Most Helpful Customer Reviews
31 of 32 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Amazing book, far better than I imagined it could be, October 4, 2005
This review is from: How to Cook Your Daughter: A Memoir (Hardcover)
As soon as I heard Jessica Hendra was writing a book, I knew I wanted to read it. I found a book store that put it out this weekend (Amazon said it wasn't supposed to be released until today), so I guess I got a bit of a jump.
First, I loved her dad's book, Father Joe - until I heard about what she says he did to her. I was skeptical at first, not because I didn't believe her but mainly because I wanted to see it in her own words. When I read the story in this book, I was even more flabbergasted than I was when I read about it in the NY Times.
This book is amazing. It's truly a great read, mainly because it isn't just about the allegations about her father but more about her entire childhood growing up in this unique and bizarre household. It is a story that unfolds just as it did for Jessica Hendra. It resolves around two storylines - the present and the past. And they intersect at the end. It allows you to understand what shaped her, and why she came forward - courageously, in my opinion - after hearing about and reading her father's book. She even confronted him about it and gave him every chance to come clean.
This book is a must-read for anyone who read Father Joe. I say that because it made me wonder about Father Joe, the book, and what it was really about. I mean, supposedly, it's about Tony Hendra's moment of clarity - when he sees his failures, confesses them and "saves" his soul. If Jessica Hendra is to be believed (and anyone who reads this book will come away believing her, I predict) then not only did he not confess it, but he continues to compound his sin by now trying to discredit his daughter (I think he called her "pathological.").
As an aside, I noticed that Kathryn Harrison who wrote The Kiss reviewed the book rather dismissively for Publishers Weekly (it's the one posted above). I find that astounding, given that what happened with Jessica Hendra seems far, far worse than any tragedy that befell Ms. Harrison, who, if I recall correctly, had a consensual incestuous affair with her father. How that equates with a child being molested - and how Ms. Harrison can suggest Jessica Hendra's book is unimportant - is more than befuddling. It's outrageous.
Regardless, I noticed other critics are hailing the book, and I would concur. I read it in one sitting (never intending to) and found it powerful, wonderfully told and, surprisingly, uplifting. More than that, compared to her father's book, I knew this one was honest.
Don't be deterred by the notion that it's difficult to read. It's just the opposite, and the parts that are meant to be difficult are brilliantly told in a way that makes them sink in without turning off.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
22 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A powerful memoir, November 28, 2005
This review is from: How to Cook Your Daughter: A Memoir (Hardcover)
I found this book to be an engrossing memoir of growing up in the Seventies in New York, and although incest was certainly the catalyst for writing it, the main focus is on this particular family's bohemian lifestyle rather than the actual incidents of incest. The book is insightful, honest and very powerful. I have read many other memoirs in the past few months, among them THE GLASS CASTLE and OH THE GLORY OF IT ALL, and HOW TO COOK YOUR DAUGHTER, though very painful, is a sincere and positive effort on Ms. Hendra's part to deal with situations which almost completely overwhelmed her. When I first heard of Ms. Hendra's incentive for writing this book, I was a bit skeptical as to whether this would be in her best interests, but after reading it I am totally convinced that for the sake of the emotional health of her own family, it was very important for her to confront the issue head-on in response to her Father's own memoir, FATHER JOE. This book is so much more than a book about incest. It is a poignant and remarkable look at an unusual family where a father's bizarre and often brilliant sense of humor and his total lack of concern or interest in his family's welfare brought intense pain and confusion to those he claimed to love. It was a family in crisis, with each individual
member trying to survive in her own way. It seems very clear that Ms. Hendra has made very positive choices in her adulthood, and fortunately in this case, history did not repeat itself; she was smart enough and strong enough to take all the negative aspects of her own childhood and turn them around so that her own daughters are being raised with the good values and unconditional love that her parents were unable and unwilling to give to her and her sister.
As far as I'm concerned, anyone who enjoys reading memoirs and learning about the way other people deal with life will find this one right up there with the best of them.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Heartfelt, amusing and gripping, October 4, 2005
This review is from: How to Cook Your Daughter: A Memoir (Hardcover)
Okay, I didn't expect to like this book. I'm not into tell-alls and that's what I figured this one would be. It's not. The story is obviously built around Jessica Hendra's decision to finally challenge her father after he professed that he had earned salvation by a lukewarm confession that apparently failed to include what he did to her.
But this book is really about what it was like to grow up in the 70s comedy scene and how, in many ways, Hendra's childhood became hijacked by her father's "humor." The thing is, she isn't really complaining about that part of things. I think she even says at one point that she wishes the other things her father did didn't eclipse the eclectic nature of her upbringing.
As a reader, I was drawn to the behind-the-scenes stuff about the National Lampoon and the infighting there, and also to the brilliance and dysfunction that is her father.
What it became in the end though was a story that I found pretty universal: how someone who could've cowered in the corner the rest of her life found the strength to become her own person.
It's beautifully written, in a way that feels true and honest and genuine. I think at times I felt as though I wanted her to be more angry at him. But maybe that was because I was learning for the first time about this behavior and she had dealt with it her entire life. The story flowed wonderfully and easily, and I really struggled for a place to stop reading so I could make lunch.
Bravo, Jessica Hendra. It's nice for a change to see a supposed "tell-all" that isn't about slinging dirt and is more about finding oneself amid chaos and calamity.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|