4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great Novel, but which came first-The book or movie?, February 17, 2005
I saw this book in the leatherbound version a couple of years ago, and have read it so mant times that I think I need to get another copy! It's a really great book, but which came first-The book or the movie. I ask this because the book follows the movie, scene for scene and some of the dialogue from the movie is in the book, almost word-for-word, and I mean this as a sincere compliment, not a knock on the book at all. I have so seldomly read a book that Hollyweird didn't butcher so badly that the movie hardly resembles the book. But in HTWWW, the movie follows the book so closely that it almost reads like a script, but very enjoably so! I reccommend this book highly, and get the leatherbound copy; it's beautiful and really holds up. Thanks, Mr L'Amour! A GREAT BOOK!!!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
One of L'Amour's Very Best!, October 29, 2004
I just finished reading How the West Was Won and have got to say that it is a mighty fine read! This Western has it all, fun, funny, scary, exciting, a fabulous tall tale of adventure.
If for some reason you have never read any of Louis L'Amour's books, you have been missing out on a real treat. I am a writer myself (Allergy-Free gardening, safe sex in the Garden, and other books) and I have to admit that for most of my life I was snobby about reading any Louis L'Amour. However, less than a year ago my brother encouraged me to try some of them, and immediately I was hooked. I, like many others, no am almost always reading one, and as soon as I finish it I find another and start in on it. I mean, they are just too much fun to be missed.
Some think too that his books are only for men, but I have found that women and many kids too really enjoy them. No one could write better adventure than L'Amour, and certainly no one could write a better Western.
This particular book, How the West Was Won, is one of his best. It is a big, fun, rip-snorting book and I highly recommend it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
L'amour fans...this is a NOVELIZATION OF A MOVIE...let this one go!, April 21, 2009
Sure, this is a L'amour novel in the sense that Louis put the pen to paper...but the characters, action, and sequence were by necessity based straight from the movie. The writing seems forced and contrived, due to Louis having to work within the framework of an existing story.
If you love L'amour, this book will be a struggle for you. Books that are adapted into movies, are often great. Novelizations based on movies...not so much...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No