Combine short stories with steampunk and you have two of my favorite pastimes. Add a dash of romance and even this cynical 40-something is along for the ride.
Editors Jean Rabe and Martin H. Greenberg have assembled a satisfying tome worthy of any enthusiast of steampunk or romance. As with any anthology, there are winners and some not-so-winners, but none that I would call losers. That alone says a lot for this book.
Because Hot & Steamy touts itself as both 'steampunky' and 'romancy' I've given each story a letter grade for its success in either category.
A=Excellent
B=Good
C=Fair
D=Poor
F=Fails
"Chance Corrigan and the Queen of Hearts" by Michael A. Stackpole is an adventure-filled story that was fun to read. It was a great opener for this collection.
Romance: C
Steampunk: A
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
"Absinthe-Minded Archaeologist" by Vicki Johnson-Steger is hurt by the author's overuse of telling versus showing. Additionally, the entire premise of the story was too obvious.
Romance: D
Steampunk: C
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
"The Problem of Trystan" by Maurice Broaddus was a confusing story with a high percentage of misplaced pronouns. I lost track of the number of times I had to stop to re-read a section so I could decipher which character was speaking.
Romance: D
Steampunk: F
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
"Clockworks" by Jody Lynn Nye is a well-paced love story populated with living characters about whom the reader truly cares. Also, it's not your average steampunk story where dirigibles and automations are throw in as an afterthought. In this one, the steampunk (an artificial heart) is integral to the plot and fascinating. This was my favorite story of the entire book, and I look forward to sampling other works by this author.
Romance: A++
Steampunk: A+
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
"In the Belly of the Behemoth" by Matt Forbeck is another story that suffers from too much telling and not enough showing. The abuse of clichés also lessened my enjoyment; but it was the racial stereotypes - even for the time period - that left me with a sour aftertaste.
Romance: F
Steampunk: D
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
"Automata Futura" by Stephen D. Sullivan is a slow tale with no discernable story problem, too much filler dialogue and the pacing of a nap. Additionally, the 'surprise' ending was visible from the start.
Romance: F
Steampunk: D
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
"Love Comes to Abyssal City" by Tobias S. Buckell is the anthology's most unique story. I realize that steampunk is a subgenre of science fiction (some would say of fantasy), but this story takes steampunk to a new level by establishing a future society that moved back to steamy tech by choice. Fascinating.
Romance: B
Steampunk: A
----------------------------------------------------------------------
"For the Love of Byron" by Mickey Zucker Reichert is a sweet story, if a predictable one. However, if you removed the few hints of steampunk, you would be left with what this story really was: a historical love story. It feels as if the author added the steampunk elements later to make a sale.
Romance: A
Steampunk: D
----------------------------------------------------------------------
"For Queen and Country" by Elizabeth A. Vaughan reminds me of The Parasol Protectorate by Gail Carriger, but without the humor. The story is fun, but again an overuse of telling versus showing hurts the tale.
Romance: C
Steampunk: C
----------------------------------------------------------------------
"Grasping at Shadows" by C. J. Henderson was a difficult story to get into due to some poor word choices and awkward sentence structures, but once those smoothed out, the story flowed better. A good action piece, I felt the ending came out of nowhere.
Romance: D
Steampunk: A
----------------------------------------------------------------------
"Go Forward with Courage" by Dean Leggett was full of short, choppy sentences that made it a difficult story to read. The dialogue was too contemporary for the time period, and the story was rife with historical inaccuracies, even for steampunk.
Romance: F
Steampunk: D
-
---------------------------------------------------------------------
"Her Faith is Fixt" by Robert E. Vardeman. While the romance was too convenient to be believable, the steampunky action more than made up for the sloppy love story.
Romance: D
Steampunk: A+
---------------------------------------------------------------------
"Kinetic Dreams" by C. A. Verstraete felt rushed and incomplete, almost as if the author was facing a deadline. Had there been more, I think this one could have been much better.
Romance: D
Steampunk: D
---------------------------------------------------------------------
"For the Love of Copper" by Marc Tassin almost lost me because the author does not seem to understand how to use pronouns. The repeated overuse of the character's proper names irritated me to the point that I almost stopped reading. Then, in the last two pages, the story became one of the most heartwarming tales I've read in a long time. Kudos for the twist that surprised this jaded reader, and I'm glad I didn't give up on the story.
Romance: A
Steampunk: A
---------------------------------------------------------------------
"Cassandra's Kiss" by Mary Louise Eklund is a slow, boring story that feeds the reader important details at the wrong time. I found myself wondering if the editors put this one toward the end hoping to lull their readers to sleep.
Romance: D
Steampunk: F
---------------------------------------------------------------------
"Dashed Hopes" by Donald J. Bingle was a well-written and well-reasoned story, if a tad depressing. Again, I questioned the editors' intentions for slotting this one as the last story in the anthology.
Romance: B
Steampunk: A
In conclusion, this book is more steampunky than romantic. I wonder if that's because 10 of the 16 authors were male. While they handled the tech well, often times the male authors confused sexual intercourse for romance. I'm sure by some definitions, sex and romance are one in the same.
However, I prefer my romance to be the good, old-fashioned tug-at-the-heartstrings-type. Those stories are present in this anthology and for that reason, I recommend this book as money well spent.