7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Bowie's Undisputed Masterpiece, June 5, 2005
Hunky Dory (1971.), David Bowie's fourth studio album
David Bowie is arguably one of the greatest solo artists of all time and his unique alternative style (notice the omission of the word 'pop') is timeless and has deservedly won him loads of fans from generation to generation. Bowie has changed his style from album to album and has produced music in loads of different styles whilst still maintaining his distinctive sound. 'Hunky Dory', Bowie's fourth studio album, released in 1971 is one of the greatest chapters in his career and is definitely one of his most powerful releases.
'Hunky Dory' is the second album in what I would describe as Bowie's classic run of five albums from 'Man Who Sold the World' to 'Diamond Dogs' when he was at his very best. 'Hunky Dory' though is one of his most unique releases. Bowie was not yet into his famous Ziggy Stardust glam rock period but neither is this album as strongly guitar based as its predecessor 'Man Who Sold the World'. 'Hunky Dory' instead is much more acoustic based with lots of piano thrown in but most of all is an album of unbelievable songwriting - songs don't come much better than those on this album. The album is really well structured as well - each side of the original LP has happy/upbeat songs for the most part but finishes off with a darker, emotive and more powerful song ('Quicksand' and 'Bewlay Brothers'). Bowie's backing group are also excellent on this album. Rick Wakeman's jazzy piano playing is there practically throughout and really characterises the album. Mick Ronson plays some great guitar solos on the album especially in 'Life on Mars'. Bowie's accomplished and often overlooked saxophone playing is also top notch on this album.
David Bowie's album collection has undergone a number of remasters since CD's became commonplace about 20 years ago. Recently an enhanced CD version of 'Hunky Dory' was released. Obviously the sound quality is great but the version lacks any bonus tracks, which incidentally can be found on the 1991 remaster. The latter is the version I would recommend. It still has excellent sound quality and also has demo versions of 'Quicksand' and 'Bewlay Brothers' as well as an album outtake 'Bombers' and an alternative version of 'The Supermen' from 'The Man Who Sold the World' album.
Eventhough this masterpiece yielded a fair-share of singles, this album is not pop in my opinion but instead is a great serving of alternative, extremely listenable music. 'Changes', one of Bowie's well known songs starts the album. An excellent song, its got a classic chorus with loads of piano play. 'oh You Pretty Things' is a great follow up - brilliant for a sing along with another catchy chorus. It runs very cleverly into 'Eight Line Poem' which is a more reflective songs with somem rather bluesy guitar playing from Mick Ronson. 'Life On Mars?' is next up and this one truly one of Bowie's great songs. The lyrics are some of the best I've heard and Mick Ronson's closing solo is out of this world - listen out for the phone ringing at the end of the track! 'Kooks' is an upbeat acoustic track which Bowie wrote for his son, Zowy Bowie. Then we come to 'Quicksand', in my opinion the best track on the album. Its got an amazingly calming start before building into a powerful, heartfelt song - the chorus is really moving. A song about losing direction in life, this is one of Bowie's greatest songs.
What was side two of the LP kicks off with a happy sing along 'Fill Your Heart', a great track, although it is the weakest track on this great album - ironically Bowie didn't write this one! 'Andy Warhol' follows this; this strong acoustic jam is excellent. The goofing around in the studio at the start is a hillarious, where Bowie keeps correcting the sound engineer's pronunciation of 'Warhol'. 'Song For Bob Dylan' is a tribute to one of Bowie's great influences and is followed by 'Queen Bitch', the most rocking track on the album, Ronson's guitar work on this track is first rate. 'The Bewlay Brothers' is an unbelievably potent finish to the album. I'm amazed how many reviewers of this album overlook the greatness of this track. I've never heard a track like it. It's mostly acoustic based and is Bowie's telling story of his own brother's lifelong mental troubles. The warped sounding voice at the end of the album is really freaky and it makes your blood run cold but its a remarkable finish to an amazing album.
The 'Hunky Dory' album captures David Bowie on one of the high points of his career. I'm not sure if I'd call it his best album but its up there with his finest efforts and this album is sure to stand the test of time. I'd recommend this album to anyone who likes a unique alternative style of music or to any fan of David Bowie, although there isn't such such a thing as a Bowie fan who doesn't own this masterpiece!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
WOW!!!!!, July 8, 2005
This review is from: Hunky Dory (Audio CD)
my first bowie cd, i just got it, ziggy stardust and diamond dogs. i just finished listening to this and now i am going to listen to the others. boy, this was great!! LIfe on Mars? Is without a doubt the best, the other songs are masterpeices. this was a very good introduction to bowie, none of theese songs are bad
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Best Edition of Amazing Album, May 27, 2009
I had Ziggy Stardust and the 1990 greatest hits album ChangesBowie and figured that was all the David Bowie a person really needed. I was wrong. This album is different but I think it's the equal of Ziggy. It uses more prominent acoustic instruments, including Rick Wakeman's (later of Yes) brilliant piano playing and Mick Ronson's guitars. The lyrics are denser and more mysterious than anything else of Bowie's I've ever heard. "The Bewlay Brothers" and "Quicksand" are especially amazing. And as you probably know, the hits "Changes" and "Life On Mars?" are emotional and wonderful.
As with most Bowie albums, there are several choices as to what exact edition to buy. I am generally a bonus track fan and the Rykodisc version has four excellent ones. "Bombers", a hard rocking, time shifting song that seems to be about nuclear testing in the desert, is not available anywhere else I could find. The alternate version of "The Supermen" is very different from the master recording from the Man Who Sold The World album. The demo of "Quicksand" and the alternate mix of "The Bewlay Brothers" both reflect and shine a new light on the original versions. Also, this edition has a complete lyric sheet - a must for this CD.
So while it might be slightly quieter and have more dynamic range than the remastered edition that came out in 1999, I think the bonus tracks more than compensate for that. (I don't even think that's a bad thing in the first place.) So to sum up - If you like Bowie at all then yes, you DO need this album and you should get THIS edition.
(Here's a final tip: Always check with the seller when you buy used and make sure they have listed their product correctly or you could end up with the wrong edition!)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No