From Publishers Weekly
After a promising debut,
Dress You Up in My Love, Stingley succumbs to the sophomore slump with this claustrophobic romantic comedy. Narrated by Cupid ("What I hate most about my job is listening to you people whine and complain that you can't find true love"), the novel follows the romance between co-workers Anna Munson and Nick Wells. On their first date, Cupid breaks the rules and prematurely shoots an arrow of true love into Anna's heart, thus transforming her into a self-sacrificing dishrag. Because he'll get in big trouble if their love lasts, Cupid must make Anna fall out of love. What follows is the book of Job as chick lit. Nick helps Cupid out by being a cad: he loses his job, moves in with Anna to save money, cheats on her, starts rapidly balding and fails to look for new work. But like most tangles with the gods, this tale has lessons. Nick, who once callously mistreated a character referred to only as "the not-particularly-promising girl," must learn to respect women and accept Anna's love. Anna must learn to stop constantly analyzing their relationship. Even Cupid comes away with surprising information about the transformative power of human love. Cupid's wisecracks, the piercing commentary on romantic anxiety and the happy ending will please some, but the book suffers from a sluggish pace and a paucity of fun.
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
In an unusual move, Cupid serves as narrator. Not the usual chubby infant, however, but rather a poor schmuck spirit, whose job it is to handle romance here on Planet Thirty-Seven. He has definitely got an opinion on how we operate, and isn't shy about expressing it. To that end, he tells the story of coworkers Nick and Anna. Nick is a love-'em-and-leave-'em ladies' man, about as deep as a puddle. Anna is a good woman who secretly longs for true love but believes there's only one chance for it. Nick and Anna go out for dinner, but he starts using his standard lines, and she is so worried about saying the wrong thing, they end up stymied. Cupid, burned out and ill-tempered, fires one of his true-love arrows at Anna. From then on, Anna is deeply in love with Nick, but he can't change his ways, causing him, Anna, and Cupid a lot of grief. Stingley's out-of-the-ordinary romance is funny and fun to read.
Maria HattonCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved