Most Helpful Customer Reviews
165 of 178 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not So Great, August 14, 2007
This review is from: Hooked: Write Fiction That Grabs Readers at Page One & Never Lets Them Go (Paperback)
This book, like others have written, features great instruction on the art of writing modern fiction, particularly that imperative hook. For me, however, the author's often insightful suggestions are completely obscured by his own partiality. He cites 4 to 5 of his own openers (because they're just that great), and truthfully, they don't warrant the inflated, self-confessed praise that Edgerton gives to himself. Other examples are largely extracted from short stories, not novels. These two genres are separated in necessity and style by miles; therefore, Edgerton's haphazard melding of the two detracts from his overall goal. If you're willing to overlook the author's self-indulgence and swallow the superficial, hollow and often displeasing examples of other "amazing hooks" provided in this manual (as I reluctantly did), then by all means, go for it. But I found that, by the last page, my suspension of disbelief had long disintegrated. There are too many examples of poor, elementary and sometimes laughable writing in this book to believe that all of the publishing industry looks solely for 7th grade style, bony, misdirected language and various forms of mind-numbing instant gratification when it comes to the search for worthy literature. Please note that my above comments do not negate that this book has some formidable insights and admirable suggestions regarding structure and the ten components of an opening. But I think that many excellent writers out there deserve better advice from a better source. So, whether you decide on this nifty blue book or not, remember this sentence: "He was so mean that wherever he was standing became the bad part of town." "He was so mean that wherever he was standing became the bad part of town." "He was so mean that wherever he was standing became the bad part of town." And... well, you get the idea. By the last page, you will know this sentence as you do your own name. It's Les Edgerton's own "whopper" of a hook, and he claims that most people couldn't resist reading on from a genius opener like that, although he willingly admits that "it's my own story and one should at least appear to be somewhat humble". Personally, after the fifth citing of this same (and very bad, film-noir-esque) sentence, it made me put the book down. It took a while to pick it up again, and longer still to trudge through the spontaneous flashes of very blatant boasting. I couldn't get past it, but maybe you can. Make your own judgments. These are only mine.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
32 of 33 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Get Hooked!, May 30, 2008
This review is from: Hooked: Write Fiction That Grabs Readers at Page One & Never Lets Them Go (Paperback)
Let me start by saying I am a writer. I completed my first novel early last year and eagerly sent out queries to publishers and agents. Many requested partials, so I mailed the required 50-100 pages, and then waited. All turned me down. After two more rounds of queries, partials, and rejection letters, I decided I needed a little help. So I headed to the local bookstore where I found the wonderful book, Hooked. I devoured it. Underling, highlighting, folding corners, and re-reading until I could apply everything I learned within it's pages to my manuscript. And it paid off. My novel, This Time You Lose, was just named a finalist in the Strongest Start Novel Competition. It has also climbed the ranks to number 5 (out of over 500) in the Readers Choice Top Ten Novel Competition. In addition, I have now secured an agent in New York, and am putting the finishing touches on my manuscript before re-submitting it to publishers. All of this within 3 months of purchasing and reading this book. I've recommended this book to other writers, both online and in person. And I continue to refer back to the pages of Hooked with each new story I write. Chris
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
49 of 54 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A MUST-HAVE for every writer, May 20, 2007
This review is from: Hooked: Write Fiction That Grabs Readers at Page One & Never Lets Them Go (Paperback)
This is probably going to be one of the most treasured books on craft on my library shelf. The author claims it's a book about beginnings, but it's about a whole lot more than that! It analyzes what makes a brilliant beginning to a novel, and talks about the components of an opening scene--and what makes a potentitally good beginning go bad. All well and good. And here is the true beauty, I think. It then goes into discussing the Inciting Incident as a trigger for the Surface Problem and the difference between the Surface Problem and the Story-Problem. You see, the surface problem (or problems, which is the usual case) are the obvious things your character and your readers are aware of, but the story problem, the deep down issue which nags at the character and drives the plot forward, and which may not be evident until the plot's resolution at the very end, is the key to the success of the entire novel. The reader does not necessarily have to know and/or understand the story-worthy problem before the end and in many cases shouldn't. BUT THE WRITER MUST. And I didn't. Not until I started reading his book and started really thinking about my book. And then all the issues that I'd been confused about, all the questions about lack of focus, everything that had been one great big question mark in my mind, suddenly vanished. I know where I'm going now. I know what I'm about. And I don't have to do a great big rewrite. A small tweak here and there, perhaps, but no big rewrite. And the writer's block that has had me blog-hopping, playing with prompts and looking for other excuses not to sit down and work, has vanished as well. I wish it had come out years ago.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|