Customer Reviews

How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb

5 star:		(503)
4 star:		(233)
3 star:		(142)
2 star:		(114)
1 star:		(363)

 

 

U2, known primarily for grandiose convictions, an intense desire to be the biggest band in the world, and a huge, guitar-driven sound with soaring vocals, have become rather conservative in their evolution. Retreating from their 1980s work, U2 primarily focused on broadening their artistic pallette, bringing in electronica, techno, and other weird fusions. This created a problem with U2's fan base as the decade drew to a close, because the farther U2 strayed into the eclectic musical territory they were pursuing, the more difficult it was for the fans to follow their evolution. When U2 experimented successfully, they made some of the most successful music of their career (ACHTUNG BABY). Yet they grounded their experimentation with a sense of purpose, and they always kept their ambition within the elasticity of the fans' and critics' admiration. At least, they tempered their music with a good dose of rock in the early 90s. ACHTUNG BABY, one of their most experimental, evolutionary records, has been universally hailed by both fans and critics alike as some of their most significant music. ACHTUNG BABY set the course for much of the decade, with U2 going more and more into post-modernism.

Then the 1997 nadir POP happened. Not that POP was necessarily a BAD album. Instead of sounding a natural progression of the band's ambition, the experimentation never really gelled, much like R.E.M.'s UP. POP comes across as torn between two different directions - the anthem-driven, spiritually aware U2 lamenting a loss world, and a strange, dance-driven beat that is supposed to celebrate living with almost primitive desire, instead of commenting on the moral and social decline of earth. Both a critical and commercial flop, U2 seriously re-evaluated their status as artists after POP, and streamlined their sign, making a very conscious return to their earlier sound.

In 2000, U2 delivered the followup to POP, ALL THAT YOU CAN'T LEAVE BEHIND. The title is more than aptly representative of that album. Abandoning wholly the more progressive elements of their music, LEAVE BEHIND sounds like U2 trying to write a classicist record, returning to the styles of their 1980s output. While it was fun to hear them return to that era, ALL THAT YOU, out of necessity, didn't have a lot of artistic evolution. That wasn't the point.

So it's little surprise that U2, has streamlined their music even more on HOW TO DISMANTLE AN ATOMIC BOMB. While their early records were both revolutionary and a thrill to listen too, and the early 1990s work pure genius, HTDAATB is a much more calculated record, made to sound like classic U2 instead of just being U2. U2's experimentation had gotten them in trouble, and this is the result. U2, instead of playing the music they want to play, are now playing to win back the audience that much of their 1990s work alienated. In many ways, like Essau yielding to Jacob, U2 has traded their birthright for porridge, selling their artistic evolution out for trying to be the biggest band in the world.

Although POP did have some unmitigated disasters, at least it was the old U2, wedded to pushing the envelop with cutting edge music. That's the real irony of HTDAATB; the new U2 is returning back to the old styles to win back the fans, while the old U2 was much more interested in creating worthwhile music, combining their ambition with their musical sensibilities, growing artistically and commercially. This is a record that the old U2, after making the records they did in the 1990s, would never make. The old U2 would keep pressing on, pursing their musical evolution. But POP happened and U2 has been reeling ever since.

While this may seem to be a primarily negative review of U2's latest effort, there are some postive notes. While artistically a puzzling, entirely too conservative affair calculated to win back fans, there's some great music here. The lead off-single, "Vertigo," is jagged guitar rock. "Crumbs From Your Table" plays like we're back in the 1980s. "Love or Peace" is an interesting comment on war. "Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own," written in 2001 when Bono's father died, shows us Bono at his most vulnerable. "Yahweh" (or to be strictly orthodox, YHWH), gives us U2 at their most spiritually thirsty. It has great music and a great sound, but that doesn't make HOW TO DISMANTLE AN ATOMIC BOMB the instant classic ACHTUNG BABY and THE JOSHUA TREE are.

U2's end result is rather a half-breed. HTDAATB is much too conservative and calculated to be truly revolutionary and an undeniable classic, but also just too good to write off completely (mostly because U2's trying to recreate an era of their career where they were writing and performing fantastic music. Hence my four star rating, though artistically it's three). For the causal fan, this may be a subtle point; it has a warm, big sound, and has excellent music. For those who loved U2 for being fearless pioneers will be rather disappointed.

In ways, I belong to both camps. There's some wonderful songs here. But I miss U2's sense of adventure.

[There are three songs left off the album that I am aware of. One, "Fast Cars," has surfaced on the UK and Japanese pressings as a bonus track. The band did covered Kraftwerk ("Neon Lights"). There's a non LP track on the second "Vertigo" single, "Are You Gonna Wait Forever?"]

I only heard a short clip of Vertigo prior to buying this. When I came here to make the buy, thought I would see what some of the other citizens thought of it. As I read the reviews, a few idle thoughts came to mind, not listed in any order of importance:

Several people expressed dismay that the sound of U2 has changed. There was disappointment that the Edge may not still have that "edge" that separated him from so many other second fiddles that stood directly behind many group's headliners. There was an abundance of lamenting concerning Bono not possessing that "Bono Vox" he has given the world for the almost thirty plus years.

After reading the reviews and listening to this, I found that it is a work that is exactly where it should be. It sounds like U2 should sound today. It is reflective of an incredible musical career that is beginning to span two generations. And it is the sound and contains the energy and drive that makes U2 what it was....what it is today, and what it will be remembered as.

I did not buy this hoping it would sound like "The Unforgettable Fire". I already own "The Unforgettable Fire" and am very content and satisfied with the way it sounds. I bought this with a reasonable expectation that I would hear a musical group in the autumn of their career still putting out some of the best, most original and undoubtedly most creative musical work on the planet. And I was not disappointed....I don't think you will be either.

Album: How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb

Artist: U2

Simple: Don't build one. That's the best way to dismantle an atomic bomb. I didn't come up with that (I read it in another review). Yes, I know this album came out a long time ago (in the music buiness last Thanksgiving may as well be forever ago) but it's taken me a really long time to ponder HOW TO DISMANTLE AN ATOMIC BOMB (HTDAB). First, let me say that while I love it when band's experiment....thank God U2's mid-life crisis is over and they've returned to their roots. Both this album and their previous effort, ALL THAT YOU CAN'T LEAVE BEHIND find U2 leaving behind the dark, noisy Euro-Disco scene and returning to arena rock (where they belong). HTDAB is fab...and U2 lets you know right off the bat with "Vertigo" a gee-whizzbang homerun/grandslam of a song. Yeah, so what if Apple and Clear Channel have run it into the ground? They were able to do so because it kicks so much ass! Bono and company wisely slow things down with the second (artier) track "Miracle Drug." I personally found it to be my least favorite track, but this could be caused by an acute adrenaline overdose left over from "Vertigo." The third track, "Sometimes You Can't Make it on Your Own" is the soul brother of ALL THAT YOU CAN'T LEAVE BEHIND's "Kite." Both songs sprang from Bono's adult relationship with his dead. Whereas "Kite" was about moving out, "Sometimes..." is about moving on (after the death of a loved one). The song is truthful and moving. Bono's gift for laying his feelings all out for everyone to see in this song will silence critics who accuse him of pandering and being a sell-out. No one sells out by writing a song like "Sometimes..." Next, "Love and Peace or Else" is a noisy, post-Pop manifesto for peace (by making threats). This song seems like a statement to those super activists who end up becoming the very thing they are fighting. Peace, should be born of love-not frustration and anger. If "Love and Peace or Else" were a road, "City of Blinding Lights" would be the destination. This song is classic U2, and is one of the stongest tracks. I love Edge's guitar work (his songs are always so fresh and unique). The song also has my favorite lyrics on the album "the more see the less you know/ the less you find out as you go" only a mature, world-weary Bono could write a universal truth like that (and sing it with such conviction...so much that my 21 year old ears automatically take the statement as fact rather than opinion). "All Because of You" another great single, is well...a great single. Not as fast as or furious as "Vertigo" but it's not meant to be-it's a great U2 love song. Speaking of love songs, "Man and a Woman" the next track is probably the best 'I don't understand love' song written. Totally encapsulating the whole 'what the hell is going on here' feeling of man and woman's relationships, the song features some great guitar work and brilliant chorus."Crumbs from Your Table" sounds like vintage U2, again the chorus is strong (the 'cool down mama' will stick inside your head for days). The album's weakest track is stuck down there at the bottom (where an album's weakest track belongs). The song, "One Step Closer" isn't really bad, just not very memorable and seems like a U2 song we've already heard. "Origin of the Species" and "Yahweh" close HTDAB, on a uplifting-hopefull note. The spiritual side we've all come to expect from U2 rears it head, and unlike many political bands, keeps from being preachy (while still making it's point). "Yahweh" alone is worth the purchase price of the CD (I think). A love letter to God...the song will break your heart with it's 'always pain before a child is born' chorus and humble before-the-universe lyrics. I love this album, and the band who made it. Many might dismiss U2 as a Dinosaur of the '80s, a relic still trying to cash in on their essential rock classic THE JOSHUA TREE-but HTDAB is proof positive that U2 tough (but willing to wear their hearts on their sleeves). I was, however, a bit dissapointed that the album didn't really seem to touch 9/11 or the War on Terror (I desperately wanted U2 to tell me everything was going to be okay). Upon further consideration, I realized that any attempt to do so would be an act of futility-also songs of healing and hope (like "Yahweh") are more in line with what this world needs right now (not "The Angry American").

This is a top notch CD. Unfortunately, there are many sad people here posting under fake accounts just to wail on this CD. Especially Roberto Diaz who is really GDB posting under another alias. He will be nailed shortly for account abuse. I've been watching this group for a while and there's one loser continuously posting under new accounts. IP tracking will be requested shortly.

All Because of You -- a great rocker which has gotten a lot of airplay.

Vertigo -- A FUN rocking song that most people will like if they lighten up a bit. :)

Yahweh -- A simple, catchy, straightforward hymn to Bono's God. I always appreciated his open spirituality, even if I don't believe the same things he does.

Crumbs from Your Table -- That funky chord they use and the rolling, rocking hooks. Wonderful tune.

Miracle Drug -- Sounds like something from Boy and I can't get enough of it.

Yes, this CD isn't perfect, however, it is NOT even close to being a 1 star effort like the lamers here are trying to say.

It does annoy me when people slag off an album such as this after seemingly only one listen or two at most. Be patient, and you will find this to be one of the most enjoyable U2 albums out there. People didn't like their previous effort of "All that you can't leave behind" because they found it "boring" or "too mainstream". You obviously haven't paid any attention to it, read the lyrics or given it a few listens.

This album is in my view one of the best of 2004. I am not a U2 fan, the only albums of theirs that I own are this one and "All that you can't leave behind". Most of the songs on here are of a very high quality - "Vertigo", "Sometimes you can't make it on your own" (both #1 UK singles by the way), "City of blinding lights", "All because of you" and "Yahweh".

Musically, the album is sound, as it is lyrically. I have the UK version which has twelve tracks, the extra one being "Fast Cars", a very hispanic sounding song, containing the lyrics from where this album's title originated.

Overall, a decent effort from a band whose other albums I will for sure be getting.

PS To all of you who think Bono is dumb for singing 1, 2, 3, 14 in Spanish at the beginning of Vertigo a warning. Don't underestimate these guys, they are cleverer than you. If it indeed was a mistake, someone would have noticed before the album went out - the fourteen stands for their fourteenth album.

After losing my mother this fall, this album has become the outlet to release all of my emotions. When I first bought it, I turned down all the lights in my bedroom and played the whole thing straight through. I cried to most of the songs, especially the beautiful "Sometimes You Can't Make It on your Own." As Bono lost his father and wrote most of these songs about him or the issues of death and survival, they all struck me in the heart. These songs cradled all of my emotions I was feeling.

"Miracle Drug" made me appreciate the love my mother had given me.
"Sometimes" made me realize how much I missed her and our past experiences together.
"City of Blinding Lights" reminded me of her outer and inner beauty.
"All Because of You" is like a dedication to her while letting out my anger about her death.
"One Step Closer" covers the broader topic of death.
"Yahweh" is a prayer that closes everything.

THANK YOU SO MUCH U2 FOR GIVING ME THIS! IT HAS AND WILL GET ME THROUGH THE TOUGH MONTHS AHEAD!

I've seen it happen before. A band is forced to chug out albums under difficult or rushed or confused circumstances, and the "spontaneity" and honesty of what comes out grabs the attention of the masses and hits something in the human heart. Then they become self-aware, and start over-analyzing every note. Production values soar, but the grit and soul of the music is "smoothed over." Witness "Beautiful Letdown" by Switchfoot versus "New Way to be Human." Witness "Atomic Bomb" versus "October."

I would say, lock Bono, The Edge, Adam and Larry up in a house with some old guitars and amps, a delay pedal, a trusty drumset, an SM-57, and a 16-track analog recorder. Tell 'em they come out with an album in 2 weeks or they never come out at all! I seriously think what they'd put out would be better than "Atomic Bomb." Better yet, fly 'em down to New Orleans for a day before you lock 'em up. Get some of the old passion and "crying out" flowing again! THAT is what this album lacks.

Give the last half a chance - it's better than I expected! Their slow, contemplative stuff is pretty good. I just wish they had the fire in the belly that practically brought you to tears in "Pride."

I had great hopes for this album, which had been hailed by advance reviewers as U2's big comeback, their finest album in a long, long time.

Needless to say, I was underwhelmed. There are a lot of songs on the album that show promise, most notably "City of Blinding Lights", which builds up a great head of steam but fizzles when it gets down to the chorus. Many of the other songs are simply dull, taking their time and going nowhere.

The only real standout tracks are "All Because of You" and "Vertigo". Even those two seem to fall short of expectations. The worst part of this is that U2 is trying so hard on this album to recreate their "classic" sound. The glory days of "The Joshua Tree" are long gone, and it's time to give up the ghost.

"How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb" is innocuous, but is also just plain boring. U2 can't count on its fans to shell out every time they release an album, especially not one as tired as this. 3 stars, and I'm sorely tempted to give lower.

Any U2 record takes at least a week before conclusions can be drawn. A couple hundred people here jumped the gun.

"Vertigo" - Their best single in a long time - probably since
"One"

Miracle Drug - Great hooks and lyricism. "Freedom has a scent like the top of a newborn baby's head." If you have never had a child or a baby brother/sister, you wouldn't understand.

"Sometimes..." - A remarkably mature song about the complications of growing up with a dad. The falsetto was a bit off-putting at first, but grew on me. Excellent bridge saves the song from falling asleep and makes it a winner.

"Love & Peace" - U2 meets bluesy Led Zep. How could THAT be bad?

"City of Blinding Lights" - My favorite so far. Wrings out all the emotion that was put into it. U2 does this well all the time (as any concert experience with them will bear out), but sometimes the transcendent emotion superconducts. Almost makes you want to move to NYC.

"All Because of You" - Beatlesesque hook. A great rock song as well as a great U2 song.

"Man and a Woman" - New sound but hearkens back to older stuff. Great song.

"Crumbs from Your Table" - Afflicting the comfortable into comforting the afflicted. Biting prophetic never sounded so good. Great guitar hook and good medicine for what ails us spoiled White Westerners.

"One Step Closer" - Mature song about dying from the same country that brought us "Danny Boy." Pretty tough sell on a rock album, but we tacitly acknowledge our own demise every time we look at a clock. Heidegger called us beings unto death and the Irish do death songs better than anyone.

"Original of the Species" - Transcendent song about that most mundane institution. Marriage is the toughest job you'll ever love and Bono has logged the years with Ali to earn a voice.

"Yahweh" - "But," said Moses to God, "when I go to the Israelites and say to them, 'The God of your fathers has sent me to you,' if they ask me, 'What is his name?' what am I to tell them?" God replied, "I am who am." Then he added, "This is what you shall tell the Israelites: I AM (Heb. YHWH = Yahweh) sent me to you." (Exodus 3:14-15) More a Psalm than a song. This is a great compliment to "Grace" from ATYCLB and "40" from WAR.

BOTTOM LINE - Dave (Edge) returns to the Guitar with style, Paul (Bono) spills his guts in a way that is inspiring and not embarassing, Adam and Larry maintenance the bottom end with brilliant simplicity. This is the most consistent U2 record since Joshua Tree and best since Achtung Baby.

After what seemed like an endless wait for a new U2 album, it is finally here, and while it could have been better, it certainly could have been much worse. After the first listen through, my reaction was "where are the rock-n-roll songs?" I was under the impression that this was going to be U2 going back to their roots, a more upbeat rock-n-roll sound to the album. Sure "Vertigo" has a great beat, but if you are expecting the album to be like that single, you are in for a shock. Instead we get a more mellow sound, as if this is a transitional album. After listening to it more, I have found that I am enjoying it much more than their last album (however, "Walk On" is one superb song). While this album doesn't come close to "The Unforgettable Fire" or "Joshua Tree", it is well worth the price, and over time will probably grow on us all.
Looking forward to the tour early next year, just hope we don't have to wait another five years for another offering by one of the greatest bands in the world. :-)