Most Helpful Customer Reviews
80 of 81 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Welcome to the world of e-marketing, August 28, 2010
**PLEASE READ THROUGH TO THE ADDITION AT THE END**
This isn't a review of the book per se, but a warning to other Kindle owners as to what to expect from this freebie. You are about to get what you paid for. Harper Collins should be ashamed at themselves for rushing to market a very poorly scanned edition of one of Jance's older works in order to plug her newest book. It's what literary marketing has become, and it won't change until we readers start complaining. While it's hard to complain about something given for free, I feel a small entitlement since I've been a faithful Jance fan for 20 years. I've paid my dues with many full priced books.
That Harper Collins would allow this to be published without having even an intern proof the OCR for miss-reads is a sad commentary on the greed of the publishing world. Let me say this as clearly as possible: this book is painful to read.
One of the joys of reading a good book is being transported via the author's skill to another place and immersing yourself in the world they've created. I find it virtually impossible to do that when the gibberish typos keep drawing me back to the real world. Don't misunderstand- I will put up with the OCR mistakes in many other free ebooks when they are classics that have been scanned and formatted by volunteers. For a world-wide leader in publishing to do so is beyond excuse.
Additionally, Amazon should be ashamed for using the e-publishing date instead of the original 1991 publication date.
When all is said and done, this is a good book marred by sloppy publishing. It's not Jance's best, but it is still a worthwhile read if you are willing to deal with the jarring typos.
**9/22/10- As I discussed in the comments which follow, Ms. Jance got this fixed! If you've previously downloaded the typo laden version, you'll need to delete it (go to "Manage My Kindle" and click the plus sign next to the title, then delete) before you can download this one. I haven't looked at the revised edition yet but I have faith that it is what it should be.
I have to give a grudging thank you to Harper Collins for making this right, but mostly this was due to Ms. Jance's efforts. We corresponded several times after I brought this to her attention and believe me when I say her concern for her readers was very evident. Congrats JAJ!!
I have also upgraded my rating to 4 stars, which is what I said I'd have given it without the typos.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
47 of 49 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Many flashbacks, but still good, August 25, 2010
I haven't finished the book, but wanted to go ahead and write part of a review. It took me a little bit to get into it, because it's set in 1975, and has frequent flashbacks to explain how the characters got to the current point in their lives. It also has stories/legends from the local tribes. I'm assuming they are real, since this book is set partly on the reservation. Because of all the flashbacks, it took a while for it to really gel for me, but now I'm really enjoying it. Some of the unwritten social commentary is especially telling, looking back at how differently society treated women in the 1970s, as well as American Indians. Having lived in the Southwest, I can tell you that some things haven't changed.
The main problem with the book is not the author's, but the publisher's. I'm at 70% finished and I am running into a lot of typos, including misspellings and lost punctuation marks. It's like who ever published the digital version got 2/3 of the way through and decided to hell with the rest of it. In fact, some of the misspellings look like what you get from a bad OCR (scan) job, which, since the original was published in 1991, is entirely possible.
That said, it's still a good book. I've always enjoyed Tony Hillerman's novels, and this gives you a more feminine perspective.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
36 of 41 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Climax was nastier than expected & My Rating Plummeted, July 14, 1998
By A Customer
This review is from: Hour of the Hunter (Mass Market Paperback)
Until the end of chapter 20, I planned to give this book four or five stars. I enjoyed the native legends. I cared about the two heroines, Rita (formerly Dancing Quail) and Diana Ladd, not to mention Diana's young son, David. The flashbacks to the characters' pasts were absorbing. However, I hated what happened to Diana in the climax. Ms. Jance gave us plenty of warning that her villain was a homicidal sociopath. That was enough for me. I didn't need for Diana to suffer as she did. True, what she went through was probably no worse [and didn't last as long] than what the heroine went through in *The Hellfire Club*, but that was by Peter Straub. When I read his books (or those by Stephen King or Barbara Hambly, etc.), I know what I'm getting into. I'd read only three other Jance books before this one, and they certainly didn't lead me to expect that the climax would be so brutal. What made that climax even more offensive to me was that Diana, up until then, wa! ! s portrayed as a reasonably smart and strong woman preparing for the probablity the psycho would be after her. Suddenly she jettisons most of her brains and common sense so the psycho's tricks work. I don't accept the period the book is set in as an excuse for her [initially] poor showing. Years before Diana was even born, my Granny took a frying pan to the head of a big drunk who was trying to beat her up and knocked him out cold. I admit that the book improved once Diana got her smarts back. I liked the end. I'm sure I would have enjoyed this book more if I'd known what I was letting myself in for. Well, you've been warned. Enjoy. Tip for readers: "Tucson" is pronouced "too-sahn", not "tuck-sahn." Ann E. Nichols
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
