Amazingly, the RAA remains unsigned despite recording one of the best indie rock albums of decade. Made up of only three members, lead vocalist and guitarist Nils Edenloff, and two percussionists Amy Cole and Paul Banwatt, their sound is simple, raw, honest, varied, and astoundingly refreshing.
This band has been steadily building up an impressive internet following. Despite not being signed to a record label, Hometowns made a number of year-end top 10 lists on music blog sites. The album placed #10 on the year-end Metacritic user's poll. In November, the band was signed as an eMusic Selects artist on the independent internet music store eMusic. Hometowns has since become the best selling eMusic Selects album ever.
Despite the RAA being only a trio, the songs on Hometowns are surprisingly varied. The range of the band is highlighted by the country-like acoustic riff of the second track "Rush Apart", which stands in stark contrast to the explosive punkish electric guitar in "The Deathbridge in Lethbridge". No matter the style that the RAA undertakes throughout the album, the strengths of the band shine in each: Edenloff's plaintive and emotionally honest vocals which have evoked numerous comparisons to Jeff Mangum of Neutral Milk Hotel, Banwatt's energetic drumming which is reminiscent of Brian Devendorf's work on The National's Boxer, and Cole's pitch perfect harmonizing.
Although the lyrics are simple, they are earnest and often effective. "Frank AB", which discusses a terrible mining accident in the town of Frank, Alberta, ends with a chilling outro "Under the rubble, of a mountain that crumbled, I will hold you forever." Perhaps the most stunning moment of the album occurs on "Don't Haunt This Place", when Cole's backing vocals create a pitch perfect harmony for the chorus, while Banwatt's energetic drumming playfully intermingles with gorgeous wistful cello. It's a spine-tingling moment that truly highlights the desperation and longing of the lyrics "Because we need this oh so bad".
The album ends with "In the Summertime", a summery ballad which features the most astounding lyrical image on the album "Once in a while, I know our hearts beat out of time/ Once in a while, I know they'll fall back in line."