Most Helpful Customer Reviews
42 of 46 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Truely moved by this book, May 16, 2007
This review is from: The Horse God Built: The Untold Story of Secretariat, the World's Greatest Racehorse (Hardcover)
I just finished "The Horse God Built". I sat down on my couch with it this morning and started it. I couldn't put it down except for a few convenience breaks. I almost forgot to eat! There have been some wonderful books written about Secretariat, and I've read all of them I could find. Mr.Scanlan goes a step further by including the most important person in Secretariat's life...Eddie (Shorty) Sweat. He did this without overlooking a moment of Secretariat's life and his wonderous accomplishments. Eddie's story only added to the beauty of Big Red's story by Mr.Scanlan and it wouldn't have been complete without it. Eddie would have been so proud. I'm still shaken from reading this book. I sat on my couch and read until I finished all 335 pages, including the index. Those pages had me totally hypnotized. I smiled, I laughed, and I cried. Thank you, Lawrence Scanlan for taking me back to Secretariat once again. You took me on a wonderful, exciting journey and I enjoyed the ride so much. I will cherish this book, as I will all my books, photos, prints, and clippings of this magnificient horse. You taught me things I didn't even know about BigRed. I learned things about other great Thoroughbreds along the way. Thank you, thank you!! Suzanne Whitaker a Texan and an ardent admirer of the horse God built.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
33 of 37 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Great Magazine Article, June 20, 2007
This review is from: The Horse God Built: The Untold Story of Secretariat, the World's Greatest Racehorse (Hardcover)
Mr. Scanlan, the winner of numerous magazine writing awards, has written another great magazine article. Unfortunately, Mr. Scanlan has written a book instead that does not support his story line past twenty pages. The thrust of the story is that Eddie Sweat, Secretariat's groom, was a super guy who did a fine job, but got left out of the shuffle of recognition of all those who made Secretariat great. Perhaps all of that is true. It is great that Mr. Sweat is getting some focus now. The book just does not have all that much to say past making the acknowledgement of Mr. Sweat's place in the historic picture. Some of the principles involved in the story Mr. Scanlan writes (my great privilage to know them) have told me that there are many errors of fact. For what I know first hand, Mr. Scanlan never says anything absolutely wrong, and certainly not with malice, but he is careless and he does fall back on others to suggest interpertations that do not reflect reality. For example, Scanlan, again not directly, bemoans the preservation of Secretariat's birthplace, Meadow Farm, as the new home of the State Fair of Virginia. This shallow conclusion is made from the car window conversation he had with site scavengers. So much is incorrect with this brief passage that it would take too long to detail, but the main point Scanlan misses is that the Meadow would have been turned into 10 acre "farmettes" had the Fair and Caroline County not worked together to keep the Meadow intact. A "farmette" is hardly the fitting end for Secretariat's birthplace. Now the Meadow will house an equestrian museum that will honor Secretariat while the site will once again become a center of Virginia equestrian events. One phone call would have put this story right. Somehow, the scavengers were unable to brief Scanlan on these plans. Two Books that Secretariat fans should read are Raymond Wolfe's "Secretariat" (snappy writing along with many amazing images), and Bill Nack's authoritative, "Secretariat: Making of a Champion." Both are fine works.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
23 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Glad it was a gift & I didn't pay for it, June 7, 2007
This review is from: The Horse God Built: The Untold Story of Secretariat, the World's Greatest Racehorse (Hardcover)
If you're expecting "The Untold Story of Secretariat, the World's Greatest Racehorse" or the "Untold Story of the Bond Between Secretariat and his Groom" as proclaimed by the book's dust jacket and editorial reviews, save your money because the book offers neither. Scanlan, who admits he is new to the world of horse racing & Thoroughbreds, reveals his novice status in his inability to find a focus for the book. Although he states repeatedly throughout the book that he's writing a book about Secretariat and Eddie Sweat, he doesn't deliver on that promise. He doesn't tell a "story" about horse or groom as promised in the title. What he could have titled the book is - "People and Places in the Lives of Secretariat and Eddie Sweat, and Seldom Discussed Dark and Unpleasant Truths about the Racing Industry and Life on the Backside, and Other Details I Learned about Thoroughbreds along the Way." What little he actually writes of Secretariat he gleans from Bill Nack's Secretariat: The Making of a Champion and Raymond Woolfe's Secretariat. While he may have written other books about horses, Scanlan doesn't possess the depth of knowledge to write about Thoroughbred racing. Read his description of the athletic challenge faced by racing jockeys on pages 20-21 and then read Laura Hillenbrand's description on pages 70-73 in her book Seabiscuit, and you'll see he's totally out of his element. Mostly, he writes like an old gossip gathering bits and pieces of others' memories and getting nasty digs in about owners and trainers. He's pleased to give readers the second-hand "dirt" he's dug up, even though he reports that Eddie Sweat and Charlie Davis (Secretariat's exercise rider) never wanted to see any of their complaints in print. What a big disappointment this book is. If readers are avid fans of the turf and the careers and lives of great race horses, stick with Nack and Woolfe if you want the story of Secretariat. There's nothing new about him here.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|