From School Library Journal
PreSchool-Grade 1-Written in quatrains that break into couplets across each double page, this lullaby rhyme catalogues various animals and their offspring, describing each mother's testament of love. The mountain nanny goat says, "'I love you as much as the mountain is steep'"; the camel says, "'I love you as much as the desert is dry.'" The book ends with a full quatrain of love poetry from a woman to her newborn child. Sorensen's paintings are large and bright, spanning double-page spreads and extending to the edge of each page, with full backgrounds and panoramic views that enhance the animal characters. The deep tones, well-lit landscapes (which contrast effectively with the darkness of the final picture), and the multiple layers of opaque paint suggest a formality of portraiture that is not usually seen in children's books. The text, which is discretely tucked away in the corners of the pages where it does not interrupt the effect of the illustration, is set in a decorative italic font. The potential for sentimentality is certainly present, but Melmed carefully avoids the cute and tearful. While reading this book is certainly a satisfying experience, full of pathos and meaning for parents, it's likely to appeal more to them than to their children.
Ruth K. MacDonald, Quinnipiac College, Hamden, CTCopyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.
From Scientific American
Ages 3-5. This simple picture book has a reassuring rhyming text and more than agreeably pleasant watercolors. One mother-child pair is shown in a natural setting on each double-page spread. The popularity of animal families with young readers and the comforting, rhythmic text combine to create an appealing title for bedtime reading. Concluding with a human mother and her child, Melmed writes: "Now sleep, child of mine, while the stars shine above-I love you as much as a mother can love."
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.