15 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Matheson's Hungry Debut, December 23, 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: Hunger and Thirst (Hardcover)
When legendary authors dig through their old files for unpublished manuscripts, the specialty press books that result are often interesting, frequently well-written, sometimes amusing. But it is usually fairly obvious why the material was never published in the first place; these kinds of collector's books are fascinating for the completist, but they are seldom truly important. Richard Matheson's "Hunger and Thirst" is an exception. "Hunger and Thirst" is important.
This massive novel is the first that Matheson ever wrote, completed at the same time (1949-50) that the young writer was beiginning to make a name for himself in the world of fantasy fiction through such stories as "Born of Man and woman" and "Third From the Sun." Discouraged by his agent's reaction at the time (who deemed it unpublishable), Matheson put the book away, never to return to it--even though writer Henry Kuttner ("The Graveyard Rats") read it and told him, "Your agent's a damn fool."
Kuttner was right. "Hunger and Thirst" is a marvelous, wildly ambitious novel about a young man, Erick Lindstrom, who obsessively thinks back over the events of his life as he lay paralyzed and dying of a gunshot wound in his cheap apartment. The device of a man alone facing insurmountable odds will be familiar to readers of Matheson; what may be unfamiliar is the extraordinary emotional power the author brings to his story. From the vivid autobiographical war sections to the portrayal of Erick's obsessive relationships with two women, the young author's passion and feeling for his material shine through.
For this is, in every good sense, a young man's book. Matheson's protagonist is a Hamlet-like character caught in a Dostoyevskian world of shadows and suspicions, fatally indecisive about who he wants to be. Unable to fully give himself over to love, he ruins a relationship with a fine young woman, Sally. Later he shares a tormented period with an alcoholic, Leonora, whom he accidentally impregnates. This is not cheery stuff, but it is very much in line with many American first novels, from Thomas Wolfe's to J.D. Salinger's, and it is extremely well-done.
The novel is flawed, to be sure; the war material, powerful though it is, is never really successfully integrated into the main story, and the young Matheson is occasionally given to overheated language (including triple exclamation marks and words in ALL CAPS). But overall, "Hunger and Thirst" is a major achievement--and an astonishing revelation.
Matheson's literary career was forever altered by the failure of "Hunger and Thirst." Had the book been published, he declares in his Introduction, "I would have been encouraged to write more mainline novels instead of electing to concentrate entirely (with the exception of "The Beardless Warriors") on genre writing. Not that I regret it..." In this light, upon finishing "Hunger and Thirst" the reader may feel deeply conflicted emotions. On the one hand, a career which has included "I Am Legend" and "The Shrinking Man" and "Hell House" and "Somewhere in Time" certainly cannot in any way be regretted. But the publication of "Hunger and Thirst" compels us to wonder about a Richard Matheson who might have been.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Written by Richard Matheson, not Richard Christian Matheson, July 5, 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: Hunger and Thirst (Hardcover)
Please note:... listed this item incorrectly. The author is Richard Matheson, not Richard Christian Matheson. Richard Christian Matheson is Richard Matheson's son; the two authors have very different writing styles and should not be confused.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
0 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Bad... Really, really bad., January 30, 2004
This review is from: Hunger and Thirst (Hardcover)
Matheson is definitely one of my favorite authors, but this book is abysmal. It is pretty standard drivel that any selfish, self involved, puffed up lit student writes and thinks is Shakespeare.
The lone triumph of this book is it shows that a hack of a 23 year old can write something this bad, turn himself around, change his style and purpose completely and become one of the most popular and influential writers in America.
Please don't read this book. If you are considering it, read what Matheson himself writes about "Hunger and Thirst" in the afterword. If you think this review is bad, give this book a try:)
37%, terrible..
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
