Customer Reviews

Holmes & Watson

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

I am a Sherlockian who is squeamish about pastiches and other non-Doylean Sherlockian attempts at portraying Holmes. Most of them seem overly contrived to fit the spirit and atmosphere of Holmes, and some are truly dreadful. As a result, I stopped reading pastiches around 1977, with the exception of a few written by friends. Given my judgemental attitude to these efforts, I am always worried when a friend of mine tries his or her hand at writing a Holmes story. In fairness, I must disclose that I have known Lee Shackleford for about 20 years, and I have seen the production of Holmes & Watson. When I first read an earlier version of the script, I picked it up with great trepidation. It was very good. When I saw a later version of it performed, I was pleased to be able to tell Lee in visceral honesty that it was great. I am not such a nice guy that I would do that if it was not. It is just the way I am wired.

Now comes a book version of the script that is as beautiful as the play is good. The production of the book is elegant, with wonderful photos of various perfomances of the play. I did not realize that Lee could look so much like Paget's Holmes. Having seen the play, I judged whether reading the script could provide the same measure of drama to several of the most thrilling scenes. It really does. It is a fun read whether you have seen the play or not. It keeps to the Holmesian spirit, explores the relationship between Holmes & Watson, provides thrilling moments, and has some fun with the characters, as well. You won't be disappointed.

Well-written, exciting play. Glad I have it in my library. Love the cover.