2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good Context for Voice/Data Convergence, May 30, 2004
This review is from: IP Telephony Unveiled (Paperback)
IP Telephony Unveiled by Kevin Brown (Cisco Press, 2004) provides some interesting history of the convergence of voice and data, and points out how early efforts in this area were focused on the PBX; it turned out this was not a good place to converge because the links were inadequate for ever-increasing data traffic. Eventually the tables were turned and now it's apparent that the data network is the place to converge the two traffic types.
The book discusses new capabilities and applications: virus alerts, paging, etc. And it implies throughout that many more revolutionary ("killer") applications are still to be conceived. I kept asking myself if I was convinced of this, but there weren't enough true-ringing examples to sway me. Of course, the day has dawned for IP telephony (IPT). There's no question that toll bypass and unified messaging-with its undeniable cost savings and the means to increase employee productivity and hold staff accountable-will drive a very high growth rate in the coming years. I also think that video, with highly similar requirements (more bandwidth but nearly the same service quality) to pure voice over IP (VoIP), will be another business driver, but the book doesn't touch on this in any detail.
For the CxO or IT manager, there are some interesting pointers on selecting PBX features to implement in an IPT environment. It's interesting how simple-seeming features are implemented differently from one company to the next-call transfer is a classic example. This poses both a difficulty and an opportunity for IP telephony-standards are very nice things, even if there are sometimes too many of them, and IPT is inherently less proprietary than PBX technology.
I found the insisted-upon difference between IPT and VoIP (VoIP is just the traffic and IPT is the whole solution including clients, users, etc.) to be a bit of hair-splitting. In practice, these are used interchangeably and I don't see this resulting in any serious misunderstanding or lack of awareness of the potential of this technology.
There is a nice rundown of various PBX features such as profiles, authorization codes, time-of-day routing etc. It's easy to see the advantages of integrating these applications via softphone onto the PC. And the book points out that IP phones, though slightly harder to use because they're so feature-rich, lend themselves to simpler rollout and training than you get with a PBX, because the solution can be deployed incrementally like any new network application.
Yet I think there is inadequate defense of a couple of key rollout drivers. Ongoing maintenance costs-such as the ability to perform moves, adds, and changes-are indeed lessened with IPT as the book points out, though this was not the case only a couple of years ago, and IT management probably still needs convincing on this point. It also is fairly recently that folks are accepting that the data network provides the same reliability as a PBX based phone system, and this is also a perception that account managers still need to disabuse to get their sales.
The book does a nice job differentiating PBX from IPT architecture-IPT is both revolutionary and evolutionary, and is not private, nor branch-specific, nor an exchange. In a sense, phones are just another client, and IPT is evolutionary in this sense. IPT provides all the advantages of a PBX, and allows new applications to emerge. It partly does this because of how easy it easy to merge with the web and office applications on the PC-thus the book details the notion of speed URLs, which are similar to speed dials that we're familiar with on our everyday phones.
In the last chapters, the book focuses on the "vital few" initiatives that lead to a successful rollout, and on return on investment (ROI) issues. It stresses finding the value proposition and understanding the business. There are different issues for different markets, with one common thread in that sophisticated users, who drive markets in early stages, want the same intelligence for their phones that they currently enjoy on their workstations or personal digital assistants. Maximizing ROI is a matter of driving down network, administrative, and maintenance costs, while creating applications that focus on key company initiatives. Convergence logically extends the call control platform instead of requiring (in the old paradigm) a PBX in each location. This is where I would have liked to see more on call server deployment options, such as distributed versus centralized call processing, or clustering servers over a WAN.
And this is a choice that an author faces when writing a business book about technology-how much of the technology to include when you are focusing on the business benefits. My personal preference would have been to see more technical examples, because ultimately these details illuminate the marketing-oriented points of view. This is why I would give the book four stars out of five, with the caveat that if you are not a novice to IPT or you are looking for more meat on the real issues of deployment, it's more of a three. If you need an introduction with a strong sense of historical context, it's arguably a five, though it shouldn't be your only resource before engaging a vendor and working out the nuts and bolts of your IP telephony solution.
There is some good technical advice towards the end-the author stresses the importance of an infrastructure that can handle voice. This section talked about some of the key "gotchas" to watch out for: lack of WAN bandwidth and over-utilized routers that might have trouble handling the Quality of Service (QoS) capabilities to ensure delay and jitter are within end to end limits for acceptable conversation. There are also some tips on planning the pilot and ensuring you have some voice expertise in house.
Provocatively the book ends by pointing out how little anyone foresaw the quick impact of the web and the productivity enhancements of connectivity and opines that increased convergence of voice and data may turn out to be just as catalytic. Again, I'm not personally convinced of this-I remember other grand promises-the paperless office, artificial intelligence-that fell short of the mark. In this sense, IPT is both a little less and a little more than the author implies, because the cost savings are a no brainer and this is one of the few certain high-growth areas in networking today.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This is a must read for anyone interested in IP Telephony., February 10, 2004
This review is from: IP Telephony Unveiled (Paperback)
I have never written a book review before this one but feel that this book is so superior that I'd like to see it on a 'must read' list for IP Telephony.
IP Telephony Unveiled should be required for any University's Information Technology Management curriculum. It departs from 'technology for technology's sake' and makes a quantifiable business case for IP Telephony. This is not a deep-dive technical book but the 20,000 foot view of how IP Telephony will be intelligently tied into a business ROI.
If you are a CXO and are considering IP Telephony, this book will be an epiphany and you will use it as a roadmap. It will be the best money you ever spend. Kevin Brown correctly stresses the fact that a VRA (Voice Readiness Assessment) will save lots of money and make the difference between a clean implementation and something that you'll want to rip out and sell on EBay.
If you are an engineer, this book is not technically challenging but it should be read because sometimes the business reason for implementing a particular technology gets lost.
This book should be required reading for anyone involved in the sale or implementation of IP Telephony and would be a great present to give to a CXO who may be a prospective client looking to have a converged network.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
A convincing case for adopting IPT, March 8, 2005
This review is from: IP Telephony Unveiled (Paperback)
The phone service in the United States is one of the most useful and reliable services ever invented. So reliable that we are astounded when we pick up a phone and there is no dial tone. Through all kinds of weather and heavy usage, we rely on the phone system to transmit our voices, fax our documents and be available for Internet connections. Therefore, when managers are told that there is a more efficient replacement, their "Why switch?" response is one that must be answered. The response must also be persuasive, demonstrating that the new way to do things is better than the old.
The new wave in this case is IP telephony (IPT), or the placing of voice clients and voice applications on an IP network. Approximately ten years ago, I worked for a company with a programmed phone system and at the beginning it did not work well. Furthermore, moving to another cubical generally required changes in the phone system that didn't always work as expected. Therefore, the idea that you just plug phone devices into the network is a strong argument in favor of adopting IPT.
IPT technology is here and is reliable, a point stated and restated in this book. It is written at the level of the manager considering the adoption of IPT, there is very little in the way of technical arguments. Most of the points in favor are made using examples, such as in K-12 education. One of the strongest points made in that area was the possibility of a bomb or other threat being phoned in to a school. With IPT, the conversation can be automatically saved as a WAV file and the recipient can dynamically dial up the police and have them be privy to the conversation as it is happening. It is a sad commentary that such an example can no longer be considered an extreme one.
Even though I believe that the author does a bit of overselling of IPT technology, Cisco Systems provides IPT services, the book sold me on the value of IPT. If you are considering the adoption of IPT or are just interested in what it can do for you, then this book is a primer that will answer most of your basic questions.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
