From Publishers Weekly
Stereotypes have their uses. Just ask Bondanella, a professor of comparative literature and Italian at Indiana University, who has organized his study of Italian-Americans in film by examining conventional roles. Italians may be prominent as immigrants, boxers, lovers and gangsters, but Bondanella employs the categories to showcase the values associated with Italian culture, such as hard work and loyalty to family. He claims negative portrayals haven't prevented Italian-Americans from receiving full acceptance in American society, and he emphasizes their rejection of victim status to gain upward mobility. His critique covers a wide range, beginning with the classic 1915 tale
The Italian, which addresses immigration, to
Rocky and
Saturday Night Fever, and ends with
The Sopranos, which he treats as film. In a few generations, Bondanella notes, Italians have gone from outsider to ordinary citizen. In fact,
The Sopranos is his strongest argument for a multidimensional Italian-American portrayal, since its characters enjoy range: mob king to doctor, teacher to FBI agent. Not surprisingly, half the book examines the association of the Italian-American with the gangster milieu. Bondanella is intrigued by films that pair a criminal with an ethnic law-enforcement officer, the "bad-wop-and-good-wop theme," from 1909's
The Detectives of the Italian Bureau through 1997's
Donnie Brasco. Predictably, much of Bondanella's attention focuses on the
Godfather trilogy and the variations in Martin Scorsese's films that deromanticized the Mafia. Throughout, Bondanella offers engaging plot lines, astute observations and compelling behind-the-scenes tidbits, which make for entertaining reading as both cultural and film history. Photos.
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Review
“This is the overview that the field has been waiting for … . Bravo!” —Fred Gardaphé, Director, Italian American Studies Program, SUNY Stony Brook
"An engaging look at the Italian American of make-believe, as portrayed and marketed by others and by himself, as seen by others and himself." - NICK TOSCHES
“Bondanella documents the evolution of Italian American stereotyping in this interesting, well researched book.” – The Sons of Italy Book Club, Summer 2004
“He [Bondanella] expertly blends history, analysis, and commentary in an informative reference that is also an entertaining read. Recommended.” -Library Journal, 5/1/04 (Carol J. Binkowski )
“A top scholar of Italian literature and film at Indiana University… Bondanella turns his attention to the larger Dream Factory’s portrayal of Italians over nearly a century in Hollywood Italians: Dagos, Palookas, Romeos, Wise Guys, and Sopranos, a sweeping, scholarly, virtually film-by-film analysis of its subject. An so, with graceful scholarly confidence, Bondanella reflects in Chapter 1 on how ‘people are generally more sophisticated about dealing with stereotypes in their cultures than is generally assumed or acknowledged.’… In his comprehensive, common-sense approach, packed with full plot descriptions, Bondanella… cites Hollywood’s many positive depictions of Italians over the years.” –The Philadelphia Inquirer, October 5, 2004 (Carlin Romano
Philadelphia Inquirer )
"perceptive….essential for understanding how "the Sopranos" employs, celebrates and sometimes satirizes the images of Italian-Americans that have enabled Hollywood to transform this ethnic group into a mythical entity that embodies some of this country's deepest and most cherished ideals." --St. Petersburg Times, 8/1/04 (Tom Valeo )
"Hollywood Italians is...a tour de force of knowledge spanning nearly a century of Italian-Americans in American cinema." --The Italian Newspaper, December 2004 issue
"…When Bondanella traces the frequently distorted and unflattering representations Italian Americans have endured on screen he does so with a relatively light touch attuned to the artistry and fun of so many of these films." --Marco Calavita, Cineaste, January 2005
"With Peter Bondanella's 'Hollywood Italians' we finally have a thorough survey of the ways and means Italians have made and been made by Hollywood….Bondanella has done the field and the culture a great service by taking on such a grand study. Bravo!" --Fred L. Gardaphe, Fra Noi: Chicagoland's Italian-American Voice, January 2005
Review in Italian. –Rosso Fioventino, 3/05
“…an entertaining and information-packed book.” –Cineaste
“…this book is a valuable resource for the sheer breadth of examples and details he includes, and which span nearly a century of Hollywood cinema…” – Reconstruction 5.3, Summer 2005
“This is the overview that the field has been waiting for … . Bravo!” —Fred Gardaphé, Director, Italian American Studies Program, SUNY Stony Brook
"perceptive….essential for understanding how "the Sopranos" employs, celebrates and sometimes satirizes the images of Italian-Americans that have enabled Hollywood to transform this ethnic group into a mythical entity that embodies some of this country's deepest and most cherished ideals." --St. Petersburg Times, 8/1/04 (, )