7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Quite Unrealistic, February 22, 2009
This review is from: A Horse to Remember (Perfect Paperback)
This book certainly had the potential to be great.But in the end it was very unrealistic, quite possibly a simple case of a writer just being too young.
Just a small thing I want to point out is the part in the book where Jeremy and Elise go off riding and the very moment they mount they start cantering, these are supposed to be experienced and knowledgeable riders, they should know that you never start cantering immediatly.
Also, Satan, since he is a mustang from the BLM, would have been gelded for safety reasons. All male horses captured by the BLM are gelded unless they are planning to have them re-released in the wild.
Then there was Jeremy's horse Splash. Jeremy said he couldn't jump for his life because he was a 16 year old Quarter Horse. I for one know quite a few horses with Quarter Horse blood who are good or even excellent jumpers. I also know plenty of horses 16 and older who jump just as well as younger horses.
For Hilary's first show, Susan had told her that she was ready to do a walk-trot-canter class, which I found very unrealistic. She'd only been riding a few months, it was foolish of Susan to advise her to enter a class that she obviously was not ready for. More unrealistic still, at the end of the summer, Hilary was jumping 3 foot 6 plus on Satan none the less and going to this huge competition. Impossible for many reasons. For example, most riding instructors do not allow their students to jump at all until they have been riding at least a year. Hilary just wouldn't have the skills and know-how to jump even a couple feet when she hadn't even been riding 6 months.
This book had its flaws, but was overall decent and could have been great. Even though it was a bit disappointing, I think Juliana Hutchings has a bright future as a writer. Hope to see more from her in the future.
P.S. I didn't like Jeremy at all, he acted like a jerk.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Determination, Persistence and a Dream, April 13, 2007
This review is from: A Horse to Remember (Perfect Paperback)
After a recent move to rural Tennessee, Hilary Thompson took a summer job at the Millbrooke Stables, adjacent to her new family home. A wild mustang stallion, Satan, had just arrived at the stables for training. Recognizing his loneliness and need for friendship, Hilary established a trust with Satan and worked to tame and train him for competition in jumping events.
This is a story of a bonding between animal and human. It is a heartwarming story of earning trust and finding friendship. Juliana Hutchings writes with maturity and insight. She has an amazing ability to use dialog to draw the reader into identifying with the emotions and feelings of her characters.
Photo silhouettes created by Isabelle Hutchings convey a feeling of warmth, trust, and devotion and bring the narrative to life.
This is a book that every young reader and rider will enjoy. Juliana communicates her own lifetime of experience and love for horses as she carefully takes the reader through the various steps of training, for both rider and horse. She includes a very helpful glossary of horse terms.
"A Horse to Remember" gives promise of more to come from this young gifted author. This is an amazingly well written first novel. I highly recommend it for pre-teens, teens, and the young adult reader.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
BEST BOOK EVER!!!!!, January 27, 2011
this is a great book! its something that all horse lovers can really relate to, that first love and what it feels like when you gain their trust! by far the best horse book i have ever read and trust me, i've read a lot!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No