49 of 50 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
I really want to like this book..., June 21, 2005
This review is from: Hollywood Knits: Thirty Original Suss Designs (Hardcover)
After knitting several patterns from this book, I'm a bit frustrated. I purchased the book because I loved the designs and the majority of the patterns I would either make for myself or make as gifts. There are hip, mod and sometimes quirky patterns and very wearable and stylish. If you're big into designer clothing, these would appeal to you. Suss has a knack for picking great colors, stripe patterns and texture and incorporating them into her designs. Everything seems to be knit on big needles with either bulky yarn or double strands, so it's great for instant gratification (I can complete a sweater in under 2 weeks) or last-minute gifts.
Now, for the gripes and source of my frustration.
The mistakes are numerous in the patterns and the corrections are confusing. There were 4 pages of corrections I printed off the Suss website. Some of the corrections are redundant with the information already in the book- maybe I have a later edition?- but sometimes the corrections themselves were wrong or I couldn't figure out where they belonged in the pattern. I'm a fairly experienced knitter, so if I get stuck halfway through a pattern, I can usually work things out or adjust the pattern. Sometimes instructions are given just for the small size, so you have to stop and think and figure out what to do if you aren't making a small. So I find little things like this to be annoying and perhaps something that a beginner would not pick up on and have a tragic end result. I would really have liked this book more if time was spent on editing and correcting the patterns- it seems like it was rushed to publication with no time to check these things. I don't want to be stressed out when starting a pattern hoping that everything will turn out alright.
Another gripe I have would be the pictures. Yes, I find it interesting to know who she designed the piece for, and in which movie, but the incessant name dropping is annoying and pompous, while the photographs reflect this. The focus is not on the garments, but on the celebrity wearers of the garments. In some pictures, sweaters are downright blurry, while the focal point of the picture is a beautifully illuminated face of a highly-paid model or actor. Please. I am a knitter. I know I like the sweater when someone that beautiful is wearing it and posing artfully and unrealistically. I really like the Yarn Girl's Guide to Simple Knits because the sweaters and garments are all displayed on a mannequin. No distractions and you can figure out by looking at a garment if it would actually look good on you or if it would make you look like you're wearing a fat suit. We're not all waif-like Hollywood types, you know.
One last thing...Suss uses, in many patterns, her own brand of yarn in which you can order on her website. It can be a little daunting to find replacements if you don't want to use her yarn, but it can be done.
Overall, I have mixed feeling about this book. I would only recommend it if you are up for a challenge (even though the patterns themselves are all fairly easy) and don't mind comparing yourself to stick figure with perfect features.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
UGH!, November 11, 2005
This review is from: Hollywood Knits: Thirty Original Suss Designs (Hardcover)
Incessent name dropping and unoriginal patterns loaded with mistake after mistake that only be made using "suss" yarn -- give me a break...don't bother with this one and save your money.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
21 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Book LOOKS great. Unless you're emaciated, it's a waste., March 19, 2005
This review is from: Hollywood Knits: Thirty Original Suss Designs (Hardcover)
I purchased this book, after reviewing it in the library. I found the Hollywood schmooze-fest annoying, but figured Suss thought it would sell books to celebrity lovers. I bought it, because there were a few designs I liked, and I wanted to be fair and not copy them from the library book. Silly me.
I noticed the sizes seem off. But I began knitting the two-tone halter anyway. I wear a size 6/8. I started the MEDIUM for the halter. I am now going to frog the whole thing. It looks like something for a Barbie doll. My size 12 stepdaughter realized that there is nothing in there she could knit for herself, other than a blanket or hat. I like the patterns, though they're embarrassingly easy (if you go to the Suss correction page first, of course). I can't understand why so much of the pattern selection is coded for "HOT KNITTERS". When it's so basic for even a beginner.
Bottom line? The photos are intersting. The patterns look cool (and I think that's mostly because of great yarn choices). But.. unless you have the body of a 12 year old boy, it's best to avoid this book. What a disappointment. Oh, and an earlier review mentioned that Suss's employee blamed the errors on the pattern maker, when on their websites' correction page, they blame the printer. I thought Suss designed her own patterns. What a disappointment this book was.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No