Customer Reviews

The Hustler & The Champ: Willie Mosconi, Minnesota Fats, and the Rivalry that Defined Pool

5 star:		(7)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(3)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

I found R.A. Dyer's "The Hustler & The Champ" an enjoyable and important read, especially for those pool enthusiasts that truly understand the beauty and the greatness of the lost game of straight pool. While there are young players today that can also run 'hundreds', we will likely never see the game of 14.1 played the way it was played during Mosconi's reign. Greenleaf, Mosconi, Ponzi, Procita, Eufemia and others played "old style straight pool" and all shared similar rules of navigation on the felt when running racks. Few players today, save for greats that played in proximity to Mosconi's era, such as 3-time world champion Ray Martin, Dallas West and a few others can resurrect the "old-style play."

As I progressed through Dyer's book I found myself sympathizing with Mosconi's absolute frustration and his sadness of having denied himself a personal life with his family because of his investment of years "on the road" for Brunswick doing exhibitions and living out of hotels for a game that unfortunately also died. At the "end of it all" the magic and greatness of straight pool died anyways and denied Mosconi
even the legacy of keeping the game of straight pool alive.

I found facinating Dyer's description of Mosconi's apathy for playing pool and being forced out of financial necessity to play the game and yet performing nonetheless at a level that was unsurpassable. Dyer gives the reader an accurate and eye-opening read on the separate 'worlds' of pool...the "hustler's world of Minnesota Fats" and the "tournament world" of Willie Mosconi and their eventual combative and necessary collision. I would highly recommend this well researched and informative book.

Ask anyone who the best pool player of all time was, and they may say Minnesota Fats. That's an amazing thing, because he was not the greatest pool player of all time, and the book/movie the Hustler were NOT based on him. Instead, he borrowed the name after the fact. WIllie Mosconi should be on people's short list as one the the greatest pool players of all time, but few know who he is. Such is the nature of people's lack of knowledge of pool history, and the effectiveness of Minnesota Fats' con.

This book covers these facts in detail, and covers the rivalry between Minnesota Fats and WIllie Mosconi. It all leads up to the two players contending against each other on ABC's wide world of sports.

Both RA Dyer books I have read were a bit dry, but informative. This book was more interesting than the other, though. I suggest anyone wanting to understand either of these players read this book. This information is covered in other places, but in piecemeal fashion.

If pool/billiards history is not your thing, I suggest more entertaining books such as 'Playing off the Rail' (non fiction), or 'Stroke' (fiction)

Fantastic book.... So much is revealed (and explained) about the "real" lives of Willie & Fats that I never knew...What a rivalry and what a life they lived!
A must read for anyone (especially pool players) interested in how these two icons impacted the world of pool forever, and what price their families paid for their fame.
An excellent sequel to R.A. Dyer's "Hustler Days" and "Living Off the Rail" that follows the life and times of so many more legends of the billiard world.
G. Keis / Cleveland, OH

I have been a pool fan and player for about sixty years. I've been a Mosconi fan as long as I can remember and have attended several of this gentleman's exhibitions. At that time, I was an employee of the Brunswick Corporation, Mr. Mosconi's sponsor.

This book was a "good read" from cover to cover. I read much too seldom, however once started in this book I couldn't lay it down. What was appreciated in this book was that it did not seem to be biased, it truly enabled the reader to know Mr. Mosconi.

A good job of realistically describing the life of the world's greatest straight pool player and one of the world's greatest hustlers. Interesting, colorful although sometimes dry and a little depressing.

Good facts and research.

This book is the perfect gift of cool for those who enjoy playing pool and want to know more about how it came by its reputation for tough guys, smoky rooms, and hustler-style gambling. The book is chock full of anecdotes funny enough to read out loud about the lives of two men who exemplify the two "schools of pool" and who fought to define the game. The Great Shoot Out, with the famous sportscaster Howard Cosell, was must-see TV for my father and millions like him who were glued to their sets while Willie Mosconi and the so-called Minnesota Fats went head-to-head in a billiards contest everyone said would never happen. Dyer, who handles the subject with enough respect, enthusiasm, and expertise to be an established columnist for Billiards Digest, has written a second wonderful book that is destined to be one of the classics on the subject of pool and billiards.

Actuall, a few, interesting items, BUT, could've been presented 1n 10% of the space it took, as there was'nt that much meat in THIS Dyer book; Book WAS delivered on time and in good condition!

i have heard of willie mosconi and minnesota fats since the early 60s but this book gives me an insight into their lives that i never knew.both their lives border on sad and tragic.it is a shame that willie mosconi,one of the best if not the best in his sport has been almost forgotten by the general public.

Upon completing this book, I can say I found it very informative along with being a great story. I have read the autobiographies of both Willie and Minnesota Fats and this book had numerous facts about the two I was unaware of. The book begins by explaining how there televised match originated, then goes on to chronicle the history and careers of both men. I don't think you can say Fats really had a "career" as much as a life spent hustling and gambling. Willie sure had one with all the World Championships and his lifetime spent doing exhibitions all over the country. Keep in mind that the book has much more history on Willie than Fats. The book then tells of their televised match. This part was excellent reading as he told of Fats "starting in" on Willie before the pool match even began. I read this part twice and had to laugh at the things he said and pictured him saying them on T.V. (CLASSIC FATS). The book talks about a few other meetings between the two as well as a little on their lives after pool. I thought it was kind of sad how both ended up.
If I had one negative thing to say, it was maybe a little dry during the middle chapters.
What I liked most was what the author gives us to think about at the end. Even though Willie absolutely detested Fats, Fats did a lot for pools popularity and Willie's. I believe the book claimed their original televised match had a 30 % share. That's incredible when you think about it. Willie had the records and championships but Fats was like the original one man show. Like Minnesota Fats said to Willie Mosconi...."You gotta have fans".

Dyer's investigative research chronicles the lives of two of pool's greatest players- Minnesota Fats and Willie Mosconi. He demonstrates amazing insight as he compares and contrasts the characters and unearths fascinating supportive details. The book captures facts forgotten and distorted in pool history and is of extreme value for the documentation of billiard's history and the players who contributed to its popularity. The symbolic references intertwined throughout the book create a treasure trove of images for analysis in college English classes and capture the attention of the reader irregardless of their interest in pool.