Customer Reviews

Houses of Study: A Jewish Woman among Books

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

The little I know about Judaism comes from novels I have read by Chaim Potok, Henry Roth and Michael Chabon. None of these have offered the unique, first-person perspective not only of Jewish women, but especially of Jewish women scholars.

Blumberg's preface to Houses of Study lays out a fundamental tenion: that between the traditional role of an Orthodox Jewish woman and that of a particular Orthodox Jewish woman who aspires to honor both her religion and her personal desire for knowledge and advanced study.

The story of Blumberg's religious and academic education unfolds against this backdrop. She tells the story beautifully. Her desire for immersion in studies, such as her male counterparts at Yeshiva receive, is aching and intense. That it parallels her developing woman's contemplation of love and union enhances its intensity and sensuality.

We follow her journey from the midwest to Israel to the east coast an on. Blumberg is a trustworthy narrator.

A bonus for this reader was the concurrent education in Jewish history, culture and religion. Hebrew words were used but also translated to English spellings and definitions. I could follow her story but still feel that it was written by Jew, for Jews.

In short, this is a richly-described, morally-tensioned account of one woman's exploration of gender, religion and scholarship. Well worth the read.

Cerebral and sensuous all at once, hugely passionate but completely controlled -- hands down the best book on the readerly life that I have read. Anyone who wants to know what it means really to study the Bible should own this book.

Ilana Blumberg takes her life and her choices seriously and writes about them clearly. How refreshing and impressive! I am looking forward to reading the continuation!

I was really excited when this book came into my hands. I felt that it told part of my story--Blumberg had been to places where I had been, Barnard College in New York, Brovender's Yeshiva in Jerusalem and understood, it seems the fundamental though generally unacknowledged tension between the two. What I found instead was a book that was ill organized and rambling, as if I were reading the pages of Blumberg's diary instead of a mature, well concieved work. Blumberg certainly has much to say, but she hasn't said it, not in this book, in any way that is useful to the thoughtful reader. I can't believe that she got this published.

I enjoyed this book. The language Ilana Blumberg uses is exquisite and one can truly get a sense of her struggles and thought processes. I recommend this to everyone.

Nothing new or interesting or not a cliche. Don't pretend to be Orthodox if you're not.

i felt very incomplete when i finished reading this book. i just wish that i had waited to get it at the library instead of buying it. i truly feel like i wasted my time in reading this book.