Customer Reviews

Homeland

5 star:		(6)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

When I picked up this book I was intrigued with his concept of a journey across the country to document the changes in American consciousness since 9/11.

I was startled and enthused as Maharidge uncovered the underpinnings of various and diverse, highly charged, emotional crosscurrents affecting the nation.

His dedication begins, "To the U.S. Constitution and the Bill of Rights . . ." So it is no surprise that parts of the book focus on the repression of opinions differing from mainstream conservative. Many accounts cover intimidation and lost jobs. But Maharidge doesn't stop there; he searches out and interviews both sides for their stories, which underneath have common threads.

Maharidge digs deeper than the surface tensions of neo-conservatives versus liberals, to address the economic crisis that has been building in the country for the last 30 years; the emotions of which, September 11 catalyzed to the surface in deeply divided positions in America.

The book is full of information, and reveals more controversial actions taken by the current administration after 9/11, such as the destroying of gun purchase records, (supported by the NRA) after the FBI had begun to find correlations to terrorists in the records.

He sets to rights such misquotes as, "my country, right or wrong." The correct quote, actually spoken by Carl Schurz, a U. S. Senator in 1899, goes: "Our country, right or wrong. When right, to be kept right; when wrong, to be put right."

In the last part of the book, Maharidge points out some parallels between the U.S. today, and W.W.II Germany, and actions taken by Hitler. While there are some similarities, he says the comparison is by no means exact, but it is worth taking note of.

All in all an engrossing and educational read that peels back the layers of extremism dividing the country, to expose common struggles and concerns.

Dale Maharidge and Michael Williamson's "Homeland" is the best book of 2004, and one of the most important nonfiction works ever published about the United States.

Maharidge travels through the United States observing the ways in which the attacks of 9/11/2001 have changed America and Americans. Many of these changes are obvious, but others are more subtle. With the seasoned eye of a trained reporter, Maharidge picks up on these changes and analyzes them with an amazing degree of insight. His conversations with ordinary Americans around the country reveal the different ways -- many of them downright scary -- in which the USA has changed over the last few years.

Much of the book deals with neo-McCarthyism and the distressing willingness of many Americans to give up their constitutionally-protected freedoms after 9/11. Maharidge chronicles many recent attacks on the Bill of Rights by local governments, the federal government, and "concerned citizens" alike. He also details the ways in which the 9/11 attacks fueled the latent racism that many Americans feel toward Muslims, resulting in tragedies like the white mob that attacked a Chicago-area mosque on the evening after the attacks.

Maharidge makes no secret of his left-wing perspective, but that doesn't mean this book is a political tract. On the contrary, he bends over backwards to be fair and non-judgmental toward the people he interviews, even when he's talking with white supremacists and other unsavory characters. Maharidge has his own opinion, but thankfully, he also has a genuine desire to understand events from the perspective of those who differ from him politically.

Michael Williamson's photographs are also superb, as usual. Whether it's a telling shot of weary workers riding home in a subway car, or a shot of racist white motel owners trumpeting that their establishment is "owned by Americans," Williamson's photos poignantly capture the America that exists today.

This book takes you to places where the places mainstream media refuses to go, and covers issues that most so-called "reporters" would never touch with a 10-foot pole. With the 2004 election coming up, now is the most important time for Americans to understand and act upon the issues Maharidge discusses in this book. Do yourself a favor: If you read only one book this year, make it this one. Few more important works have ever been published.

"Homeland" is Dale Maharidge's best work to date, and he's done a lot of wonderful work over the years. His research is thorough-going, his connection with his subjects is spot-on, and his anecdotes are insightful. "Homeland" is much more than a prosaic string of interviews. Maharidge threads them masterfully and meaningfully to draw revealing and often frightening conclusions. His notes at the end illustrate the energy and determination of an enterprising and resourceful journalist. Maharidge is a master craftsman of the heartland.

This is a great book! This book is also incredible. It describes the mood of the nation between 9/11 and the economic meltdown. At the same time it is revealing that things weren't so great before 9/11. Our problems were in the making for a few decades. It gives an excellent description of our political climate and it is compared with other totalitarian regimes of the past despite the fact that we are not there yet.
The book is written in a simple journalistic way, the authors are journalists. It's relatively short and very worthwhile for the price.

I read and loved "And Their Children After Them" for its patience, its sincerity and its in-depth look at middle-class workers. "Homeland" contains little of the same effectiveness. It mostly recounts politically-relevant news happening in the 2-3 years after 9/11. There is very little focus on the economic troubles of families existing before 9/11 (as promised in the book summary). The first 1/3 of the book follows the trial of Katie, a high-school student. The other 2/3s of the book simply relate loosely connected interviews and news reports with very little insight that can't be gained by looking around the internet. Even the white supremacist who was interviewed is given only a very shallow description, and this person, whom the author calls a "failed product" of US society, is actually remarkably similar to the hero Katie in some respects. The author seems to be heavily influenced by internet media and opinions. I would recommend this book to people in other countries who have a hard time understanding the presence of US nationalism after 9/11. For the most part, though, it is not particularly insightful or unique.

This book offers a good look at the rise of nationalism in this country after 9/11. The stories of dissenters offer a peak into this country's fear of non-Christian foreigners. Couple this fear with racial prejudice, ignorance of history, ignorance of non-Christian religions and an economic shift from middle class paying manufacturing jobs to low paying service jobs and you get a society primed to follow an authoritarian leadership that offers a source for the public to vent it's anger. Non-Christian foreigners become the enemy and anyone that does not blindly follow the government's message becomes ostracized from the society with labels like "liberal" or "unpatriotic".

The author also makes comparisons between post 9/11 America and the period before the rise of Hitler. His theme is: when a country faces economic uncertainty they tend to follow more authoritarian leadership and an event like 9/11 can be exploited by the authoritarian leadership to instill fear and a sense of security through blind faith and loyalty to the government. Many call it patriotism because it makes them feel good, but it is more accurately defined as nationalism. The real stories of teachers, students, lawyers, etc. offer some unique insight into the post 9/11 culture and what "freedom" means to many American's when they feel threatened.

I can't add to the superlatives of the other reviewers of this book. I learned about this book by accident; C-SPAN had taped a talk with the author and photographer. Somehow, my edition (received from Amazon) was actually signed by the author!

I will say this: It ought to be required reading for anyone seeking public office in the US or, for that matter, anyone who plans to vote in this nation. The stakes are simply too high and Americans are dangerously veering towards Fascism.

My only hope is that this year's election results will mean that I need not buy a stack of these books to give as holiday gifts!

I read most of the book last night and was disturbed by several things - The author deliberately blurs the line between "Arab" and "Muslim." He calls non-Arabs "whites," and makes whites sound like low class, trailer trash, uneducated red necks. Aren't Arabs white? I was offended that he mentioned Danny Thomas as an example of all the fine Arab people who have come to US to find a better life. Yes, Danny Thomas was Arab, but not a Muslim. Maharidge quotes an Arab comedian as saying that there's so much discrimination against Arabs. But unless they point out that they are an Arab, how would one even know? How can you treat someone different, unless they point out how different they are?

I have personal involvement in two of the stories quoted in the book, and know that facts presented are incorrect. I think it's grossly incompetent and irresponsible for an author to present a work of nonfiction without verifying his information.

Knowing that some of the facts are wrong, I would look at the rest of the book with reservation. Maharidge treats those he perceives to be the underdog with sympathy, but paints those who speak against them as ignorant, uneducated bigots.

Maharidge's premise that contemporary America dangerously resembles the Weimar Republic, or "Heimat," that led to Nazi Germany is an oversimplification of the current government of the US. This proposition is deliberately anti-administration, inflamatory, and a grab for publicity.