Most Helpful Customer Reviews
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
An epic quest without an ending, July 23, 2006
I have never read anything where the author is so frustratingly self-involved and yet so amazingly lacking in self-awareness. The whole book is a poorly written festival of whining.
The writer spends the book searching for a cure to one ailment after another--all using her parent's money. Anytime they don't automatically pony up with the money she whines until they give in (bad enabling parents, bad, bad!).
I was amazed that anyone could go through the process of writing such a book and not start to gain some sort of self-awareness. For example: Jenny complains that she needs an operation. The doctor does not want to do it. Jennie demands it. After having the operation she's told by some lay person that the operation was a bad idea. Jenny then rails at the doctor for butchering her. Has she forgotten that she was the one that demanded it against medical advice?
The saga of how she took more pain medication than she was supposed to and then got painfully constipated is another example. (Jenny, if you're reading, don't take more pain medication than you're prescribed, and if you do, accept the consequences, don't blame it on others!)
Then we get to hear how hard she works at getting better by spending weeks and weeks at a spa (yet again spending her parents money while contributing nothing to society--unless you want to argue for the Bush theory of "trickle down economics").
The final insane leg of the journey is a trip to South America (yet again paid for by money wheedled from her parents) to visit a healing guru. As much time or more is spent talking about what kind of souvenirs she bought as anything about her visit with the guru (who charges a fee for bottled holy water in the gift shop. Yes the healing guru has a gift shop!) Money wisely spent.
The whole book ends with Jenny saying she has not found any significant resolution to her quest but that she will continue to do basically the same thing she's done throughout the book over and over again until she finds what she's looking for!
The most unfortunate thing about all of this is that this book actually got published and that Ms. Lauren got paid an advance more than twice what most Americans make in a year!
This book has no insight whatsoever. Anybody who thinks that this could be a good book for others with eating disorders should know that it will leave the reader frustrated and with the sense that there is little hope for a cure even with more resources than 99% of the population. If anything, this book is a badly written portrait of self-pitying self-centeredness enabled by privledge.
Ultimately, I feel for Ms. Lauren. She is obviously dealing with a lot of pain. I just don't think that the book she wrote is of enough value to share with the world. If anything, it's probably done Ms. Lauren more harm than good because her whining must feel more legitimate now that it's in print. Maybe the final blame should go to the editor who believed that the Lauren name would sell enough books to turn a profit no matter how unworthy the content.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Unexpectedly Poignant, April 19, 2004
This review is from: Homesick: A Memoir of Family, Food, and Finding Hope (Hardcover)
I expected very little from this book, to be honest. But how wrong I was. Each time I was about to conclude Ms. Lauren is a spoiled brat, she would surprise me with her actions, intelligence and most of all, her elegant and honest writing. It was sad, however, to read about all the time and talent Ms. Lauren has wasted on her disease. She is clearly a sensitive and thoughtful person who on some emotional level cannot get past a desire for the perfection of an imagined life. Sad because so many women fall prey to this and end up ruining the natural beauty that comes from inner peace. Not only could I not put this book down - spent all day Saturday engrossed - I have not stopped thinking about it. Ms. Lauren grew up with grueling expectations of beauty. Her discipline was Olympian and she paid a steep, horrible price for trying so desperately to control her body. I am so thankful that Ms. Lauren was courageous enough to show the unglamorous side of anorexia. When I was growing up attending an all-girls' private school during the 1980s, anorexia was fashionable - the thinner the winner....We had no concept of nutrition, of muscle tone or of antioxidants and healing therapy. It was an era of laxatives, ipecac, vomiting and self-denial. Unfortunately many of the books that came out about anorexia at that time- "The Best Little Girl in the World," "Second Star to the Right" and "Goodbye Paper Doll" - all made anorexia sound like a great way to get attention, fit into lots of clothes, and even find boyfriends. Thanks to writers like Marya Hornbacher and now, Jenny Lauren,the uglier side of eating disorders is being revealed. Thank-you to Ms. Lauren. I hope she will keep us all updated on her progress.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
TEDIOUS, May 14, 2004
By A Customer
This review is from: Homesick: A Memoir of Family, Food, and Finding Hope (Hardcover)
My sister died as a result of an eating disorder. No one understood her. The sad thing about this book is that only through escapism has the author been aided. I think that doctor's misguide patients, routinely. I did not care for this book though. I felt it was whiny and an unending pitious vent. I wish the author well in her recovery, but am sad I wasted the money buying this, "poor rich me" rant. The author should be thankful for the family support and the freedom she has enjoyed instead of focusing so intently on the crackhead, the sexual acting out, etc. She really has problems and I hope she finds herself or healing or anything good. I would not recommend this book as it has affected me negatively.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|