Customer Reviews

Hope and Honor

5 star:		(13)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This is the gripping memoir of a child Holocaust survivor who immigrates to the US, enlists in the Army and works his way up to Major General in the US Special Forces.

The story begins with the horrors of the Lithuanian Holocaust death camp (Kovno) described through the eyes of a young, naive boy. Shachnow tries to make sense of his small world as his life quickly spirals downward. I found the brazen anti-Semitism displayed by Lithuanians alarming and disturbing. Shachnow watches helplessly as his mother is violently raped and family members are robbed, tortured, humiliated and brutally slaughtered, one by one.

To make himself less vulnerable to extermination, Shachnow performs excruciating work on a labor detail where a malicious guard bludgeons him unconscious with the back of a shovel. Rail thin and slowly starving to death, his hair and toenails begin to fall off from malnutrition but he narrowly escapes the death camp on the eve of it's liquidation. The Holocaust portion is without a doubt the most harrowing part of the book.

After immigrating to the United States, Shachnow must adapt to his new life in suburban middle-America. The Americanization of this young, unassuming refugee from post war Europe is at times poignantly heartbreaking and at other times laugh-out-loud hysterical. Still unable to speak English, he attends school for the first time in his life, tries Coca-Cola (tastes like medicine!), loves rock-and-roll, learns to play football, and does his best to fit in.

This book shines light on how important it is for immigrants to integrate in order to succeed. In one particularly heartrending episode young Shachnow discovers the disturbing truth that his father is a sad failure at assimilating into life in America. He surprises his unsuspecting dad by showing up at his "engineering office" only to awkwardly stumble upon him in the restroom, bent over, scrubbing dirty toilets in a janitor's uniform. Shachnow keeps his father's shameful job a secret from his family, but must work long hours after school to help them keep their heads above destitution and poverty.

The journey continues as Shachnow enlists in the US Army to escape his controlling and demanding family. He labors his way from Private to Sergeant, getting into fist fights and rowdy bar room brawls along the way. He gets his act together, attends Officer Candidate School and is sent to Viet Nam along the Mekong River with his Special Forces unit where he eludes death by a hair's breadth more than a few times, winning two purple hearts and a silver star in the process. Amazing.

The story rounds out as Shachnow is inducted into Berlin's "Detachment-A" -- a cold war, covert unit secretly imbedded into Special Forces. The true identity of this clandestine unit was concealed, it's existence denied, and it's missions classified. In order to blend in, Det-A personnel dressed in civilian clothing made in East Germany, grew their hair longer and learned to walk, talk and think like Easterners. They carried Eastern European documentation & identification and were on high alert 24 hours a day, every day. I would have loved to read more detail about these cloak-and-dagger operations but perhaps some of it is still restricted information.

During the fall of the Berlin Wall and the end of the cold war, Shachnow is assigned the position of Berlin Brigade Commander. The story culminates with a great twist of irony as Shachnow's assigned military home is the same house that Nazi General Fritz Reinhardt owned and lived in during WWII. A residence where Hitler and his cronies attended parties and dinners. (Fritz Reinhardt was Hitler's Finance Minister).

An ordinary man caught in many extraordinary circumstances, Shachnow's story is told with straight forward warts-and-all honesty and a self deprecating sense of humor. All in all, a truly engaging and inspirational read.

I just got the book the other day but finished it already. It's the first book I've read in years that I just couldn't put down. It is a facinating true story. This is a truly amazing tale and with some great humor. I loved it!

This is the best book I've read recently and I heartily recommend it.

The first and most harrowing part of the book deals with General Shachnow's childhood and miraculous survival of the Holocaust. The protagonist of the story is primarily Shachnow's mother -- an extraordinary, quick witted and determined woman. It is mainly due to her efforts and incredible daring that both her children (one of whom was a mere toddler) survived, while pretty much everyone around them perished. Her strength through the war and the heartbreaks and challenges of the family's post war experiences were to me the most touching and heartrending aspect of the book. Shachnow does a fine job at crediting his mother's extraordinary sacrifices and bravery, but also touchingly describing her weaknesses and eventual failures.

The second part of the book, which in some ways is just as touching, deals with the Shachnow family's move first to post-war Germany and then to the US. The immigration experience was particularly rough on General Shachnow, who arrived in the US as an unschooled and traumatized teenager, but managed, through toil and faith to complete high school successfully. Shachnow's parents fared less well. They seemed unable to transition to the new culture and its demands. Shachnow speculates that his mother had used up all her strength and ingenuity to survive and therefore found herself unable to cope with the new world. Shachnow tells us how the graceful heroine of the Kovno Ghetto turns into a nagging, selfish and small-minded woman, whose behavior inhibits her and her husband from succeeding in their new life. In one of the saddest parts of the book, Shachnow describes his break from his family following his marriage to a non-Jewish girl -- an event that his family treated with neither wisdom nor grace.

The final part of the book is devoted to General Shachnow's military career, starting with his enlistment as a private at the end of his high school studies. His rise to the rank of general is described with humility and is of much interest, though, like other reviewers, I wish it was more extensive.

This is an extraordinary book. In part it made me cry (the touching love between the brothers and the terrible heartbreak of Sidney's parents experiences in the US) and in part it made me wonder. But most of all -- the book inspired me. This is the story of the incredible power of love to save lives, to give meaning to existence. It's the story of familial ties and their challenges. This is the story of the ultimate inevitability of success to those who are sufficiently persistent. And finally -- it's the story of true patriotism and leadership. It's a must read.

I heard the book on CD (Blackstone Audio), read by the excellent Brian Emerson.

This is a wonderful book that is filled with memories of a life that reads like fiction. Major General Shachnow is an amazing man, led an amazing life with courage and strength above and beyond most people. The stories of his childhood are heart- wrenching and yet they show the beginnings of this boy's growth into the man he became.
The only complaint I have about the book is that some of the recollections seemed to be cut short, I would just be getting into a story, wanting to know more, and the author was on the way to something else! I sometimes wonder how people survive the many hardships they have in their life, and Major General Shachnow had his share of hardships plus some. And of course, his joys and happy times as well. They are all told in this book with honesty, humor and matter of fact humility.
This book was a gift, and I'm grateful that someone gave it too me, I had not seen it in the stores. Read this book, even it you don't normally read memoirs or non-fiction, it is well worth it.

How often are we supposed to remember the Holocaust? Seeing it through the eyes of a 7 year old, makes this one of the most profound survival stories ever. And kudos to Sidney's Mother, whose strength of will and ingenuity got them through history's darkest years. I honestly could not put this book down, and although Sid is an immigrant to this country, it made me proud of our constitution and mad at Hitler all over again.

This is an extraordinary story of strength, courage and love under the most trying conditions imaginable. After surviving the Holocaust as a boy in Nazi-controlled Lithuania, Sidney Shachnow eventually emigrated to the U.S. with his family to start a new life. Risking his life in defense of freedom as a career soldier he truly gave back so much to his new homeland. As such Gen Shachnow's story serves to remind us of the real meaning of American patriotism, which, sadly, in not taught in schools the way it formerly was.

This book makes an equally valuable contribution to American literature as Gen. Shachnow made to the U.S. Army. Unlike so many celebrity autobiographies, which are little more than self-agrandizing fluff-fluff, this book presents the story of Gen Shachnow's life in a painfully honest manner. From cover to cover it is the forthright story of a real man and a real human being, warts and all. That Gen. Shachnow has no trouble being as open as he is with his readers further attests to his bravery and character.

Excellent book. I have read MG Shachnow's military bio, heard stories about him from other soldiers, and met the man on more than one occasion - but the book brings to life with vivid details the trials and tribulations of a real-life hero. This true story is more captivating than any fictional character and story could be.

A remarkable story wonderfully told. Had my complete attention and was fascinating in every respect. The best gripping memoir of a personal tragedy, perseverance and ultimate triumph.

I bought this book based on a very good review in "Vietnam" magazine. The story of MG Shachnow's life from surviving the Holocaust to becoming the #1 officer in Special Forces makes for an intriguing biography.

The first part of the book is amazing and provides for a very personal and emotional description of a young boy surviving the holocaust in Lithuania. I highly recommend this first half - the emotions and details are chilling.

The rest of the book covers his military career in a very general way, i.e. without a lot of depth to his experiences. I wish that the book had been made into two volumes, with even more time spent on his childhood and early experiences afterwards as well as a second volume going into much more depth of his experiences as a soldier. To me it seemed that just as a topic was getting interesting, the chapter ended and a new topic was introduced (and then cut off). I would happily have read a 500 page volume 1 and a 500 page volume 2.

The writing style is adictive and the content intriguing. The only criticism is the lack of depth in his military experiences (the main reason I had bought the book).

This is a fascinating tale of survival in Lithuania, and the grit and hussle that Shachnow brought to the US as a teen-ager to rise to the rank of major general in the US Army Special Forces.