Customer Reviews

I Think I Love You

5 star:		(8)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(3)
2 star:		(6)
1 star:		(19)

 

 

I, too, saw Katie's showcase on "Bubblegum Babylon," and was not terribly impressed with what I saw. Katie does bear some resemblance to her father (particularly when she smiles), and so the fact that she is coming out with: A) a famous last name [UNLIKE Norah Jones], B) an agenda that stresses her relationship to said famous parent [again, UNLIKE Jones, who has done everything in her power to distance herself from Shankar], and C) a remake of her parent's big hit, makes the whole thing look gimmicky, and not just a *cute* kind of gimmicky.
Case in point: if one of Donny Osmond's kids threw a revamped bit of "Puppy Love" into their stage show, but didn't make it a central focus for their career, it would be cute.
This is not cute. This is...sad.
Katie seems like a truly nice person who really wants a career, but this is not a good idea. The song is a hyperactive, whitewashed, oversynthesized mess, and you can barely hear Katie singing. I'll bet she has talent--but terrible management.
The basic problem can be summed up in a quote from one of the little girls HIRED from a local dance studio to cheer at Katie's showcase/concert.
After the show, this elementary-school tot was asked what she thought of the show. The child's reply? She liked Katie because she was pretty and can dance well. Not a word was said about her singing ability.
Katie seems to be falling into the same trap her father faced: letting the image take over the singer.

I first became intrigued with Katie Cassidy after seeing the special on VH1. I thought she was pretty, and I really liked the song...she seems very down to earth and sweet. So I ordered the single, and I like it. I agree that Kaci's is better, but just because I like the arrangment of Kaci's. I think the arrangement of Katie's single was ok and all, Kaci's was just better. But you can tell that Katie has one fantastic voice, and I for one can't wait for her to come out with an album, I'm sure it will be great.

I'm reccomending this cd for the first track,
whereas the dance remix is dull.

I had never heard of Katie Cassidy until last week when there was a show on either VH1, E, or MTV about teens that have CDs...and I had honestly never heard of Katie Cassidy, and they kept stating "Katie gets so much attention, she gets airplay on every pop music station" - and that's not true. None of the radio stations in MI play her, to my knowlidge.

Anyway, I like her vocals, and think she has loads of talent, but she needs more airplay, and she also needs her OWN music. Not just a remake of her DAD'S songs.

I'd like to hear more from Katie, but right now, she just doesn't cut it.

Overall grade - C

There are 2 versions on here and both are just OK. Her voice is good, but nothing unique. At least if there were better arraingements, she would come shinning through. Her father David has the best version, even if his version sounds dated!

First of all, I'd like to say that if somebody becomes a "pop sensation" at 15 years of age, they should be smacked. I mean, its just publicity acting out on some ditzy blond.

Now, onto the cd... First of all, I think they just discovered a new kind of warfare. I mean, make enemy troops listen to this, and they'll go insane! I mean, its just plain annoying. The background music sounds like a bunch of monkeys, no, not monkeys, but rednecks are trying to play instruments other than the banjo and harmonica. Its a disgusting "tribute" to music. And "hip-pop"? Don't make me laugh. I mean, come on, this isn't even deserving enough to be in any of those horrible genres. And her voice sounds like somebody is giving a cat and enema. Seriously, her voice cracks more than that mr. manager guy on simpsons. Thats the end of that chapter...

First time I heard this I couldn't tell a thing about her singing ability. Her voice was drowned out by the music. You couldn't tell a thing about it and you could barley understand what she was saying. It didn't sound nothing like David cassidy sang the original I think I love you. She might be able to sing but who could tell with this cd. It isn't worth the money. Sorry Cassidy Family.

i have never herd katie sing before but

when i did i was shocked is that really her?

i think she should stop the whole i want to

follow my dads foot steps thing. sorry katie

i think you should leave the singing to

jesse mccartney.

I also saw the VH1 clips, and I just felt sorry for Katie. She is not meant to be a singer, yet her mother and manager are blinded by their own goals and don't seem to notice or care. Katie appears to be a sweet, sincere girl. I checked out her website, and I felt somewhat reassured to see that the focus of the content is on her recent work as a model. No link to a music page like most musicians provide, just a link to Amazon. I think Katie's found a more appropriate career at which she can succeed. I wish her the best.

I've heard girls' with bad voices before, but please...shes horrible. I think she needs take some voice lessons because she can't carry a tune at all. This is by far one of the worst, most boring songs I have ever listened to.