Most Helpful Customer Reviews
67 of 69 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fascinating History, August 22, 2009
This review is from: With Hitler to the End: The Memoir of Hitler's Valet (Hardcover)
Linge was Hitler's personal assistant from 1939 to the end, constantly by his side during that entire time.
This book has come out after another new release, "He Was My Chief" by Christa Schroeder. This is the first English translation of this work. The original publishing was in German in 1980. "Chief" is a new book that was released after Schroeder's death.
The books, while definitely different in style appear to paint a similar portrait of Hitler and his inner circle.
Linge's book is a personal memoir while much of Schroeder's book is gleaned from letters written by her to a friend. Both of these authors claim no knowledge of the atrocities committed by the Nazi government and unlike Hitler's other secretary, Traudl Junge, neither demonstrate any outward remorse.
What is fascinating about both books is the intimate look into the rulers of the Third Reich. You learn not just about Hitler, but many details of his inner circle.
The Linge book gives the reader a more detailed account of Hitler's daily interactions and life while the Schroeder book seems to give more detail in the whole atmosphere surrounding Hitler and his henchman.
Both works pretty much cover the same time frame in history and have many similar accounts. The reader walks away with a completely different view of Hitler and the German people from that available in history books or popular media. The country and their leaders are portrayed as people, with human aspirations and faults, and not mystical evil monsters under a witchcraft spell.
Perhaps that is what makes both books so incredibly important. What happened in Germany can happen anywhere. A nation can easily be lulled into complacency, accepting what they are told, controlled by manipulating leaders and an oppressive government. It demonstrates the importance of staying involved, always questioning and holding our leaders responsible for their actions.
If you are interested in Hitler and wartime Germany, both are a must read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
37 of 38 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent story from a first-hand personal perspective, September 17, 2009
This review is from: With Hitler to the End: The Memoir of Hitler's Valet (Hardcover)
Excellent story from the perspective of Hitler's valet; thus much of the material does not concern grand political strategies, but quotidian details such as Hitler's daily habits and health concerns as well as the author's personal feelings about many of the people constantly around Hitler (some of whom were in working capacities similar to the author himself, such as Hitler's physician[s], but also such figures as Himmler, Goebbels, Göring, Bormann and others; in regards to the latter the author provides interesting details on many of their personalities, the rivalries between one another, and the feelings of the headquarters "underlings" such as himself [Hess was beloved, while Bormann was despised, for example]).
Those looking for a work to either demonize or exculpate Hitler will be disappointed. There are numerous details and stories which serve to humanize Hitler, however, none of them are told in such a way that could be characterized as revisionist in the negative sense. (Things such as Hitler in his nightshirt changing a lightbulb by himself in his bedroom, or his problems with flatulence during the last years of his life.) Having said that the work does serve to humanize Hitler implicitly, although personally I feel that that is long overdue (Hess and especially Goebbels are also presented in a more positive light than is usually the case, while Bormann, Göring and the entire military leadership are seen as more flawed.)
Shone new light (for me) on certain events such as Rommel's suicide (the author thinks it was ordered by Bormann because of an old grudge from the Polish campaign) and Hess's flight to Scotland (the author thinks Hitler knew about it), as well as new events (for me) such as Hitler's effort to sound out peace terms from the West in 1944/5. Also includes periodic passages about the author's years-long interrogation (including torture) at the hands of the Soviets after being captured fleeing the Führerbunker.
Includes much discussion about the political power struggles that went on around Hitler, and how these affected domestic and foreign policies--there is much here to inform histories which all too often address events without taking into account the personal turf battles that take place in every government bureaucracy, fascist or otherwise.
There are periodic notes from the translator(?) about how other personal accounts from people at Hitler's headquarters differ from those presented here, but this is to be expected on a subject this volatile, with so many people having such a vested interest in being presented a certain way (along with the passage of time, and differing perceptions, of course). Having said that I found the author to be highly credible, and while I'm sure he has his blind spots, I think his story will be a valuable addition to histories of the time.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
31 of 32 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
What der Butler didn't miss!, December 14, 2009
This review is from: With Hitler to the End: The Memoir of Hitler's Valet (Hardcover)
" I had a theatre box on history, and remained in it until it collapsed..."
Thus speaks Heinz Linge, personal valet to Hitler from 1935 until the suicide 10 years later.
For those few (post-"Downfall") who still view Hitler as some kind of supernatural ogre or maniacal beast this book will truly be a revelation.
For the rest of us, intrigued as to who this man was, this book is another fascinating fragment in a compelling mosaic.
The best way to picture Linge is outside the Fuhrer's bedroom last thing at night and first thing in the morning. Never farther than arm's length from his master for the last decade of his life.
Linge comes across as apolitical although clearly intoxicated by his attendance on this human phenomenom.
There are some absolutely priceless vignettes to savour in this honest, even-tempered and even-handed account:
From the banal; Hitler kept a chest expander under his bed, he wore large cap visors to block out light
...to the bizarre; a woman claimed Hitler raped her, Hitler admired the man who tried to assassinate him in 1939 and utlised him to design other bombs,
to the exotic; Hitler and Eva caught embracing by Linge, Hitler possibly visiting his illegitimate child and former mistress during his tour of the WW1 battlefields...etc.
And that's before you get to the pen pictures of Bormann (a brute), Goebbels (engaging and loyal), Goering (brave but absurd) and Hess (loved by all).
An absolute cracker of a book with the pleasant and unpretentious Linge slowly descending into Hell. Unmissable unless you have no interest whatsoever in History and it's human carnival of characters.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
