Most Helpful Customer Reviews
48 of 54 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Mind bending assessment of the human role in the universe..., February 9, 2007
This review is from: The Human Touch: Our Part in the Creation of a Universe (Hardcover)
Michael Frayn offers a thought provoking and suprisingly enjoyable treatise on humanity's role in the universe, showing a deft handle on subjects ranging from physics and cosmology, to the intricacies of language. From beginning to end, Frayn has the wit and sensibility of a kinder and gentler Richard Dawkins (newly minted superstar author of the much more confrontational and intellectually arrogant (in my humble opinion) - "The God Delusion"). While Frayn is certainly no Christian theist, he offers some amazing insights into the central role humanity plays in the conscious understanding of the cosmos - an idea with some meaningful Biblical applications for those so inclined. As both a philosophy professor and Christian pastor, I found Frayn's thoughts to be both strikingly original in their combinations and refeshingly coherent in their execution - think C.S. Lewis after a few weeks alone with Hawking's "A Brief History of Time." Overall, I consider this book to be worthy reading as I found it both effective in expanding my horizons and being challenged in my assumptions. - S. ** EDITED MINIMALLY FOR CLARITY OF GRAMMAR, SPELLING, AND PUNCTUATION **
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
I kept reaching for a pencil, March 21, 2007
This review is from: The Human Touch: Our Part in the Creation of a Universe (Hardcover)
Professional philosophers will have the same problem with this book as professional historians have with Paul Johnson (thus a few 4-stars will appear in an otherwise unassailable 5+-stars). As a non-professional philosopher (but professional scientist), I found this to be a remarkable work: An amalgam of physics, neuroscience, linguistics, and philosophy, brought to bear upon the issue of how we create the universe. Its an astonishing synthesis. Frayn has a genius for accessibly posing the important questions. What is free will? What is consciousness? Does the universe exist (metaphorically) without us? Most important, do we have the language to even ask the right questions? Could we ever understand ourselves? Frayn has serious doubts, and the answers pour through our fingers like water. But our hands are left wet, and we thirst for more.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Big, Friendly Summary of Philosophy, April 22, 2007
This review is from: The Human Touch: Our Part in the Creation of a Universe (Hardcover)
Michael Frayn is well known as a playwright for the hilarious farce _Noises Off_ (film version good but less funny) and for _Copenhagen_, a drama about quantum physicists. He is also a novelist, translator, and journalist. When he was at Cambridge, though, he studied philosophy, and he might say that all his works have been offshoots of that particular endeavor. He returns to the big subject in _The Human Touch: Our Part in the Creation of a Universe_ (Metropolitan Books) with a suitably big book with lots of big and important topics and plenty of profound but lightly-expressed ideas. It has to be said that most of Frayn's ideas have to do with just how deep our wonderment ought to be and how few answers we have, but still, this is a genial guided tour of the issues that have consumed thinkers since before the days of Plato. The paradox that Frayn looks at in many different ways is this: "The world has no form or substance without you and me to provide them, and you and I have no form or substance without the world to provide them in its turn." He also says that we have not even begun resolve the paradox. "The universe plainly exists independently of human consciousness," he writes, "but what can ever be said about it that has not been mediated through that consciousness?" We have come scientifically to understand a great deal of our universe, especially the planet we inhabit, but the amount compared to the mysteries that still remain is tiny. When we look closely at its complexity, it merely becomes more complex. Frayn, as you can imagine, thinks that numbers are invented. After all, we messed around with numbers for centuries without using a symbol for zero until that concept became part of the system. "Number, in short, is not something logically and mysteriously anterior to space and time, or to cause, or to the human presence in the world." Frayn examines the truth content of stories; how can we evaluate, for instance, the statement "Sherlock Holmes lived at 221B Baker Street"? It is all less complicated than counterfactuals, which have been a puzzle for philosophers for centuries. All this is less puzzling than that of the old bogey of consciousness; Frayn writes, "About consciousness much has been said, and not a word of it that told us anything we didn't already know perfectly well from our own lifelong experience, which is nothing. We can't even say what _sort_ of a thing it is." Consciousness is plainly dependent on the mechanisms in the brain, but paradox again, no accounting of such mechanisms comes close to explaining what feeling and being aware are. What meaning we get from the universe, too, is up to us. Frayn starts and ends his tour of paradox and how little we can really know with a Rashomon-like invitation: on a calm, clear night, just look up at the stars in wonder. It isn't enough for us humans, because we will start wondering about those lights, and their spectra, and their speed of emission, and on and on; it isn't enough, and then it is enough because it has to be. Frayn's deeply personal explanations of philosophical ideas expressed in an avuncular and amiable way is an engaging look at a broad range of important ideas. Despite his repeatedly showing how much of what we know for sure cannot really be known for sure, this is not a book of despair but an invitation to look with delight more deeply at the nature of things.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|