 pages chock-full of details, there are surprisingly few technical errors. Unfortunately there is no bibliography, but it includes copious end-notes and an index. The maps are nicely done, but need a listing. The back cover states incorrectly that this is "the first one-volume study of the history of Christianity in Africa". Peter Falk's The Growth of the Church in Africa appeared in l979, but Isichei's is certainly the superior one.
Something that the author does better than most is to allow the Africans to speak for themselves. The innumerable citations make one aware of the Africans as people. One feels that one is touching reality. And this is appropriate, for as she rightly states, while the most famous missionary names belong to the nineteenth century, the expansion of Christianity in the twentieth was largely the work of African evangelists.
Elizabeth Isichei is from New Zealand, spent sixteen years in Africa, and gave Igbo names to five of her children. This book is a child of another sort, but thankfully Africanized as well. And in today's climate of hostility toward and ignorance about Africa, that is no mean gift.
_______________
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A truly enormous story, January 4, 2008
Isichei conveys one of the most dramatic stories of recent history. It is a gigantic tale of passion and creativity, as African Christians claimed independence from colonial churches, launched a myriad of indiginized "new religions", and formed the largest movements of popular Christianity in the modern world.
-author of Correcting Jesus
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
0 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Gossipy politicially correct anecdotes, July 20, 2010
The title of this book is misleading for two reasons. First, only a single short chapter covers the years before 1500.
Second, it would be better titled "Some Politically Correct, Gossipy Anecdotes from African Christianity". Rather than writing a real history, the author gathers a few gossipy snippets from particular regions at specific times in history. Many of the anecdotes are political, about sexism, " white racism", colonism, or ism-ism. Any story about a woman may be included, no matter how minor her role in history. The faults of individual Christian missionaries are noted, perhaps with a guilt-by-association implication for the Christian religion in general. Any sort of bloodshed is considered sensational enough to be included, especially martyrdoms.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No