Most Helpful Customer Reviews
78 of 79 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
EEEEEEEeeeee-VIL!, September 20, 2000
This review is from: Illustrated Jewish Bible for Children (Hardcover)
If you are Jewish, DO NOT buy this book! And even if you are a Christian, if you have any respect for Judaism, you should probably steer clear as well... This book is designed to perpetuate the myth that the Torah and the other books of the Tanach (the Jewish bible) are an "Old" Testament, which has been supplanted by Jesus' teachings, contained in the "New" Testament. I feel sorry for unsuspecting Jewish parents or grandparents who buy this book for their kids or grandkids only to discover that it presents Judaism only in relation to Christianity, not as a religion in itself. (for example, it discusses Abraham in terms of how long before Jesus he lived, and refers to the Tanach as "what Jesus would have read when he was a child." Notice that the publisher has stuck a "rabbi's" name on the cover, while hiding the genuine author's name on the back cover... this is a conscious ploy to attract Jewish customers to what is basically a Christian book. I have no fight to pick with Christianity, and if Christian parents want to teach their kids about their Jewish roots, this is probably a fine book for them to use. But because of its deceptive targeting at Jewish families, I strongly suggest that nobody -- Christian or Jew -- buy the book, as it would only encourage the publishers in their efforts to mislead. (P.S. I tried to give this book 0 stars, but the form wouldn't let me)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
68 of 70 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Good but misleading, November 7, 1999
By A Customer
This review is from: Illustrated Jewish Bible for Children (Hardcover)
This is a well done book but the title is misleading. Jewish parents will especially want to take care, as this book is really written for non-Jewish children to learn about the Jewish Bible. THe book references the Jewish Bible from a Christian point of view, and references historical characters as to their distance in time to Jesus. I wish they had been more explicit about this; in fact, by prominently featuring the name of a rabbi who wrote the FOreword on the book's cover, the publishers seem to be purposely misleading potential buyers as to the nature of the book
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
34 of 34 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Warning!Deceptive marketing at work! Not a Jewish Bible!, January 1, 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: Illustrated Jewish Bible for Children (Hardcover)
If you are looking for a children's Bible for a Jewish child, DO NOT buy this one. This book has been inaccurately titled. It should have been named "The Old Testament for Christian Children". A quick glance at the religious consultants listed is a pretty good warning that all is not as it seems. Only one of the names listed is identifiably Jewish, while two Reverends, a Father, and a Sister are obviously Christian. The remaining three consultants are not identified with titles (but one is named Mary...). The front cover only lists the author of the foreword (a Rabbi), and not the true author of the book, Selina Hastings. Upon reading the "Introduction to the Bible", I was shocked to find such passages as "The Bible...is divided into two main parts, the Old Testament (or Hebrew Testament) and the New Testament." Further on, I read, "The 39 books of the Old Testament have guided the Jewish people throughout their history. These are the Scriptures which Jesus read." Every mention of Jewish tradition is followed by a reference to the Christian counterpart. Had this been presented as a book for Christians, or even a book of comparative religion, I could understand this. But it was not. When presented as a Jewish bible-with a foreword by a Rabbi-it should stick to Judaism as the focus, rather that referring to the Christian Bible at all. For their edification, I do not refer to the Jewish Bible as "The Old Testament"-it is THE Bible for me, period. To the author's credit, this book is excellently illustrated, with a large amount of historical information. If anything, this, rather than the overly simplified Bible stories, is the main value of this book. Note-even the illustrations and stories are from a Christian perspective, such as the sidebar on circumcision (on a page labeled "Abraham's Two Sons"), which includes a painting of Jesus' circumcision.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|