24 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Welcome to the Hotel Majestic, December 26, 2006
This review is from: The Hotel Majestic (Penguin Mysteries) (Paperback)
Georges Simenon was the author of over 100 Inspector Maigret mystery stories. They were immensely popular in the 1930s through the 1960s. Inspector Maigret stories also appeared in film and TV version. Simenon also authored dozens of books described as "romans durs", `hard stories' that had a darker tone than his Maigret novels. Simenon seems to have fallen under the radar in recent decades but in recent years he seems to have been rediscovered by a new generation of mystery/detective story fans. Penguin Books has begun to reissue some of those Maigret mysteries and the New York Review of Books Press has reissued some of his `hard stories', dark novels that did not feature Inspector Maigret. Penguin's latest Inspector Maigret Mystery reissue, "The Hotel Majestic" is as good a place to start for anyone wishing to discover (or re-discover) Simenon.
As with most police procedurals, the Hotel Majestic begins with a dead body. Mrs. Clark, a guest traveling with her wealthy American husband, their child and a governess, has been found murdered and stuffed into an empty locker in the basement of the Hotel Majestic. Maigret arrives to begin the investigation. His investigation quickly draws him into two parallel words: the world upstairs of champagne and caviar and the world downstairs filled with hotel employees eking out a living. Maigret's investigation begins with an examination into how and why these two different worlds collided in this brief but deadly incident. From there he proceeds to interview everyone and anyone who might have information about the crime of the victim. Maigret is no Sherlock Holmes. For Maigret, crimes are to be solved by a process of accumulating as much information as possible and then analyzing that information based on his past experience. Maigret plays hunches to be sure but Maigret's chief weapon is perseverance and determination. Consequently, the reader is presented with information about the crime and the protagonists in real time along with Maigret. As I read these stories I find myself absorbing these bits of information and trying to weigh them against the information previously disclosed. This served to keep me engaged throughout the book and caused me to keep turning page after page until the `final curtain'.
Simenon has a keen ear for dialogue and character development. Maigret is not a character that is revealed to the reader immediately. Simenon doesn't set about to provide you with a character map to Maigret's personality in any one book. Rather, he grows on you over time. He has an innate disdain for higher authority that is appealing. Simenon's settings and other characters also add a dash to his Maigret mysteries. These are not parlor room mysteries where the reader has to determine which upper-class member of the gentry (or the butler) committed murder most foul in the library. Simenon's stories have the feel of grit and the demimonde about them that adds a bit of spice to the `formula'. In Hotel Majestic, Simenon's description of the hard-streets and dark bars of Paris and the people that inhabit them all seem quite fully realized to me.
All in all, I find Simenon's Maigret mysteries to be consistently entertaining. They may not be as dark or foreboding as the novels released by New York Review of Books - but it you like well-written, taut, police procedurals you will like Georges Simenon's Hotel Majestic. Recommended. L. Fleisig
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Upstairs/Downstairs ala Parisian, February 23, 2009
This review is from: The Hotel Majestic (Penguin Mysteries) (Paperback)
"The Hotel Majestic" is one of many of Georges Simenon's deftly written Inspector Maigret stories that play beautifully against a backdrop of mid-20th Century Paris. In this case, it's two consecutive murders in the service basement of an up-scale Paris hotel circa 1938. This particular Maigret tale takes a sympathetic look at some underclass souls who have labored for years in hotels and clubs making life entertaining and undemanding for the wealthy and privileged.
Early on in "Hotel Majestic," it seems as though the working class will take still another hit to preserve convenience and tranquility for the rich. But Inspector Maigret has no patience for convenient solutions, no particular affection for the upper-class, and ultimately prevents a miscarriage of justice that would make the lives of the working class characters in this tale more miserable and difficult.
As always, author Simenon provides the reader with a rich and sustaining period environment which is worth the price of the book alone. This is a good mystery with an even better context. Recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Simenon unsurpassed., September 23, 2008
This review is from: The Hotel Majestic (Penguin Mysteries) (Paperback)
Georges Simenon is peerless in his genre, and I strongly encourage any of you who have not read his novels to get with the program. One caveat: it can be addictive. I especially like the "romans dures" but the detective genre is raised a big notch with the Maigret works made popular on the PBS series. And the best news of all? He wrote hundreds of books.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
